Mafia #23 Revenge

[judgemax]

which is what is worrying me

Because your not included in that sentiment?..

 

[judgemax]

Okay I am here sorry RL was horrible yesterday, things went wrong, I am catching up now.

Hope things are better.

 

[OgreMkV]

lady: good lord, i hate to say it, but I feel she has to be innocent!

ogre: I don't know, i felt he was innocent at first, But since nightfall, we haven't seen a whole lot from him. I HAVE HIM AT NEAUTRAL

hook: Well, i hate to say it, because I know things are crazy for him right now, However, I miss my aggressive HN,I have him leaning slightly mafia.

ice: WELL, i think he is mafia, .I think he defended grins, and logically in my mind, I could see grins choosing him, as one of her minions. This is also why i feel HN could be mafia, i see no issues with Grins choosing him.

blue: I don't know, She seems to be a little aggressive, but If i remember correctly,she was like that in several games, and was mafia and Innocent, so i don't think its a tell, .however, she is a little higher on my list as well.

clown: WTF?..seriously, I am now mafia, ..?..so, ..are you grins other choice then?..

DD: DD where are you?..You are usually much more involved, and haven't really posted anything, your just as bad at being bad, as me, ..I think, she may be mafia.


emo: I don't think emo is mafia, I think, he got bored with the game, ..i think, he started playing because he thought it was cool, and has now decided, as kids are apt to do, that its to much work, to actually pay attention.

cory: where are you?.. is teh game not fun enough for you?..did you guys decide that its not what you thought? that it takes to much work?..
I do have him as innocent, because that is why i feel he isn't playing. He has no role, and is bored.

lchp: I know this sounds crazy as well, but i think LC is posting less, and acting so different, because he is bored being innocent..JMHO, ..its giving him teh attention, so, he is continuing, .no "fame" in being just another innocent..

ILB: INNOCENT

beth: I believe beth is kinda in the same boat as cool, she will be a stellar pl;ayer in time, but you guys are intimidating, ( myself included ) we really do get a little nasty sometimes, (all of the vets, and i am also including grins ) I think, she is trying, and again, i think she is innocent.

bkw: I don't actually know?.

joan: WTF , ..next time, drink at home! seriously! !!!! INNOCENT DR.

cool: I will atleast give you some credit, whether or not your posts are helpful, you have atleast been a little more involved, .I think he is innocent, I think this, because, he is young, and a novice, and face it guys, you guys can be intimidating, and, I think, he is coming up with his odd ideas, just so he can "try" and help.

grns: You my don, are mafia..

mad:i have him leaning innocent

jdge: i am innocent

mal: well? WTF mal?.. I hope, ..you continue to play, and I really hope you read like ten games, before you do so. P.S. RB is going to kill you and ILB for those **** after death posts, roflmfao!

king: Well, I think, he is playing in true king style, which makes me want to put him mafia, ..as you guys say about me, ..so true also, about him. he is always evil.

Z: glad to have ya back! he seems to have rejuvenated himself with his long hiatus, .I think, he was def one of the players, that keeps the board full, I also have him leaning innocent at this point.


these are my opinions, and observations. not saying everyone i have as mafia is mafia, not saying everyone i have as innocent ( myself excluded) is innocent, ..i do however feel, that i have good reason, for thinking what i am.

Note a few things. Could her reference to grins be a freudian slip? Notice how JMax has implicated both Ice and Hooked as being team mates with Grins.

IMO, this makes her seem more innocent OR we are totally off on who the general consensus is on mafia. I know Ice has been mentioned several times as a possible as has Grins. If JMax if mafia, the only reason to push them, is she's on the other team. But she seems very sure of herself (as she is want to do).

The other note is bkw. Everyone gets something but him... could he be on a team with Jmax?

It just seems, when I'm noticing things in posts, bkw keeps popping up for me. Not enough to call mafia, but it is curious.

WoooHOOO, i am whimsical!

seriously, I almost hate playing these games anymore, Because you all always think i am mafia, and no matter what I do, i will always be mafia, ..I tried questioning something i thought wrong, and basically got railroaded into being a " communicating mafia" because Of ices PARANOID delusions. Lets face it, according to ICE I was defending "my buddy" ogre, then my DON mal, and I was distancing from her, then , when that didn't pan out he immediately switched to the fact that i am hooked to someone else, I believe that he insinuated that it was MAD?..OR bkw, Yet the whole time, he was defending grins, who jumped right behind him, like the pied piper was blowing bob bons out of his pipe. so, if you guys really want to get technical, whether i acted like an idiot or not, ..you have way better suspects than me, ..right in your face, yet, because you are all so **** close minded, and refuse to believe I could be innocent in one game, ..you actually forget to focus on some one who is doing something shady. hence the reason i said to just lynch me, ..at that point we could have afforded to loose me as an innocent, and you guys would have actually looked at other stuff, rather then harping on me having a good time with a stupid situation.

This post really makes me think JMax is more mafia than innocent.

I vote to lynch Jmax. The result of this lynch may tell us a lot about teaming at this point.

