Mafia #28: The Play

You know guys, I am looking back through posts and noticing alot from Ice...also both DD and "Huggie" were worried about him, and the way he nit picked at DD about her "inconsistence", yes...she made herself look bad the way she worded it and I thought her to be mafia also. Then I think again BOTH MM and DD were innocent yet he wanted to pick on me for my MM vote instead of DD...if he was Mafia, I'm not sure he would of cared so much which I voted for, unless he was just trying to get me to look bad in some way to use against me later in the game?

I'm just thinking out loud here..both newbs voting for Ice worries me also, not exactly sure why but Ice is a hard one to go after for vets...let alone newbs. This is going to sound "out there" but could anyone see Ice being on a team with them and having them vote him to help them later?

Lets see what about Ice, Jmax, Zig and Live?????

Yes...something about RB is buggin me too, but he is another that many times I was positive to be Mafia and he was innocent, so I'm not sure where I put him at this time.
 
IceH2O
Lady G
rbishop
ZSandmann
Cory Lover
Swayde
Hooked Newbie aka Huggie Bear-Known innocent
Reefscape (Niko)-Known innocent (DR)
The Zigman
johnlarson
LiveoutLoud
Dangerdoll-Known innocent
Judgemax
Mee-mee-Known innocent
charile_stubbs

I wish we knew how many Mafia there are...we are down to 11 players and all lost were innocents..
 
ZSandmann said:
I had expected more people to be posting but I guess a lot ran off for the night. I get home from work at 5:30 so I need to vote now in order to be safe from UD. I will hopefully find time tomorrow at lunch to post and see what others think.

I vote to lynch LOL (again).

Other suspects,
John
Swayde
And now I have to add Ice to the list based on DD and HN. I'm not solid on this will look back tomorrow.
Click to expand...

Can you tell me what it is about John and Swayde that have you worried Z?? More then a "feeling"...as your feeling on Niko was wrong...
 
That was pretty a prettysucky nightfall, late as it was. Sorry DD, but your posts were the best I had to go on for Day one.

Guess the UDs are becoming the most consitent thing in these games.

Not sure if I will be able toreview and poat before this early nightfall.

Best guess for now is......

I vote to Lynch Cory Lover...
 
The fact that JM didn't vote for Rb when she could have pushed him to the front for good and her lack of voting for me when thats who she wanted to vote for kind of seals the deal for me.

I can live with she didn't see RB as bad because I didn't either.But I still don't get why she thought a vote for me at the time of her vote would have been a waste. I would have placed my vote on who I thought was the mafia player, not on someone I wasn't sure of being mafia.

The rules don't say anything about the Don having investigations so its not really important to get the Don this game,as long as they are mafia we are good.

I know I said I'd vote RB for HN and DD but more and more I feel as though I have to vote JM based on my thoughts above

I retract off RB and vote to lynch JM. Either is a good vote IMO and I will go back to RB if not enough see JM as a threat.

Zig and Live, you need to start talking. Suspects and why you think so.

Z, I don't get why Sway and John are suspects to you and why JM isn't? Care to explain and help us see what you see?

Charlie who are your suspects, we know you voted LOL but that can't be the only person you are looking at.

We need to be right, its either 6-5 right now or 7-4. If there are only 4 mafia then we have a night we can be wrong. If its 6-5 then if we lynch wrong its game over.Hopefully someone was granted the DR role and they protect the correct person tonight from the hit. That would also buy us another day.
 
IceH2O said:
So then why didn't you vote me?

At the time of your vote it was:

Ice 1
RB 3
Cory 1
Live 2
DD 2

You would have moved me 1 away from tying RB and put me in a tie with DD and Live. Who knows what would have happened? A vote my way and a good explanation might have shifted others to me.

Weak excuse if you ask me, you should always vote who you think is mafia and only swap if needed to another mafia suspect.At the time of your vote you could have gone to me no problem. Did you go to DD to protect RB?
Click to expand...

