Mafia #26: Roadside Picnic the Game

[Hooked Newbie]

WTH, kill me for vote hopping if you want. I've been feeling uneasy about my vote so I'm going with my first instinct.

I retract my vote for Ice and vote to throw Judgemax into the zone.

 

[jpappy789]

well, honestly, i think it was a mistake, and generally, i use the tones from other posts to judge whether it was a sinister mistake or not. the description of this game has some inconsistencies,and frankly, i am somewhat confused by this scheme myself, ..so, i am not jumping on a band wagon, just because its there, i still have twenty four hours to decide where my vote is best suited, .. so, thats why i have not voted OGRE yet.

At this point, the only one other than Ice that I'd be ok voting for is Judgemax. If we can get a consensus, I'll move my vote. I'm having some second thoughts about Ice as well, but it's a coin flip between the 2 right now for me. Our suspects seem very similar and we have the numbers right now to leverage by working together.

Jpap- thanks for the compliments (I think) and yes, I have had an "off ganme". I've been admitting it for several days now. Look back on my posts in comparison to your's. I was actually a bit worried about you because you were posting very similar thoughts and I was worried about you being evil and trying to attach yourself (like I did with Ice last game). If you aren't, we're of like mind. To say that I'm playing like Ogre is wrong though. Look at the post counts, the suspect lists, etc. Where's he been? Who are is suspects? And the key question to me... Why did Z save him? I actually thought he might be the Doc until Jensons posted the heal post. When will the docs learn to not hint huh? lol

Ok, ok...bad comparison. Your posts are a lot more helpful than Ogres, which really isnt saying a whole lot...

Funny:silly:

 

[jpappy789]

ok, jmax's post was not supposed to be there...my bad...

 

[Rbishop]

So is this how its going to be for the next 24 hours? At least start working on your suspects case for when I'm found innocent. Don't waste the next 24 hours.

I've been spending some time reading the 1st days events. Especially the role play. With knowing LG Grace and Coler were mafia and actually have posts to read you can see Ogres name thrown around a lot.

Coler was pretty protective of Ogre while bashing Cory.

LG flipped back and forth on him. She said something about me and RB should work together and we might figure something out.

Ogre says he thinks me and RB are innocents.I believe twice in fact.I vote Ogre on a slip and he OMGUS votes me.

So I'm figuring Ogre is a stalker and RB and Cory are for sure clear.

At this point I think Ogre and JM are both stalkers.

Yeah re reading the 1st days events I came to a different conclusion also. I'm just trying to put out as many scenarios as possible. The more put out and squashed the easier it will be to narrow the field. Might even force a stalker into slipping.

You guys being quiet isn't helping the town.You're all giving the Stalkers time to get a plan together. You need to keep the pressure on them.

OK reading further into the day as it ends and the start of Day 2 I'm thinking Ogre might not be a stalker. Him and LG go after one another pretty hard and Ogre even puts her on his list.

Reading further into Day 2 I'm starting to feel that the stalker team is JM and Bkw. Tough to tell though as neither has posted much. I'm basically having to go by the thoughts of the people I think are innocent.

I agree with you Ice, that we need to look ahead, but this last group of posting from you reinforces my thoughts on you. I could be wrong and you are an innocent; it is always a possibility in these games.

However, I only see these posts by you, to throw out as many different thoughts as possible to confuse folks and get them to change their votes.

Depending on the results of your impending lynch, my leanings are towards judge or Ogre.

 

[IceH2O]

I agree with you Ice, that we need to look ahead, but this last group of posting from you reinforces my thoughts on you. I could be wrong and you are an innocent; it is always a possibility in these games.

However, I only see these posts by you, to throw out as many different thoughts as possible to confuse folks and get them to change their votes.

Depending on the results of your impending lynch, my leanings are towards judge or Ogre.

Thats fine as I said I don't want anyone to believe me until they see the night fall thats says I'm innocent. I don't want to be saved and have people still doubting me and having the focus taken off the real stalkers.

I do find it strange though that you say you are still looking at Ogre. If you re read the thread you can see that Ogre and LG went at it pretty hard before LG was outed. I think this clears him.

I was pretty tired last night as I decided to just focus on 1 person at a time to disqualify them from being a stalker. As I said right now its JM and Bkw that stand out the most.

 

[IceH2O]

So far I feel that the innocents are:

Sway
Cory
RB
Ogre
HN
JL
Jpap
Ice

In order of who I think is stalker


JM
Beth
Bkw

Still think Beth has a good shot at being a stalker. I don't know what Sway is looking at but at the time of Beths vote for LG there was no going after by LG except 1 simple question that drew Beths vote. Now after LG was outed they did go at it pretty hard,but it could have been distancing.

JM is for sure scummy as per her vote and reasoning on HN and her wanting to protect Ogre then asking why everyone all of a sudden thinks he is innocent.

Bkw the only thing I really see on him is knowing or I should say quickly trusting Plantling as being a known innocent.

 

[IceH2O]

Sounds good Z...

Regarding Ice's comments on Beth/Lg:

Beth did vote Lg early and after swayde came out with the investigation result it would have been very scummy for her to switch.But at the same time Jensons had a nice train going as well, yet Beth put out the Lady G vote. When Beth came back asking if she was still alive, Lg put some heavy pressure on her. Lady G is an aggressive player but not so much when scum as you can see with this game. I don't think they would have risked that much distancing when Beth was already looking pretty suspicious to quite a few people at the time because of her lack of imput. I would be very suprised if Beth turned out stalker as well.

Again where do you see heavy pressure? It wasn't until after the night fall that LG went hard after Beth.

Why not jump on LG? What would her vote on Jensons do? If she was a stalker and knew Jensons was the Dr it looks good she didn't end up on her.

Her vote for LG I believe was for distancing and when Sway came out it blew that plan out of the water. They had no choice then to go after 1 another to distance Beth from LG.

Eh basically I've done all I can till after night fall. I've put out what I thought and if you guys go back and read you might see the same thing. I stand by my 3 choices and in the order they are.

 

[Rbishop]

My only concern with Ogre is that could have been some initial distancing, then the turn of events with the UDs..and that still nagging issue over the number of stalkers.

 

[IceH2O]

My only concern with Ogre is that could have been some initial distancing, then the turn of events with the UDs..and that still nagging issue over the number of stalkers.

I could see that, it bothered me that he acted as if he knew we were both innocents and his quietness lately is disturbing.

I had a pretty good feeling on him as posted a bit earlier. The only reason I discounted it was because he put LG on his list and they went at it before Sway outed LG. I guess if I'm going to put Beth on the list for that reason Ogre should be there as well.

 

[johnlarson66]

WTH, kill me for vote hopping if you want. I've been feeling uneasy about my vote so I'm going with my first instinct.

I retract my vote for Ice and vote to throw Judgemax into the zone.

I am going to keep my vote where it is on Ice. I think Judgemax can wait until the next day.