Mafia #18 The Santa Game

[Madcrawdad]

I vote to lynch Beth

Something isn't right there....

In an early post, she posts coherently enough about Coler & Clown Lover's argument being possible distancing, which says to me that she's capable of thinking logically about the game. Since then alot of posts have been nearly unreadable and illogical... Since being called on it, though, her recent posts make much more sense. What gives?

Also, the fact that twice she's either voted for me or tossed my name out on a suspect list, to be retracted both times with only the slightest of questioning. It seems like she's trying to blend in by putting suspects names out there, but doesn't have much of a reason for doing so. I mean really think about this...2x she named me as scum, and 2x when lightly questioned she turned tail and said, 'Oops...my mistake.' What's up with that?

 

[Reefscape]

^ the non vote is suspicious niko.

checking back I see JL and HN are voting for me - bit early lads no ? I hope I was at least investigated and that one person therefore has empirical proof of my innocence.

HN 'attack me like you did clown' - lol clown is still around, also it was me voted clown, and clown who attacked me...of course I respondend...read the posts my friend. if you're going to vote for me you might show us the case - I didn't vote for an innocent last night at least (not saying you did can't remember )

(as we move towards night I would like people to keep Ice's post on niko in mind tomorrow...walking away from a split vote like that...very poor town play...understandable mafia mentality - we've all done that as scum folks)

yes...rather amazingly despite the fact that I am a scumbag (according to cl) and suspicious according to jpapp (and in a small way to LG) and have 'set up a train well' according to niko...there is not a single vote on me...

...I will not be around tomorrow, will come up innocent, and no one wants to have a vote against my name...correct fairies ?

nothing from clown lover *shrug*

and nobody putting up a case for an innocent clown lover *shrug*

this makes it impossible for me to change my vote.

I predict either a landslide of votes for clown lover in the next hour, or a serious effort to run another lynch candidate.

unfortunately its late here and I will not be around for nightfall, but never let it be said I didn't give a sucker an even break.

do you really think I'm evil japp ? come on and put the vote on - won't look good when I come out as the innocent hit will it ?

My lead suspect is Coler..He has been on the defensive since the game started and has done nothing since to make me feel otherwise. All he seems to of done is egg people on to vote for him and been very blazay about it too...All he seemed to be doing was trying to get the run going on CL..

 

[charlie_stubbs]

My lead suspect is Coler..He has been on the defensive since the game started and has done nothing since to make me feel otherwise. All he seems to of done is egg people on to vote for him and been very blazay about it too...All he seemed to be doing was trying to get the run going on CL..

well, at risk of being "linked" to Coler, the majority believes CL was evil methinks.

 

[Dangerdoll]

You can almost guarantee I'm evil??? Thats a bold statement to make.
You are in damage control mode now, thats certainly apparent. Off to the chat room then, to see if your friends can help you squirm out of this.

Bold statement it is, my beloved. However, I know that if I am not lynched by the town tonight, I expect to be hit by you elves. I just woncer how you could do it to me.

DD, my main concern here isn't the cut/paste job. Early in this post you cast suspicion on Grins for not knowing about your's and Chas' virtual romance. But let's be honest, it's not like you guys are Bogie and Bacall (or Ogre and Z, for that matter ).

You end the post with a vote for Charlie. Do you think that Charlie and Grins are evil and linked?

As a side note, where the heck has Coler been? Also, sure would like to hear more from Niko before voting.

Mad, I didn't have a solid suspicion on grins, I only had a passing thought that she was using a clever tactic with her post if in fact she is. I never accused her of not knowing about Charlie and my romance, I was only thinking it was a clever post if in fact she is teamed up with him, just to make her look innocent. I am not however, sold on gher innocence or guilt at this time.

DD another question.

Your posts says that the heat isn't off Niko as a suspect but Charlie stands out more.

Is it possible that your original vote and suspicion on Niko was a distancing tactic to throw us off?

Reason I ask is that once the heat really turned onto Niko you jumped to Charlie.It was no longer a safe place for a vote.

Charlie has become the safe vote for today but close enough to suspicious that it doesn't look very much out of place.

I really think Niko has shown more evilness then Charlie has. My only suspicion on Charlie really has to do with his posts against Grins at the same time Niko was doing it. Is Charlie also a teammate? Is that why no role playing? Is it all going on off thread?

No, I still think Niko is evil but I am more sure of Charlie. What me and Charlie have is the biggest thing I have to go on. He is different than what I expect, I feel I know his subtle little ways of letting me know. Is it consciously done by him, I don't know but I can tell.
If you were to ask me this same question early yesterday, my answer probably would have been different. Today, it stands for Charlie.

minus the seal clubbing (DD would never allow that) this is what I pictured as well.

thank you Charlie you are always thinking of me

she would never have to know....tell her that they're faux seals

Now Mad, Charlie only tries to see if he can trick me in Mafia, no where else as he knows it's getting harder and harder to fool his beloved.

 

[bethkira2000]

go madcrawdad I will say this to you if I am lynched you were wrong.

 

[Blueiz]

Still voting for me Blue? still you have not posted anything to make you keep your vote on me. Even when you tried to, others could still not understand. Simple fact is, you dont have anything on me and that is quite obvious by your lack of providing anything substanial to say about me..All you do is refer to the post exchanges between myself, you and DD..If that is all you have to go, then you have a very poor case indeed.

Yes Niko, Im still voting for you. As I stated,

My vote from last night carries over to tonight. Niko has provided nothing to sway my suspicions on him.

I dont feel a need to go back and repeat all that has been said, the posts speak for themselves.

 

[Reefscape]

Yes Niko, Im still voting for you. As I stated,
I dont feel a need to go back and repeat all that has been said, the posts speak for themselves.

Obviously they dont, else you would be re-itterating your case...as it appears from you post, you dont have one..

 

[Hooked Newbie]

well, at risk of being "linked" to Coler, the majority believes CL was evil methinks.

Maybe I'm in the minority. I agree that he was acting strangely, but based on the count from Rb and my suspicions about Judge, I think he was innocent.

 

[Grins]

Quote:
Its nice to see you jump on the train with the other Grins..


If it was false infomation, then the forum was lying as the last activity times of the three members i posted where taken from your AC member pages..To be honest, i am not bothered if you belive me or not, i know the infomation was correct.

It was not correct as I was not near the computer at that time. So either the server is not accurate, you were mistaken, or you were spreading false information. As I said before I was willing to give you the benefit of the doubt at first but behavior since then makes me less inclined to do so. In fact it seems detrimental to the town to do so.

Quote:
Seems sudden? it was pointed out by someone that it was not really right to push you in that manner, so i realised this when i saw the post and appologies...Keep your vote on me, its people like you who are voting for me who will have a surprise when i show up as innocent if i get lynched, then its you's who will have egg on your faces...

You're right, I will have egg on my face it you turn out be innocent. But for now I happen to believe that you are the most guilty acting of those I suspect and I plan on keeping my vote as is.

To clarify for others, my current suspects are Niko, Beth, Coler, HN, and now DD. DD is new so I'll explain that the posting of the email signature seemed to be what others mentioned..evidence she is is in one of the groups communicating. Because that leaves a strong possibility that she could be evil I have to consider her right now.

 

[Grins]

Oh good grief this game plays with one mind does it not? Each day that goes by I end up suspecting more people not less. :thud: