Mafia #26: Roadside Picnic the Game

[bethkira2000]

I haven't fallen out of the game I wasn't able to be on yesterday and I thought that I Ud'd because I didn't see that nightfall was tonight.

 

[OgreMkV]

I vote to toss Jensons into the zone. I know, I initially thought her innocent because she stood up for me. On the other hand, that would have been a perfect alibi for the future. "Hey look, I said Ogre was innocent and he was, so I must be innocent."

It was a good play and it had me on the sympathy part, but there seems to be too many people noticing too many things for her to innocent.

 

[bethkira2000]

Cory I am sorry that I voted for you, I should have switched my vote, I just don't like voting for Newbies on the first day, and you seemed like the best candidate. I will take full responsability for my vote.

 

[plantling]

Doctor, help me!!!!!!!!

I voted Ice because he voted for me, is turning people against me, all on very little evidence. I post like a known innocent because as far as I am concerned, I am. If I post like I have something to hide then it's time to be concerned. As far as pm'ing out of the game, if I did that, then we lose an innocent and that is definitely not in the best interest of the town. I will keep up with reading when I can and won't miss a nightfall. Please, calling this a "scummy play" is rather rude and hurtful. I am comfortable with Ice being a Stalker. It's not entirely an OMGUS. If i have time, i'll make a case later.

I can't help but wonder if you're asking for the doctor's protection because you want your target to be clear for a hit tonight. Also you would have looked less scummy if you had made a case against Ice before or while you voted him.

Okay first things first I didn't say she was a mafia, the "so" was supposed to be a "do" as in Do I think she is mafia possible. a Typo nothin gmore or less. Do i wish I had switched my vote to her as I was thinking of doing yes I should have.

Well now you say it's a typo and maybe it is. However you've been pretty quiet so now I'd like to hear who you suspect.

 

[Lady G]

Another thought that probably doesn't mean too much with Grace being dead....but I wonder if the Stalkers knew the win criteria from the beginning? If they didn't get it in the game PM they may have asked for it from Z. With her being a newb, maybe that was a reason she felt the mil ops were evil and inappropriately commented on them.

For her to do it twice still leads me to believe that the stalker team isn't cohesive and communicating well, or they could have stopped her from doing it a second time.

That really is a good point there, RB and if they aren't communicating well, then I bet we will see many more slip ups.

Doctor, help me!!!!!!!!

I voted Ice because he voted for me, is turning people against me, all on very little evidence. I post like a known innocent because as far as I am concerned, I am. If I post like I have something to hide then it's time to be concerned. As far as pm'ing out of the game, if I did that, then we lose an innocent and that is definitely not in the best interest of the town. I will keep up with reading when I can and won't miss a nightfall. Please, calling this a "scummy play" is rather rude and hurtful. I am comfortable with Ice being a Stalker. It's not entirely an OMGUS. If i have time, i'll make a case later.

Are you flat out asking the Dr to protect you here Jensons??

As far as your vote for Ice you said in the vote itself it was a OMGUS vote, how could you expect people NOT to react to that, you have played this game plenty and know how that can be a very anti-town move. Now that people are reacting to your vote, you say you have a case....why did you not make your case when you voted him instead of just saying OMGUS???

Who said you were PMing outside the game?? I looked back, and in less I missed it..the only refrence to PMs was made by RB, and it had nothing to do with you, it was about Grace.

Wait am I still alive?

Yes, Beth you are still alive...how would you not be still alive??? We haven't had nightfall yet.

 

[bethkira2000]

That Nightfall was incredibly satisfying. Yay us! =) Grace, thank you ever so much for slipping up for us. I do hope that you will play again, afterall you aren't the first "scum" to give themselves away.

My scumdar is going off on Beth (there's alarm bells ringing from her for me, but I can't quite nail it. I went back and reread her posts and there really isn't too terribly much substance to go on. I can see what appears to be her throwing around names of people that others mentioned as suspicious, defending newbies, and trying to look helpful when she's not really contributing anything)...but that's just what I see, it could be that she's just a follower and prone to going with the flow to stay in the game longer...I am not familiar with her style, which makes it difficult for me to be sure.

My theory at this moment is that Ice is an innocent, and LG is a stalker and she's following him around. I also am inclined to believe Jensons is innocent, and LG is trying to distance herself and latch onto Ice.

This other new person, Enya, I am still concerned about that vote on Ogre after most people backed off since the case against him was proven to be invalid. Bears watching, but not sure if they are evil or just too busy to keep up with the sick kid (which I empathize with, my son's been sick too).

I don't think Corylover is a stalker...I don't think Ogre is a stalker.

Coler...well he seems to have disappeared, I wouldn't trust him as far as I could throw him and definitely going to be keeping an eye on him, if he posts again.

RB...not sure, I could be convinced either way to be honest.

HN...also really not sure, I could see him going either way.

JM, Jpap, JL, BKW, Plant...I am inclined to believe they are innocent until proven guilty.

That gives me for a list, 2 that are probably stalkers (Beth & LG)...1 possible (Enya), and a few maybes (Coler, RB & HN).

If I was to name the remaining 5 stalkers it would be: Beth, LG, Enya, Coler and RB.

I know I don't have a lot of posts this game, but I hope that you can all see I am aiming for quality > quantity with my limited time.

I vote to toss Beth into the zone

You know it was day1, I watch thte posts if I see something then I post about it, I am not really a "burn the house down" day 1 kinda player. Mostly on Day1 people do make mistakes as in this case, but usually it is fun, and people just start to get into the game. I become more aggresive as the game moves on.

 

[Swayde]

You know it was day1, I watch thte posts if I see something then I post about it, I am not really a "burn the house down" day 1 kinda player. Mostly on Day1 people do make mistakes as in this case, but usually it is fun, and people just start to get into the game. I become more aggresive as the game moves on.

We'll see. I specifically said in that post....

but that's just what I see, it could be that she's just a follower and prone to going with the flow to stay in the game longer...I am not familiar with her style, which makes it difficult for me to be sure.

And it seems to me nobody has stepped up to defend you at all, however, several people that seem to be helpful to the town do indeed agree that you seem scummy.

I am glad to see you posting. I hope that you manage to get your opinions in on people before nightfall because as of this moment, you've given me no reason to change my vote or my opinion of you.

 

[bethkira2000]

Thats Okay Swayde, I am here now.
jensons-I see the case for you being a Stalker, the early innocent banner waving really bothers me, I did it in my second game and i was mafia then.

Cory-you could still be a stalker, but right now you haven't do anything to scream stalker. you are one to watch

RB-leaning innocent atm

Jpap-nothing screams mafia leaning innocent,

Ice-I am so tired of not being able to figure you out,

HN- Your "typo" still bothers me. You have played to many of these games to make such an obvious mistake. You are leaning stalker

Lady G- you are a good player, you also blend in sometimes too. You could be stalker, you have my eye atm

Swayde-you are leaning innocent atm, I have no idea how to read you, but so far you have been a great help to our town.

Coler-no idea if your even still here

Enya-I don't know

Ogre-I gave you the benefit of the doubt about your "incident" but I know how you play, you are leaning stalker

Beth-I know me

Bk-you are undecided for me.

These are all the thoughts I have for now, I only found out I was still alive an hour ago. So forgive me if I have forgotten anyone, and this is in no order, and will change.

 

[bethkira2000]

Kay I hate to ask this of you Lady G, but were you skimming? I gave an explanation in post #401, as to why I would ask If I was still alive. Which in fact came after I asked the question, so why would you ask that?

 

[bethkira2000]

I vote to toss Lady G into the zone
subject to change