MAFIA 22: Who is who?

[IceH2O]

Now why would you need to boost your post count jpap???



I thought you had stated earlier emo that you had read the disclaimer line.. Skimmers are always mafia.. I'm thinking Jpap might be onto something with his little joke here..

BTW noticed that Grins was on last night when I was browsing the salty forums but she didn't post here.. Compared to how aggressively she played her last couple of games I find that wierd.. So that makes me wonder if she is playing as in the sign up thread she did state that she hadn't said she was in.. (Kind of like how Jpapy ropped me into his game as well.. I hadn't said I was in either but he was skimming his own sign up thread )

ICE can you confirm if Grins is playing or not??? I don't want my vote to be wasted..

Well now you know she is playing lol.



Hey guys, I have ALL your IM names too, remember that as you click onto craigslist.

 

[Lady G]

Was it me? No, guess not . Actually, I'm happy I get to have one more "baseline" game as just another innocent...it'll keep everyone guessing for the one game when I actually do get picked to play Mafia.

Oh, well Lchap I'm so glad you posted that you are just another innocent again...now I can take you off my list of suspected baddies, ummmmmm NOT!

 

[Lady G]

Well now you know she is playing lol.



Hey guys, I have ALL your IM names too, remember that as you click onto craigslist.

Ummm, what IM name Ice????

And IS Niko playing, I didn't see him on the list of players??

 

[Grins]

oooohhhh tell us Grins....please some of us don't know

No way, what if you're evil. I mean you'd be the perfect person to make evil I'm thinking. I feel less inclined to vote for you to be lynched because I feel bad about the target someone must have placed on you at one time. What if Ice thought the same way and then made you one of the mafia to toy with us all?

 

[jpappy789]

I'd just like to remind you that there's a 50/50 shot you are evil.

Man, if the teams didn't know who each other were, I'd say we got us a team right there. MG, Emo, and jpappy. distancing, arguing, constant and nearly instant posting... it's like they were in a chat room or something.

But Ice would never do that to us :uhoh:

I was bored last night...er this morning I guess it was. It was fun poking at emo but I think he might have slipped.

Now why would you need to boost your post count jpap???its a joke:silly:



I thought you had stated earlier emo that you had read the disclaimer line.. Skimmers are always mafia.. I'm thinking Jpap might be onto something with his little joke here..

BTW noticed that Grins was on last night when I was browsing the salty forums but she didn't post here.. Compared to how aggressively she played her last couple of games I find that wierd.. So that makes me wonder if she is playing as in the sign up thread she did state that she hadn't said she was in.. (Kind of like how Jpapy ropped me into his game as well.. I hadn't said I was in either but he was skimming his own sign up thread )

ICE can you confirm if Grins is playing or not??? I don't want my vote to be wasted..

Haha...well I assumed you wanted to play because you kept asking questions about the rules. You couldnt resit anyways!

And emo...it was joking at first but now I wonder if he really is evil. That whole skimming thing is odd.

well, i think, emokid, mg and jpap, had a field day in the thread, and nothing to substantial has yet happened, ..So,i will wait and see what this afternoon brings, ..

I also agree, that Ice has tweaked the who's who, in this game...(pun intended)

AH-HA!! I knew if I waited long enough, I would find a clear answer and how clever as to make Pappy evil this go around!!! Gotcha Pap!!

as

Psh...trying to delflect attention back at me DD after I put you own my list. How evil of you.

crap... hit send too quick... holy crap and a triple post.... eeh..... an unassociated mod needs to delete the 2 extra posts...

I was saying as far as the whole emo vs. pappy thing, not sure if I'm buying it...

What is there to buy DD? I was joking with emo at first and then he slipped, or I guess I think he did as I dont really know for sure. Seems typical evilness from you DD...pop in and not really pick a side but just mention the dispute so it doesnt look like you are completely noncommital...hmmm

Well let's take a look at who Ice would have tweaked into what role...

First the playerlist:


Well first lets look at the Unknowns...These are people who haven't played Mafia before, and so we (And Ice) have no clue how they'll react. I doubt Ice would place either of them in the Boss slot, but he MIGHT have used them for the hitman/police; unlikely but possible:
CT
Emo

The Oldtimers. These are players who are vets at Mafia, from what I've gathered. I still haven't read more then one game before I began playing, but it seems these are the people that have played at least 5 games. Ice would know how they'll react and do in any roles, and many of them are the first to be investigated:
Jpap
HN
LG
Clown
JM
RB
Grins
Ogre
Bkw
DD
Cory

I noticed the list above seems to include just about everyone...of these, who usually stays off the radar, and who is always in the limelight? I don't have enough background to say, but they may have been given a role.

The Novices. These are the players like myself who have played a few games, enought to get a slight feel for, but still haven't been in enough games to show everything they got:
Mg
LC
Beth

Ice may have given someone in the Novice list a PR...maybe as an experiement to help him guage them in future games, maybe as a chance to watch them shine. I also realize that I'm in this list, and well...kinda scares me to be getting that much attention again...I swear I was about to be lynched 3 nights in a row last game, and I only survived two...if the Madman hadn't hit me, I'm sure Ice would have had the town on me.

Of the novice list, everyone BUT Beth has had a PR (as far as I'm aware). IF Ice is running a little experiement, he'd prolly give a role to Beth...

This is all crazy LG analysis of the game, Day 1 style...I'm just trying to start to get into Ice's head, and think how he does, so we can figure out where he gave the roles. I think that the teams are random, and the only thing he did was tweak the PRs...so let's figure this out.

I'm going to keep my vote on RB for the time being...no reason for it being there, but no reason to move it. I can't wait till I'm investigated, and on a communicating team. I hate being paranoid of everyone...it's too much like work. :lipssealedsmilie:

Ummm Lchap, Beth was the Doc last game. I am surpised that she didnt even catch that...hmmm I am starting to like my first list:grinyes:

Crap, I thought this started on Thursday. Sorry guys I've had a killer migraine for the past day and a half. Going to try and catch up.

suuuure ya did grins... I still think you are the mafia boss lol...

thanks for pointing that out


um, seem like you know the stept o the game, it's like you've been spying and collecting data, this might be the work of a mafia.:grinyes::silly:

of course you would agree emo...trying to latch on to someone else's doubt of me? diverting attention again emo?

 

[Lady G]

Crap, I thought this started on Thursday. Sorry guys I've had a killer migraine for the past day and a half. Going to try and catch up.

Grins, so are you saying you DID NOT get your PM yesterday when you logged in and was posting in the Salty forum???

 

[jpappy789]

weird Grins...why did you think Thursday? Unless I missed something I dont remember that ever being mentioned in the sign up...

 

[Lady G]

Hey, Pap...I wore blue for you today....no not a dress but blue non the less

 

[Grins]

And emo...it was joking at first but now I wonder if he really is evil. That whole skimming thing is odd.

Ask HN about my theory of the word "skimming" during the pirate game.

 

[jpappy789]

Hey, Pap...I wore blue for you today....no not a dress but blue non the less

:silly::silly::silly:

You are sooooo evil...