No, not hardly. I did what i felt i had to do, i also stated why i did what i did. I am not perfect, and am content with where my vote now lies, if your innocent, then I will gladly look otherwise, but i feel there was more to the exchange between you and hooked than you are willing to admit. Thats just my personal opinion, and i am sticking to it this time.
 
IceH2O said:
The fact that JM didn't vote for Rb when she could have pushed him to the front for good and her lack of voting for me when thats who she wanted to vote for kind of seals the deal for me.

I can live with she didn't see RB as bad because I didn't either.But I still don't get why she thought a vote for me at the time of her vote would have been a waste. I would have placed my vote on who I thought was the mafia player, not on someone I wasn't sure of being mafia.

The rules don't say anything about the Don having investigations so its not really important to get the Don this game,as long as they are mafia we are good.

I know I said I'd vote RB for HN and DD but more and more I feel as though I have to vote JM based on my thoughts above

I retract off RB and vote to lynch JM. Either is a good vote IMO and I will go back to RB if not enough see JM as a threat.

Zig and Live, you need to start talking. Suspects and why you think so.

Z, I don't get why Sway and John are suspects to you and why JM isn't? Care to explain and help us see what you see?

Charlie who are your suspects, we know you voted LOL but that can't be the only person you are looking at.

We need to be right, its either 6-5 right now or 7-4. If there are only 4 mafia then we have a night we can be wrong. If its 6-5 then if we lynch wrong its game over.Hopefully someone was granted the DR role and they protect the correct person tonight from the hit. That would also buy us another day.
Click to expand...

ICE???? i am shocked, you pulling an OMGUS vote?..are you really that worried about my influence that you feel the need to try and get me lynched?...
 
Man that was a painful Nightfall to read over =/ I don't know about ya'll, but I'd really like to see us ease up or get rid of the UD, it's a bummer being down 4 people after the first nightfall when we're having trouble getting people to play as it is.

Anyhow, on to my thoughts.

Rb, I really am not seeing anything to make me think you are not mafia

Ice, Up until I read your last post, #375 which I pretty much agree with 100%, I was going to vote for you because of the 2 "mistakes" you made regarding me, and how hard it seemed to me you went after DD. So now I am just not sure about you.

The Zigman, coming in at the last minute and throwing out a vote with no reasons looks really suspicious, if you are a townie I hope that you will show yourself to be more helpful today, otherwise you are going to be a very likely mafia candidate for me.

LG, this is probably the first game I've been in with LG that I don't have a bad feeling about her, which feels really strange. So I am leaning her innocent, but I am watching because you do have a habit of being quite tricky.

ZS, I thought you were being a little too quiet, but I wasn't very suspicious, however you've got my attention now. Why do you suspect me? Why do you suspect JL? I would really appreciate some more info from you.

JL, I haven't seen anything that screams mafia to me from JL, which is why I am suspicious of ZS now.

LOL, I do not get a feeling that she is mafia, no bells going off there for me. I just get a regular old newbie player vibe.

CL, I do not see whatever it is that JL sees. It does look to me like RB is following JL's lead though, which is understandable since JL seems most likely a townie to me, but that doesn't mean RB isn't mafia trying to follow a safe townie. So I am not comfortable with a vote there at this time.

JM, she's said some strange things, namely that post commenting on the don in a pm and I haven't noticed her being very helpful. So I do see why she's a suspect, however, I am not comfortable voting on her with Ice sitting there.

CS, I am growing very suspicious of CS. He hasn't been any help to the town and he's been very laid back. I would consider placing a vote on him.

I will have time throughout the day to check in on the game. So my vote can be changed if I feel it needs to. My husband will be working a littler later than normal today as well so I should even be able to make it for nightfall.

I vote to lynch Rbishop.
 
Tried top post a minute ago.. not sure what happened.
I forgot about the game, and was out of town. I got back home with only minutes to vote. not having enough time to read up on the happenings here, I had to make a hasty decision. I voted at the last minute, only to avoid an UD. I knew Ice wouldnt get enough votes to be lynched, thats why I voted for ice (sorry man).I didnt want to hang someone without being sure they were evil.
Sorry for the confusion. I'll try to catch up today.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom