Actually it was stated (by me) it could mean Clown or Cory...I didn't say you, in that post at all.
Think like me, and say the three of you??? I actually said, Grins, Clown and Cool. Where do you get I was say the three of you???
Mafia #23 Revenge
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
Actually it was stated (by me) it could mean Clown or Cory...I didn't say you, in that post at all.
Think like me, and say the three of you??? I actually said, Grins, Clown and Cool. Where do you get I was say the three of you???
Good, question there!!! I don't see how ANYONE can say they think Jmax is INNOCENT, I could see someone MAYBE lowering her or saying she is looking more innocent (if they felt that way), but to come out and say you think she is innocent...why? I admit, I have looked at her twice...at points wondering maybe she is just being Jmax...but I think she is mafia.
Well it was a "trap" of sorts...some of my "on the wall" suspects are posting, and I figured an innocent would have caught it quicker then a Mafia...maybe even change their vote when they did. However, no one jumped on it and it reveals little.
anyways, if you lynch someone else, and they hit me, you'll have a 10-15% better chance of lynching a Mafia then if you lynch me or JM...but then if they hit JM, ya'll will be after me. If they hit me, JM will be clear.
BTW, the Detective role will STILL be valueable to the Mafia team with him after the PRs have been revealed...the way I'm reading the rules, his is the only role that can investigate someone of the -other- Mafia team and get a "Mafia" result. I know if I were them, I'd find that really valuable.
anyways, if you lynch someone else, and they hit me, you'll have a 10-15% better chance of lynching a Mafia then if you lynch me or JM...but then if they hit JM, ya'll will be after me. If they hit me, JM will be clear.
BTW, the Detective role will STILL be valueable to the Mafia team with him after the PRs have been revealed...the way I'm reading the rules, his is the only role that can investigate someone of the -other- Mafia team and get a "Mafia" result. I know if I were them, I'd find that really valuable.
okay now I got it, sorry I had forgotten that point to, which makes me want to vote him. With that:
I retract my vote on Grins
I vote to Lynch LC
Looks like your minds are set. I just hope they don't hit JM tonight...at least some good will come of this.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
seems some quotes popped into my post....
Quote:
I continue to hear more about secrets being held in people coming to their decisions and frankly, am finding it extremely Mafia-ish for folks to keep saying "I have this secret" or "I noticed this and will say what I suspected later".... either you are bluffing or you are holding things from us. If you are trying to help us, why keep things to yourself. And for the excuse already used in this game, the excuse that "so I can use it for other game", I think by Clownie, is a load of crap.... sorry clownie... if you can use it, we could. Bottom line is, you are withholding information that could be beneficial to finding the mafia.
Quote:
I continue to hear more about secrets being held in people coming to their decisions and frankly, am finding it extremely Mafia-ish for folks to keep saying "I have this secret" or "I noticed this and will say what I suspected later".... either you are bluffing or you are holding things from us. If you are trying to help us, why keep things to yourself. And for the excuse already used in this game, the excuse that "so I can use it for other game", I think by Clownie, is a load of crap.... sorry clownie... if you can use it, we could. Bottom line is, you are withholding information that could be beneficial to finding the mafia.
This whole LC coming out as/was the Det just throws me for a loop. I don't care about his a,b,c it just doesn't make sense no matter how you slice it. Because if he is the Det. and Mafia why would he come out to "save" Jmax, or at least say she is innocent?
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
Quote:
Originally Posted by LesbianChap
When have I ever played subtly? Even my first game apparently Grins and HN were going crazy trying to subdue me...apparently it's not in me. I've been a top suspect, and nothing I do seems to stop that, so I've got some information and I'm trying to make the best I can with it...
Here's how it goes tonight:
A) Lynch me, they hit JM...the town loses two innocents and probably the game.
B) Lynch someone else, they hit me...the town knows at least one person is innocent, and have a better chance of lynching an innocent.
C) Lynch JM, they hit me...the town still loses two innocents and probably the game.
D) Lynch JM, they hit someone else...I'm top suspect tomorrow.
E) Lynch me, they hit someone else...JM is clear tomorrow.
F) Lynch someone else, they hit someone else...both me and JM are top suspects.
Those are the scenarios. Personally I'm prefering that B happens, but that'll require Mafia cooperation and since I've posted this, I doubt it'll happen now...so the best I can hope for is E...but I doubt that'll happen either. What will prolly happen is A unless the lynch changes...
Originally Posted by LesbianChap
When have I ever played subtly? Even my first game apparently Grins and HN were going crazy trying to subdue me...apparently it's not in me. I've been a top suspect, and nothing I do seems to stop that, so I've got some information and I'm trying to make the best I can with it...
Here's how it goes tonight:
A) Lynch me, they hit JM...the town loses two innocents and probably the game.
B) Lynch someone else, they hit me...the town knows at least one person is innocent, and have a better chance of lynching an innocent.
C) Lynch JM, they hit me...the town still loses two innocents and probably the game.
D) Lynch JM, they hit someone else...I'm top suspect tomorrow.
E) Lynch me, they hit someone else...JM is clear tomorrow.
F) Lynch someone else, they hit someone else...both me and JM are top suspects.
Those are the scenarios. Personally I'm prefering that B happens, but that'll require Mafia cooperation and since I've posted this, I doubt it'll happen now...so the best I can hope for is E...but I doubt that'll happen either. What will prolly happen is A unless the lynch changes...
ummm..... so this post was meant to provoke people to do what?
Well, I was going to say I hope you are not trying to say you are the Detective/Doctor team...since the Doc is dead...but I see, you were trying to say you "were" the Doctor.
I'm sorry Lchap, as nice as it would be to believe you, I don't. There would be no reason for RB to "change' ppls roles. We have played games when our Dr and Detect. were both killed and I just do not think a mod would do that.
