Not just making a big deal about it, but also seemingly 'innocently floating' ideas out there in hopes that someone else might run with them...
But, in a nutshell, you've got it correct, Beth.
Mafia #23 Revenge
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
Not just making a big deal about it, but also seemingly 'innocently floating' ideas out there in hopes that someone else might run with them...
But, in a nutshell, you've got it correct, Beth.
That is the way I have read the post as well Beth.. But its not the first time she has done this in this game.
This is part two I think lot of people may be right that Grins' style is off and Mad pointed out an example. Do I think Ice was defending her and that they are a team, its possible i suppose. I don't see enough evidence to support that yet.
When the whole Ogre post thing happened I thought it was odd the way she answered not sure if that made her Mafia, but it is making me think. AS to Ice being Mafia for "defending" her, not enough to support that yet either. Ice is another player like Ogre who wouldn't post an obvious "tell".
Mafiameter:
jdge-8
mal-8
mad-6
ogre-6
clown-6
lchp-6
ice-5
blue-5
hn-5
bkw-5
joan-5
cool-5
grns-5
mad-6
lady-4
DD-4
emo-4
beth-4
ILB-3
Reasons for the extremes: Mal and judgemax...don't think I have to say anything there lol. ILB, I truly think she is a newb innocent, her posts just don't seem mafia'ish' to me, but thats MO.
And looky grins, this time theres a 5 point gap :grinyes: Now I deserve a bon-bon...lol
Top suspects:
judge-Craziness. Someone flustered her and since then she has went on the defense. I do think she is mafia.
mal-More craziness. Weird behavior, way to many posts to quote lol And I do also think she is mafia.
mad-Gut feeling.
ogre-IMHO, I still think that that thing Ogre said was suspicious, is it suspicious enough to get my vote today? No.
lchap-You sure know how to get the ladies mad.....
Your game play is NOT helping the town much....please start posting more.
Matt
jdge-8
mal-8
mad-6
ogre-6
clown-6
lchp-6
ice-5
blue-5
hn-5
bkw-5
joan-5
cool-5
grns-5
mad-6
lady-4
DD-4
emo-4
beth-4
ILB-3
Reasons for the extremes: Mal and judgemax...don't think I have to say anything there lol. ILB, I truly think she is a newb innocent, her posts just don't seem mafia'ish' to me, but thats MO.
And looky grins, this time theres a 5 point gap :grinyes: Now I deserve a bon-bon...lol
Top suspects:
judge-Craziness. Someone flustered her and since then she has went on the defense. I do think she is mafia.
mal-More craziness. Weird behavior, way to many posts to quote lol And I do also think she is mafia.
mad-Gut feeling.
ogre-IMHO, I still think that that thing Ogre said was suspicious, is it suspicious enough to get my vote today? No.
lchap-You sure know how to get the ladies mad.....
Your game play is NOT helping the town much....please start posting more.
Matt
CL, your list is interesting in that it goes from High (mafia) down to Low (innocent), right? You gave me a '6' which means slightly mafia. Okay. Notice that you've got me listed with the higher mafia folks, but you've also got me listed with the lower townie folks.... This says to me that at some point while formulating the post that you might have had me lower toward townie on your list.... What's that about? A little unusual isn't it?
Ugh, I think I have strep. I feel like crap so going to make this as quick as I can.
lady: innocent, her posts seem to be just as they always are when she is innocent. The only possible oddity I'm seeing is her reduced amount of posting but that could just be real life issues.
ogre: innocent. I agreed with Cory's question of leaving out the word "just" in that now infamous quote but I don't have a problem with how you answered it when you found the question.
hook: innocent. Although he has proven to others that he is clever enough to pull of acting like an innocent mafia, I don't see anything that gives me reason to believe he isn't innocent day one.
blue: innocent. She is hard to read though because she is good at acting innocent when she is mafia, I learned that in my first game. However, I can't understand her saying I edited a post or even which one she is suggesting I did that to. Not only did I not edit anything, I had no reason to. Maybe a case of her multitasking and being confused?
clown: neutral. I am having a really hard time reading clown. At one point he seems mafia for his hostilty towards a few posters and then the next he seems focused and level headed. I will probably not have a clearer idea on him until day 2. Clown, I can see where you missed it in the flurry of posting yesterday but I asked what line of questioning you think I avoided in the first part of the game. I sincerely don't see where I missed something.
