Mafia 17: Vampires

[Dangerdoll]

Hooked my casting the deciding vote is yes of course suspicious.. But I already have rationalized why and all I would be doing is reposting what I've already stated.. But unlike you I post a rational behind why I am voting a specific way. If I remember correctly in the last game (according to my notes it was post 387) where you voted for DD and broke the TIE last game where she was innocent as well.. When I questioned you on the Lame excuse you basically told me you didn't care if you thought it was lame.. Well ice the shoe is on the other foot.

You know as well as I do night one is very subjective and we all do the best that we can to come up guilty suspect in which to lynch.. I made a mistake.. So have you.. Was Bob right with his suposition that was is good enough for you is not good enough for anyone else??

You see that question mark at the end of my post? It indicated a question and I thank you for answering it. What I said to you in the last game was that if you found the "excuse" lame, I was lame because it was in fact the truth. Also that was a day or two AFTER DD was voted out. Night one is somewhat subjective, but I always remember who I am replying to.

Hey Ice... the shoe is aparently on the other foot. lol

I got that too. It's also the 2nd "little" thing I've found from you CL.... subtle things but things none the less.

 

[johnlarson66]

Well it sucks that we lost two in the first night, plus I think one was turned, so that is three the town is down.

I think KOTD could have posted a quick vote and survived a UD, I think after Wenesday the next night fall is Saturday, at least I hope, it will be hard for me to post very much.

I still think rbishop is a good suspect. I know it might not be fair, but I am pretty sure at least one of the mods is a vampire. Nothing personal.

I vote to stick a stake into rbishop

I could be convinced to change my vote, I would preffer to vote for one of the mods.

 

[Reefscape]

Well...its a real shame that Kuhli turned out to be a innocent, not good at all..one less of us to battle this stinking retched evil that lurks in our midsts..So, to confirm, is that 3 vampires on the loose now?

I am still concerned about this HN and RB thing..i dont know what it is, but, its not sitting right with me.

On the issue of a hand picked LV, i dont believe Ice would give it to a newbie who has only play one, or no previous games, as its a role that i think is complex and needs some gaming experience to carry out...so, i shall be looking to someone with a little more experience for this role...

 

[Fungi]

Why is it so slow this evening? This time yesterday Lady G was powering through the comments.
It's a shame that we lost KOTD, especially considering he might have been able to continue playing...

 

[Fungi]

On the issue of a hand picked LV, i dont believe Ice would give it to a newbie who has only play one, or no previous games, as its a role that i think is complex and needs some gaming experience to carry out...so, i shall be looking to someone with a little more experience for this role...

And by the same token, if Ice chose a more experienced player as LV, then the LV is equally unlikely to choose a newb as an acomplice, as evidenced by kuhli's death, whom many assumed was the "Little" vampire (or lV)

 

[Lady G]

IT IS NIGHT



RB-5- JL HN DD Mal Kuhli

LG-1- JM

Fungi-3- CS Rb Blue

Blue-2- Jpap LG

Kuhli-6- KOTD Jo** Niko Fungi Andi CL

Jo-Plant

**- vote was never retracted

If Kotd died an untimely death, did his vote still count?? If not did we have a tie..how was the tie decided?
Also no mention of a innocent being "turned" I assume this happened since in the rules it states nothing could stop it, but it wasn't mentioned so does this mean something DID happen?
Just a couple questions I had about night fall.

 

[Lady G]

Here's what I'm thinking (re:last nights posts)
That kind of posting is the norm for you, while abrasive, it certainly has proven to be an effective way of finding scum. I was suprised by some of Bob's posts, he seemed to become especially agitated rather quickly. Certainly what i would consider out of character for him. I do not believe the fight was staged.

While I had started to believe Ice chose a newb for LV, it would not suprise me if he selected RB again as LV. He often employs reverse psychology and may have believed we would think it too obvious.

