Mafia #20 - Pirates of the Carribean the Play

[jpappy789]

Some little things about DD that have, together, started me to question her innocence...

wow, what a start of Day 1. I will start by saying LesChap sure does peak my interest because of the multiple finger throwing and the ability to know what he's doing this game, despite his newbie status. (I am thinking LC is a he). Some of his posts that stick out...

Although I will be available for time for the game this go around, it's been my first chance I had to get here in trying to get things ready for a brunch tomorrow, it's the only time I may be out of AC...... Beth has been acting very jumpy... perhaps paranoid, and seems to me skating on thin ice and knows it..... here is what I've found interesting:


I noticed this too and thought it was weird. What I found weirder is beth's changing it again, once it was pointed out.


here, she discusses it. She explains here that she will change it to a more holiday oriented one and then explains later in the game that she chose the dog in the hood cuter.... what happened to the Christmas tree?


Could this be protection?


how convenient, you frightenly sound Judge. Is that because you have been talking to her in chat?


IMO, regardless when you did it Beth, the point is, you did it when called out.


oh brother, this is what... the 2nd or 3rd game and you all of a sudden have newb-itis?


LMAO an OMGUS vote if I ever saw one.


and a pity post.... beth, you know that these games are not supposed to be taken to heart. Is it because people are aware of your status so soon that you are feeling you don't want to be in it anymore?


Not sure I know what "the Niko and Blue" relationship thing is supposed to be geared at. What I do notice though is how you claim not to leave LC... am I reading this wrong?






And these 3 posts... well, I think Beth finds an excuse to jump somewhere and takes the leap. There is no explanation for the retraction though.... or was it because of the mod accusation post?


OMG... Beth, are you really giving yourself away this easily?


and more desperate pointing.

here, I found some other weird posts that peaked my interest.


ummm....arggh maties???


MG... no reason?


ok, this to me sounds as if you are not interested in working with the town... got your own agenda here?



hmmm..... old nickname, judge or is it an inside joke from chat?


:headshake2:

Starts off Day 1 questioning LC's ability to play this game, no doubt something to consider, him being a newb and playing well but I honestly do not see anything wrong with that as too many times newbs slide through or get lynched because of misunderstandings. IMO it is nice to have a new player adding to the game...ok now I have rambled on my own thoughts, my point is that already DD is throwing out a name, insinuating that they are being coached, and what really is odd is that last sentence..."Some of his posts that stick out..." and then none of his posts are quoted.

calm down, it was a mistake on my part. I posted it to show I was aware of it. Looking for "anythings" to jump on, Lup, Judge, and JL?

Names 3 people who joke about her missing the red M in MG right after it happened. No one, as far as I can tell, made a big deal about it so really this post is off to me.

sorry for not getting back so quick, I am having eheim leak drama.... so I am dealing with that and trying to keep the house in shape for company tomorrow.

To answer your question, Ice. I guess I noted on Grins and not HN because I am used to HN playing like that, and his post was in response to Grins. Also, he's a long time veteran to the game and I guess I am comfortable with his sarcasm. With Grins, I am not so used to her game, when I did play with her, I didn't play long so I am not used to her wit. I am not positive that it's sarcasm or newbieness babble. I was just noting on it.


MG, why do I feel like so far all you are posting are pieces to a puzzle? Why do you keep throwing out posts like these? All it seems to me is you want people looking at you for some reason.

First paragraph on her questioning grins "choice of words" vs. not mentioning hn at all (Ice was the one who asked DD). This answer seems unsatisfying. DD, I remember you not picking up on sarcasm in the past. You are used to hn's but when grins says 'arg maties' it deserves questioning?

hmmm... in a PM, huh? Lupie, have you been PMing Grins?

DD brings Lup and Grins together. No commitment to the 'hunch'...just insinuating again.

ok... now that I am all caught up. I have no idea what the whole Gamer thing was about but I do have to say, I did consider him a pirate. I am really quite surprised that he's not.

I have to say that my two best suspects at the moment are LC and Beth. LC for know too well how to play the game and admitting to only reading through 1 game, and Beth for the accusations which seem to make little sense. On her pick on me, Beth, don't yout think it's best to find what is most suspicious about people and post your thoughts? Why condemn me for it.... to me, it makes no sense.
I also have a suspicion on Lupie because of his nothing posts... not sure what they are all about other than trying to post so that he doesn't fall onto Ice's "low post list"

For now, I am going to place my vote on beth but this is subject to change to LC or Lupie if it is going to help the town.

I vote for beth to walk the plank

Sentence in red makes absolutely no sense. How can anyone at this point in the game, Day 1, know who to switch to in order to help the town?

well, I really didn't consider myself freaking out, sorry if it came off that way. I never meant to come just at you with wondering why you are questioning my whereabouts but I do however, find it interesting that you say you remember about some sort of ehaim drama but not about the party when they were mentioned at the same post.... posts 231 as well as 455.


I wasn't intending on questioning who Lup was PMing, I was unnerved that Lup was PMing in the first place. To who? I didn't make any big deal about that or didn't intend to. My primary note was focused on that he wasd PMing in the first place. Grins... why do I have the suspicion you are a bit on edge and paranoid? Need to feed the parrot?

DD, why would people pm'ing each other point to mafia/pirate like tendencies? I think most have learned to stay away from that as a means of communication between team members. And why would your "primary" suspicion be that Lup was pm'ing? It is a feature of AC that is open for anyone to use, is it not???

my fault, in the rules, I mistook the one rule where it says "3) If you do not vote daily, then you will pass away from some strange (probably embarrassing) illness that I will give you. (see special holiday rules posting)". I thought it read that If you do not post daily and when I was reading that, I thought it was weird, but these games change everytime, so I thought ok. Then when I read that pappy won't be here tomorrow, I figured, I guess he's out then.

