Mafia #21 Cabin Fever- The Play

[IceH2O]

I also think that Ogre could have some sort of role, not sure of what one either.

Okay I pulled this from earlier.

What if Ogre is the Don. In reality the Madman would want the Don gone by banishment since he can't kill him. The Don does nothing for the madman and after night 4 is really a liability.

I believe if JL UDs the game ends.

I'm going to retract my vote on Cory and vote to banish JL

 

[Rbishop]

Wow, quite the night....

About 10 hours to go until nightfall...

Still no post or vote from JJ21...

Since I don't see a tally from jpappy or any announcements, either he hasn't seen the supposed PMs (probably due to his PM box being full) or we are being suckered in to folks quitting.

Here is what I have for votes:

cory (1) by Mg 103

Lchap (4) by Lady 164 mal 183 jdge 184 DD 217

Mg (3) by Lchp 160 Ogre 192 cory 195

malbri (2) by Rb 186 beth 210

ogre (1) by clwn 292

jens (1) by bkw 303

bkw (1) by jens 322

ice (1) by jl66 374

jl66 (2) by hk 385 ice 411


Cory voted Ice in #372 and Ogre voted Ice in #355, but I didn't see a vote retraction by either of them.

Jpappy...you need to wake up and let us know some things....

 

[clown-lover]

Wow.. Interesting evening.. Well if Ogre is the Don it will be very telling.. However with what has transpired I don't think voting for someone that has said they are going to UD at this point is worth a vote until Jpap ultimately lets us know what he is going to do... There is no rule that states that you can't threaten to UD and use it as an in game tactic. I do agree however that JL's abnormal RP is quite different than anything than I've seen from him in the past. I will state however that if he doesn't UD between now and nightfall my vote will resoundly sit on him tomorrow.

While I believe that HN and ICE are better players than to reveal their roles I do question the motivation behind what has transpired. Is it a deflection move to get people to change their votes? Is there truth in those posts? Of what exactly I am not sure, but I'm not willing to blindly follow along with their reasoning either. I have more than once been led by the nose by both of these guys.

I find it more interesting that after I posted that JL jumped in and said that Ogre could be a role and now ICE is also using that info.

As of this point we don't know anything about anyone.. Other than there are a whole lot of innocents and only 1 true bad guy. With no investigations as of yet no one can be certain of anyone.

My list is as follows (In no particular order)

JL - Roll Playing more than he has in the past and as HN or ICE said it is completely out of character for him to RP that much, that UD statement (tactic or no?) and overall defensiveness after HN vote.

ICE - I finding it completely odd that ICE would Roll Play at all. He says that he has RP'd before well I wasn't part of that game and do find this completely out of character for him to do so.

RB - He hasn't answered my question about how he could know that Lchap was innocent with the conviction of that one post. While he's not at the top of the radar he is on the radar...

So for now
I retract my vote on Ogre and vote to Banish ICE

 

[clown-lover]

That should read "Isn't worth a vote" vs "is worth a vote"

 

[clown-lover]

And I need to add

JM - for coming to ICE's defense after I questioned his posting of that one song that she had mentioned.

 

[Rbishop]

I thought I had answered, Clown, back in post #224, but I can see how it looked like I was only talking to DD.

It was really just a shot back at Lchap's previous post about it being a pity he was going to be banished. With 14 folks against a Madman and an Accomplice, you can claim just about anybody is innocent by the odds, but there isn't enough info available, yet, to say it with any conviction, by anybody.

This has to be the longest day one, without much to go on.

I'll be glad when Jpappy gets off his duff and responds to last nights activity, if he needs to, since hooked and jl could just be BS'ing us.

 

[clown-lover]

I thought I had answered, Clown, back in post #224, but I can see how it looked like I was only talking to DD.

It was really just a shot back at Lchap's previous post about it being a pity he was going to be banished. With 14 folks against a Madman and an Accomplice, you can claim just about anybody is innocent by the odds, but there isn't enough info available, yet, to say it with any conviction, by anybody.

This has to be the longest day one, without much to go on.

I'll be glad when Jpappy gets off his duff and responds to last nights activity, if he needs to, since hooked and jl could just be BS'ing us.

Ok, understand but realize that you are still above a neutral at this point because of that post.. I won't lead a charge to put you on the chopping block yet..

I also agree that Jpap needs to answer some questions about what has transpired, unfortunately I cannot be here during the day and won't be back until after nightfall occurs. So my vote is going to have to stay.

 

[Malbri]

lol Rbi you're impatient. The insanity started right after he left chat last night, he probably went to bed and hasn't gotten up yet

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I thought I had answered, Clown, back in post #224, but I can see how it looked like I was only talking to DD.

It was really just a shot back at Lchap's previous post about it being a pity he was going to be banished. With 14 folks against a Madman and an Accomplice, you can claim just about anybody is innocent by the odds, but there isn't enough info available, yet, to say it with any conviction, by anybody.

This has to be the longest day one, without much to go on.

I'll be glad when Jpappy gets off his duff and responds to last nights activity, if he needs to, since hooked and jl could just be BS'ing us.

I'm not BS'ing. Like I said, IF JL quits I'll bow out too. I thought it was a game and was treating it as such. If my play offends or upsets people, I'll go away. I'd rather have a clear concious than try to play in a way that's not me.

 

[Rbishop]

no offense taken by me, hooked.