DD: innocent. I've noticed things she does when she is mafia and I'm not seeing them this game.
emo: innocent. If he were mafia I'd think that his teammate would be dragging his butt out of AC chat to participate.
cory: innocent. I'm not seeing the mafia tells I saw from him last game. He appears helpful when posting this time as well.
lchp: neutral. I don't like your game play this time around at all. Something Clown said in a recent post however has me hoping he is right about you and you're just being a foolish townie this time around. Please be the helpful LC you can be when innocent if you are indeed so.
ILB: neutral. Don't know her and find her posts strange but maybe it is just her way of having fun in the game. Since she is a newbie I don't feel confident enough to have her leaning in any direction right now.
beth: innocent. I don't see anything to point to her being mafia yet.
bkw: neutral. I just don't have a ton to work with on his posts.
joan: neutral. Again, don't have a ton to work with here.
mad: mafia. I don't believe for a second that he found JM's actions yesterday to be believable and he is perhaps trying to protect his teammate by avoiding what many saw as crazy behavior by her.
jdge: mafia. Puhleez woman, please. :silly:
mal: mafia. If she isn't mafia she has gone stir in the Maine winters.
king: innocent. No matter how much Mal doesn't get that, I do.
Z: innocent. Again, obvious at this point in the game.
That makes my highest mafia suspects at this point in the game Mad, JM and Mal. The most obvious mafia for me in that group would be JM. So I retract my vote on LC and vote to lynch JM.
lady: innocent, her posts seem to be just as they always are when she is innocent. The only possible oddity I'm seeing is her reduced amount of posting but that could just be real life issues.
ogre: innocent. I agreed with Cory's question of leaving out the word "just" in that now infamous quote but I don't have a problem with how you answered it when you found the question.
hook: innocent. Although he has proven to others that he is clever enough to pull of acting like an innocent mafia, I don't see anything that gives me reason to believe he isn't innocent day one.
blue: innocent. She is hard to read though because she is good at acting innocent when she is mafia, I learned that in my first game. However, I can't understand her saying I edited a post or even which one she is suggesting I did that to. Not only did I not edit anything, I had no reason to. Maybe a case of her multitasking and being confused?
clown: neutral. I am having a really hard time reading clown. At one point he seems mafia for his hostilty towards a few posters and then the next he seems focused and level headed. I will probably not have a clearer idea on him until day 2. Clown, I can see where you missed it in the flurry of posting yesterday but I asked what line of questioning you think I avoided in the first part of the game. I sincerely don't see where I missed something.
DD: innocent. I've noticed things she does when she is mafia and I'm not seeing them this game.
emo: innocent. If he were mafia I'd think that his teammate would be dragging his butt out of AC chat to participate.
cory: innocent. I'm not seeing the mafia tells I saw from him last game. He appears helpful when posting this time as well.
lchp: neutral. I don't like your game play this time around at all. Something Clown said in a recent post however has me hoping he is right about you and you're just being a foolish townie this time around. Please be the helpful LC you can be when innocent if you are indeed so.
ILB: neutral. Don't know her and find her posts strange but maybe it is just her way of having fun in the game. Since she is a newbie I don't feel confident enough to have her leaning in any direction right now.
beth: innocent. I don't see anything to point to her being mafia yet.
bkw: neutral. I just don't have a ton to work with on his posts.
joan: neutral. Again, don't have a ton to work with here.
mad: mafia. I don't believe for a second that he found JM's actions yesterday to be believable and he is perhaps trying to protect his teammate by avoiding what many saw as crazy behavior by her.
jdge: mafia. Puhleez woman, please. :silly:
mal: mafia. If she isn't mafia she has gone stir in the Maine winters.
king: innocent. No matter how much Mal doesn't get that, I do.
Z: innocent. Again, obvious at this point in the game.
That makes my highest mafia suspects at this point in the game Mad, JM and Mal. The most obvious mafia for me in that group would be JM. So I retract my vote on LC and vote to lynch JM.
No confusion here grins. I would have never quoted what you said and asked "Huh?" if I had not questioned why you were refferring to UDing while quoting me. I dont do things absentmindedly, and I know better than to not pay attention to what I post. So... dont try and send out expalnations on my behalf, I KNOW what I saw.
The only other explanation if you in fact did not edit your post, which I dont believe, is something screwy went on because so many posts were being made at the same time. Doubt that tho.
I said I agreed with Judge's assessment that there didn't appear to be anything malicious in Ogre's comment. Apparently you also agree with that assessment, now.
Why she felt that she needed to keep addressing the issue (before Ogre did) is her own doing, not mine.
The fact that you again try to link me to Judge makes me feel pretty good with my vote.