Interesting, why would the players of this game allow clown to have a rule where you HAD to post every day or you UD'd in the first place. The UD rule has been about voting for a long time. Weird how you somehow misread the rules...seems to me like you were looking for another reason to suspect Lup because he "wasted" a vote on me night 1.

hmmm..... where were you on night call, LC?

Another insinuation...(is that even a word?)

I am finding it quite interesting, the over posting G has been doing on RB today..... while I still find rb to be quite odd this game, I am finding it a bit questionable as well as to how hard G is pushing the envelope on him.



Ifound this interesting and worth a second look on LC for looking so deeply into the roles of the pirates. Just why are you so interested in exactly how the roles of captain/s is, LC? Is your chat room becoming confused?


I was willing to let that go until I saw this, below. Grins excuses this behavior because LC is a newbie for the game, but me, I am having a problem with it. Yeah, I might excuse someone who flubs all over the place during their first game, but LC has been pretty detailed in his findings/thoughts, acting as a real pro.... and when he does admit to editing, he still names the wrong players. Just what other posts have you "edited before anyone posted", LC?

Quite a lot of accusing going on from DD all of a sudden. For someone who admits to not being perfect in past games you are going after LC pretty hard for making mistakes DD.

all from today.... I don't know, G... you do the math. While I do consider RB one of my top suspects, maybe even my top... not yet sure, I found this behavior quite odd and seemed to see a pushing of the paper and pen...

As far as having LC come out as a PR, never in my right mind would I ever consider even thinking that, G..... not sure how you saw me questioning LC double checking the laws of the Captain to saying he held a power role. If anything, I thought that was showing he was/is more captain than anything, checking on the role and trying to put it out there that this is the way it goes. Not a wise move either way if you ask me. What I find even worse is you putting that thought out there for the pirates to double think that thought if by chance LC is a power role as opposed to Captain.

Gosh Lupie, I hope things aren't that bad for you *hugs* If they are, know that you will get through it and you have us to help hold you up you if you need it.

I read over LG"s posts and IMO I do not find her pushing for rb's lynch at all. She defends herself and questions him.

And then the whole captain thing...which has been pointed out already.


So these are my thoughts on DD atm. Basically threw a bunch of names out there at first and then starts attacking LC (after a few questioning posts) and LG (almost out of no where) today after two of her other suspects ended up innocent. I guess I could say DD is my top right now.

 

[jpappy789]

DDs 1st post of the game









So going back and reading all 22 of DDs post at this time I see she also jumped on LC for being to good of a newb to play at his level.

She made a really good case for Beth, but can't really hold it against her, or can I?

LC and Beth were both suspects but Beth got her vote. Did she not want to be the 1st one on the LC train?

In post 458 DD brings up that Grin is claiming DD skimmed.

Well read posts 256- 266 and you guys decide if it was a justifiable question.

Post 619 again DD is pushing for LC. I think if a couple of innocents would have jumped to LC to make it closer then DD would have switched. LC is much more a threat to them then Beth was and it would have been easy to restart a train on Beth the following night.

I was going to bring this up in my post but forgot so thanks ICe for reminding me...what I didnt like was the way DD phrased her resposne to grins..."and just to note, Grins, you have the nerve to question whether I am skimming??"

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Well, it looks like I'll have to place my vote tonight or sneak home for lunch tomorrow. If I do make a switch, it will be between 5 & 6 EST and I'm leary of a change that late unless somethng dramatic happens. Right now, I'm leaning towards voting for Rb but I also am tempted to vote for JM or DD to keep them on the radar. I'll place a vote before bed tonight. I'd really like to see more from JM and DD, but I think they might be in hiding now.

/Game off
I have a CL find to pick up tomorrow evening. http://atlanta.craigslist.org/for/512289944.html
:grinyes:
/Game on

 

[Rbishop]

Malbri....good posts...be sure to tell those who are coaching you they did well.

Now come up with some original thoughts....

 

[jpappy789]

rb your two posts today have not added any thoughts at all...care to share anything not assicoiated with LG?

 

[Rbishop]

Seems several of you are overly concerned about my vote on judge. Would you have preferred me to be on Beth?

You are right, several others had lower post counts than judge. I never said I was voting for the LOWEST poster. At the time of my vote on judge, she had posted absolutely nothing but fluff and she is a better player than that.

In fact, so many of you seemed to be concerned about it, it causes me to have deep concerns about you. Need to protect an associate...?

I vote to make Judgemax walk the plank....

 

[Rbishop]

rb your two posts today have not added any thoughts at all...care to share anything not assicoiated with LG?

Don't skim, jpap...

 

[Rbishop]

My two posts today, per your count probabaly equal your two posts for all of day one....

 

[Rbishop]

As you stated early, I don't care about the real life issues....just you laying low.....

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Don't skim, jpap...

My two posts today, per your count probabaly equal your two posts for all of day one....

Rb- Jpap has definitely not added much up to this point, but his points this evening seem to be pretty valid. Why so defensive? Do you in fact have any thoughts or are you content to just post in defense? Why are you solely concerned about post count? (You may need to add some more smily only posts to bump up your count). You also seem to go back and forth whenever convenient on whether or not RL issues are valid reasons for not posting. I for one would like to see your thoughts on people.