I have a question for Chaz, you posted this right before nightfall...so are you or are you not thinking RB LV? You seem to have "suspicions" of RB from this post, yet you leave your vote with the same person RB is voting for...are you thinking he would vote for the only other Vamp in the game at this point? Did you NO he's innocent and hoped this would pull votes to him, to get him out of the way?
I don't know Chaz something about this post, it's timing and your vote don't add up?

 

[Lady G]

I quoted this post, not as a point to make specifically but as a grouped one kinda. What I have seen over the whole "blue failed to recognize my post" bit was that Pappy, you and LG have been all over Blue for this one reason for posts upon posta. I can understand where she is coming from in asking and finding it weird that you would just throw this post out there when no one had even asked. How it was done in the last game is besides the point. The bigger point of this is, I was completely railed in the last game for something little and franly, I can guess at what blue going nuts if she is innocent. I'm not protecting blue, nothing of the sort, I just find it odd that you and LG have gunned her so badly in the corner for something I consider small.... She asked why you felt the need to say it, not why are you home or why are you sick. If this was a Vamp move from you and LG, it looks a bit sloppy but worth some looking into.



My screen shows quotation marks.... I think this might be the problem with the instructions for whoever makes it up (hint, hint, HN)
/game off


You can swing by my place, King... my internet is on all day... I'll leave the key under the mat.... just make sure the dogs have water, k.
/game on

ummm.... ok, I can see the post being created in a half hour but reading up on events AND posting? You sure there was no skimming?

First DD, that one post was not the only thing I thought suspicious of Blue. But the fact of this post is she asked it, he answered and she still asked it 2 more times, not even acknowledging he answered it. Also with this post he stated he was home from school, when I said something about him and school, she said she didn't know he was a student (not exact wording) but he said it IN the post she questioned?? Plus in a game where you are questioned about "being different" I can understand why he would add that.

Sorry, but also her post pertaining to the Rb, HN "fight" she says she sees why he would react that way (defending him), last game she defended you, you were innocent...she was mafia. I am wondering if RB is innocent an she knew this, votes were building on him for her to defend him would make her "look good" if he was lynched, just like with you last game.

Then the point where she said HN "suddenly" jumped out at RB, it did not happen that way period. I believe she was connecting herself to one innocent while throwing suspicion on another. Obviously I could be wrong, I believe RB over reacted..but who hasn't.

No Vamp move on my end DD, I just found her suspicious and felt her a better vote than Kuhli so I went with it. She is posting just enough to stay noticed and not adding any of her own real thoughts. I do believe her to be Vamp..possible LV. She is for sure one I could see Ice "hand" picking.

 

[Fungi]

Sorry, but also her post pertaining to the Rb, HN "fight" she says she sees why he would react that way (defending him), last game she defended you, you were innocent...she was mafia. I am wondering if RB is innocent an she knew this, votes were building on him for her to defend him would make her "look good" if he was lynched, just like with you last game.

I wouldn't really believe that DD's vote 'saved' rb, he still had the second most votes and has suspicion clouding around his head like a swarm of bees, it'll be hard for him to fully clear his name. Why, then, if DD is the LV would she want to 'protect' rb? Unless she's buttering him up for a conversion, I don't think that's likely, one has already been turned and there's one more to go, unless he was turned overnight (unlikely after the previous episode, too much heat, I reckon) he might be turned tonight (if he was not already a vamp)... it's too confusing, all of this, but there are three vamps who'll keep on keepin' on.

 

[Reefscape]

Well, chances were slim we would nail one on the first night.

I am going to continue exploring my theory of Ice selecting a newb for LV. Even if he didn't, it doesn't seem far fetched that an experienced player would select a newb as his minion. I am going to vote for the newb with the Mod powers. Seems like a good place to start.
I vote to stake Atnixon

Care to provide more thoughts on this Charlie? or wild stab in the dark? a wild stab in the dark would be rather fitting for you as Vampires dont like the day light...Picking me to state just because i am new and a mod seems rather flimsy to me, my mod status on the forum bears no relation to the game..However, what will be will be.


Fungi...hmmmm...you seem to be going to real great lengths to profess your an innocent with the avatar and the text below your name..seems a little "overboard" to me..concerning...