Mafia #32 LMAO

OK Vote count

Mseckman - (1) catfish 877 (retract 904) wingnut 890 Judge 885 (retract 907) Cnote 886 (retract 904)
DriverColerme - Msceckman 897 (1)
Wingnut - (3) catfish 904 Cnote 906 Judgemax 907

2 to vote. That would be me and fish. I hope you guys (catfish & Cnote) are ready to hop your votes around if necessary guys. Do you like your company at the moment (noting JM is on with you ? Who is your second candidate ?)

I stress I'm not exonerating wing nut at all - you've seen me all over him/her too. But lets take this one very carefully. I was reasonably comfortable until now.
 
I always have a hard time reading Judge. She doesn't post a lot most games and so it's not so easy. I admit her posts appear scummy this round.

Driver, what happened to your suspicions on Wing-nut?

Catfish if you want we can go back to MsEckmann and so we'll have one more day to decide about Wing. I'm still looking over her early posts.
 
OK i have really thought this one through for the las few hours. The only way to solve this problem is if you trust me Cnote we need to play it down to 2 people again and see if we get a jumper. i know we have 7 people but if everyone wants to claim town so be it. here is how it goes


the vote on Wing - driver/coler, Cnote, MS

the vote on Ms- wing, fish, judge

I will set on you Cnote and when people jump i will be ready does this sound fair to the town. because these are 2 people i believe could be mafia
 
see anyone who can vote as the town requests is suspect and i believe this is the best for the town. just tell me if its good or bad and we can get into position.
 
It might be overthinking it a bit cat...I mean what for instance if both are innocent.

The way I see it now, Judge is kinda stuck because she first hit on MS having named Wing as top suspect (and after others had voted MS), and then jumped onto Wing for the asking. I find it hard to see this as pro-town voting, its more like self-preservation.

That said, perhaps the thing to do is look at who the other mafia is/could be. I don't think Judge can swap of Wing now without looking hella scummy. Leave Wing out of it and lets settle on who the remaining scumbag is. Get a few votes on there (mine and fish being unvoted yet) and it might get interesting.

I'm finding it hard to pair Wing with anyone at the moment - thoughts on who ?

Again I stress I'm not exonerating wing. In fairness I voted them Night 1 and have been banging on and into them for the last while.

(as an aside our real problem iat this stage of the game is two lynches in a row without any information gained)
 
When I say leave wing out of it, I mean forget them for the moment (the votes are on so they're covered) and lets think of who could be their partner.
 
lol if both are innocent qed me and fish are the scumbags. I just am not sure that this is the best set-up just yet.
 
I won't move my vote again, I only followed, because I assumed that we were trying to get everyone to vote for one votee. I think, MS, and wings are guilty. I have no problem voting either one.

WHEN have any of you not thought I was posting awfully scummy in any round of mafia?..
if i post little, or post lots. Coler, ..I am the new you, even when I am innocent, I am guilty.( although, I must admit, G is giving me a run for my money now!~:)
 
Well coler her is how the chips fall for me. I have look at this.


[AC] Driver8- ALIVE - N1wing, N2 ZS, N3 ogre, N4 ogre N5 MS
[AC] wing nut- ALIVE - N1 LG, N2 ZS, N3 Jens, N4 ogre N5 Driver
mseckman- ALIVE- N1 ZS, N2 Pix, N3 Ogre, N4 Ogre N5 MS
judge- ALIVE -N1 Wg, N2 Wg, N3 Ogre, N4 ogre N5 DD
fish34- ALIVE - N1 LG, N2 ZS, N3 Ogre, N4 Ogre N5 DD

These are who i have to vote for. One of these 5 people. With you claiming innocent and i do believe you to an extent. that leaves 4 and with fish voting 4 outta 5 nights for mafia i believe shes innocent. that leaves me 3. Now im down to three and i believe that if we pick 2 outta those three we have a 33% chance of hitting the mafia and thats dang good in my book. even if we get an innocent and they hit another that will leave it down to 3 too 2 innocents. IMO its either judge wing or MS there is no doubt in my mind.
 
catfish69hunter said:
Well coler her is how the chips fall for me. I have look at this.


[AC] Driver8- ALIVE - N1wing, N2 ZS, N3 ogre, N4 ogre N5 MS
[AC] wing nut- ALIVE - N1 LG, N2 ZS, N3 Jens, N4 ogre N5 Driver
mseckman- ALIVE- N1 ZS, N2 Pix, N3 Ogre, N4 Ogre N5 MS
judge- ALIVE -N1 Wg, N2 Wg, N3 Ogre, N4 ogre N5 DD
fish34- ALIVE - N1 LG, N2 ZS, N3 Ogre, N4 Ogre N5 DD

These are who i have to vote for. One of these 5 people. With you claiming innocent and i do believe you to an extent. that leaves 4 and with fish voting 4 outta 5 nights for mafia i believe shes innocent. that leaves me 3. Now im down to three and i believe that if we pick 2 outta those three we have a 33% chance of hitting the mafia and thats dang good in my book. even if we get an innocent and they hit another that will leave it down to 3 too 2 innocents. IMO its either judge wing or MS there is no doubt in my mind.
Click to expand...

well, if wings is guilty, wouldn't that make me voting out mafia everynight?..
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom