Mafia #18 The Santa Game

well now Madcrawdad, what do you mean? how does this not make the topic pointless, there really is no way save sacrificing an innocent to figure out who s/he is. we will just have to wait and see I think.

because folks more interested in hunting Blitzen than scum, are themselves scummier in my eyes than those intent on actually hunting down scum....
 
because folks more interested in hunting Blitzen than scum, are themselves scummier in my eyes than those intent on actually hunting down scum....

yes...my initial point that was. You don't inspire confidence in me at all.
 
well, nightfall is in 5 1/2 hours by my reckoning - I may not be on the net between now and then so I best vote.

I vote to lynch Madcrawdad clever but unconvincing. He's just my best guess for now and I would probably prefer not to vote but I am of course obliged to.

My next prefernce is Hooked Newbie for voting me and not explaining why.

I may be on before nightfall (hopefully so) to review. I very much expect to get hit this pm but so be it - come and get me cowardly fairies.
 
I think Coler might have a point Madcrawdad, you said that hunting down Blitzen is scummier than trying to hunt down the evil elves, but you have never mentioned hunting them down yourself. Only critizing those who wanted to go after Blitzen, I think I might second Coler, only becuase that seems to weird. If I am on later also I will review. But I think I will say I vote to lynch Madcrawdad.
 
I'm not sure who i am am going to pick yet I have my suspicions but I want to read through the posts some more.
Well I'm off to petsmart to do some price matching getting at least 10 dollars off each of everything i need..Sorry dont mean to get of subject..
 
I think Coler might have a point Madcrawdad, you said that hunting down Blitzen is scummier than trying to hunt down the evil elves, but you have never mentioned hunting them down yourself. Only critizing those who wanted to go after Blitzen, I think I might second Coler, only becuase that seems to weird. If I am on later also I will review. But I think I will say I vote to lynch Madcrawdad.

Never mentioned hunting down scum, myself? You might want to do a quick reread and make sure you understand all of the posts. Hopefully this one will help jar your memory...

Here are my thoughts....

After day 3, we will know Blitzen's status (townie or scum) for sure:

- If a townie turns up dead from the Blitzen bomb, Blitzen remains an innocent.
- If no dead townie from the Blitzen bomb, Blitzen has gone to the dark side.

Either way, we'll know their status. A pre-emptive strike really doesn't make sense IMO, as we'll be looking for a townie at this point.... Makes more sense to look for scum, and let Blitzen worry about Blitzen for the time being.

Also very interesting that you'd toss a vote for me mere minutes after Coler, especially with a day-and-a-half until nightfall....
 

well, that was a lot of reading, one or two actually belly laughs, and some moments, when all i can do is go WTF?..so far hoked admitted to being and elf, and plant to santa>?>>.WTF?..
Ummm JMax, you should read more carefully before thinking I claimed to be Santa. JL said his therapist told him he would have to kill me now. Perhaps he was trying to be funny, but it sounded gruesome, so I asked if his therapist was "harboring some ill will agaist Santa." In the intro RB said this about the Grinch:

The Grinch. Completely rotten to the core. He was about to be adpoted at the local church, years ago, then that fat ole' St Nick guy just had to give a wink at the prospective parents!

So, to spell it out, I was asking JL if his therapist was the Grinch. Sorry if that made you think I was claiming to be Santa, but c'mon JM, that would have been totally stooopid of me coming out the first day and I'm not claiming to be super smart or anything, not just that stooopid.
 
Ummm JMax, you should read more carefully before thinking I claimed to be Santa. JL said his therapist told him he would have to kill me now. Perhaps he was trying to be funny, but it sounded gruesome, so I asked if his therapist was "harboring some ill will agaist Santa." In the intro RB said this about the Grinch:

The Grinch. Completely rotten to the core. He was about to be adpoted at the local church, years ago, then that fat ole' St Nick guy just had to give a wink at the prospective parents!

So, to spell it out, I was asking JL if his therapist was the Grinch. Sorry if that made you think I was claiming to be Santa, but c'mon JM, that would have been totally stooopid of me coming out the first day and I'm not claiming to be super smart or anything, not just that stooopid.

I would hope not, lol, but as i read them, it threw me for a loop, I am like wtf?..where is the game, when every one is giving away who they are, esp. santa?..
 
AquariaCentral.com