 

[clown-lover]

Well because of something else done in this thread again.. I can't afford to make a mistake so I'm going back on my vote AGAIN... You guys could turn me into an alcoholic really easy you know that...

I retract my vote on LesbianChap and vote to Lynch JudgeMax

 

[KingOfTheDeep]

And I never proclaimed him or you innocent. I said with him leaning innocent but yet undecided on both of you..

i got that part, i just don't see how anyone could have him leaning innocent right now, he's playing the game like he always does, even whe he's evil he is still quite active..vote tallys..questioning..lists..it's all the same whether he's innocent or evil.

 

[judgemax]

Note a few things. Could her reference to grins be a freudian slip? Notice how JMax has implicated both Ice and Hooked as being team mates with Grins.no, no Freudians slip, ..it was a play on you my dear, ..i was being my stupid sarcastic self. i thought about how it actually looked afterwards , however, No editing, so whatever.

IMO, this makes her seem more innocent OR we are totally off on who the general consensus is on mafia. I know Ice has been mentioned several times as a possible as has Grins. If JMax if mafia, the only reason to push them, is she's on the other team. But she seems very sure of herself (as she is want to do).who me?..

The other note is bkw. Everyone gets something but him... could he be on a team with Jmax?Because i honestly have no clue with him?..

It just seems, when I'm noticing things in posts, bkw keeps popping up for me. Not enough to call mafia, but it is curious.



This post really makes me think JMax is more mafia than innocent.

I vote to lynch Jmax. The result of this lynch may tell us a lot about teaming at this point.

I agree, and that was my point day one, I am an innocent, and have no problem, putting myself up there, and being lynched, if it helps the town, If the town wins, I win, regardless, and because of the interactions with me, ..i think, you could learn alot, once you all KNOW i am innocent. i wasn't trying to be mellow dramatic.

 

[ZSandmann]

Because she is my internet friend, I don't put a game ahead of a friend.

Grins, like I said, I don't always go on what people post, I go on my gut partly. Thats my playing style...ask other people if you feel you have to verify that.

Who said I'm not considering them? If I wasn't considering them they would be a 1. A 4 means I'm thinking they are innocent, but am not sure.

Matt

Cory, this is a game. Do you let people beat you at checkers or tic-tac-toe because they are your friend? Remember the last lines of the rules, in this game you will be accused and called a liar, don't take it personal. I am friends with other in this game but if I believe they are Mafia I will call them out, and I will see them lynched. And gut feelings are fine, but don't try to convince me of a player's guilt based on gut. Use your gut to lead you to investigate a person more closely, then find posts, slips, and facts. I can't think that you actually believe what you say here, so it makes me believe you are possibly Mafia trying to sway us with emotion.

I think that most people have come to the conclusion that emo will not be joining us much this game. This presents kind of a problem, as if the guy doesn't post, his status can only be guessed at.

I think that at some point, the town will need to address the issue, as based upon his single last-minute vote yesterday he doesn't plan on UDing.

Everyone keep in mind that lynching non-producing newbies has typically not gone in the town's favor, so lynching Emo is risky. But if it's going to be done, earlier is probably the better time to do it just to put an end to the distraction.

I myself would prefer to give him another chance to UD, and if that doesn't work, then deal with him. Thoughts?

I agree Mad, my vote was in hopes he would be drawn out. I figured if he cared enough to place that last minute vote he would be here on day 2 to add to the game. He is posting elsewhere on the board and he was in the chatroom. So I can now only assume he is choosing not to play. I wish he would pm Bob and bow out but it looks like he will have to UD or be removed via lynching. If he saves late again, I will not hesitate to vote him first thing on day 3.

Well there are technically "two" CLs..Clown and Cory...Maybe he was refering to Cory instead? At least you're not looking at JM anymore. I'm starting to think more and more that she's innocent. You still got at least one player on there that's wrong.

Anyways, I'm going to retract my vote for Emo in the hopes that he UDs. After that, I'm going to vote to lynch Blue. Why? Day 1 she was too quiet, even for her, then the clue RB left in the night posts, and now she's gotten too defensive over simple questions. She seems like a good suspect, and if we get a 2-way spread I'd like to see her in it.

Part of interest bolded by me (not the votes). This is the second time I have seen you make a post where you use a present tense declaration of certainty in regards to another player. Before you said CL IS Mafia. Now you state that Ice has got at least one person on his list wrong. Which makes it appear you believe his list IS correct otherwise. If you know something I don't please enlighten me, all my suspects are shades of gray, I only wish I could see the game in black and white.

 

[judgemax]

shoot, i replied in red to his red! ..hold on, ..i will fix that. not by edit either!

 

[LesbianChap]

I'll telling you guys, I can't support this lynch-train on JM.

 

[clown-lover]

i got that part, i just don't see how anyone could have him leaning innocent right now, he's playing the game like he always does, even whe he's evil he is still quite active..vote tallys..questioning..lists..it's all the same whether he's innocent or evil.

Ok so help me here.. I said earlier that I believe that you two are hard to read.. If he should be leaning mafia are there any inconsistancies that you have seen in his play that should make you think so..