Mafia 34-Time Crisis(the Play)

[Chill]

Maybe...I'm just mystified as to why you stating 17 made him think up a detailed response quoting exact numbers of evil, sniper and turn. When I read it I just thought you were referring to what I thought was the 3 players who haven't posted yet. 20-3=17.

The other thing that does not make sense about it is he read your post which said 17 and posted about 16 players. Sounds like he's guilty of the same thing. Oh well...maybe I'm just reading to much into his post. What do you guys think?

No not sure where I came up with the number but that wasn't it.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Dawg how do you get that he was talking about 17 players that have posted so far from that quote?

Because I thought it was mentioned that 3 people had still not posted to this point. I assumed that's what he was referring to. I thought it was a joke. Then I read his response which says that he just plain made a mistake and confirmed it was not a joke...and it made me think twice.

I can see why Chill would be on your radar right now, but am curious as to why Ice is..... he's the one that brought the thought to the front in the first place.

Maybe it is because I am newer to this game...but the detail Ice shows in his response as to specific numbers of evil and the sniper vs 16 innocent made me think about his response. Seems like he could have received a PM from BKW which stated the same numbers. When I read Chill's question I had absolutely no idea what the ratios might be. Possibly because the only game he and I have previously played started with a lone evil.

Then again it would be pretty dumb for an evil to state the exact numbers in his post. This game even gets you to second guess yourself...never mind the other players.

 

[jpappy789]

Because I thought it was mentioned that 3 people had still not posted to this point. I assumed that's what he was referring to. I thought it was a joke. Then I read his response which says that he just plain made a mistake and confirmed it was not a joke...and it made me think twice.



Maybe it is because I am newer to this game...but the detail Ice shows in his response as to specific numbers of evil and the sniper vs 16 innocent made me think about his response. Seems like he could have received a PM from BKW which stated the same numbers. When I read Chill's question I had absolutely no idea what the ratios might be. Possibly because the only game he and I have previously played started with a lone evil.

Then again it would be pretty dumb for an evil to state the exact numbers in his post. This game even gets you to second guess yourself...never mind the other players.

deja vu...remember all when ogre (i think) got grilled because he posted numbers of evils but he was innocent?

I think this is something that will turn out in a wrong lynching...it always does. Unless chill trips up again I dont see a good reason to warrant a vote on him

 

[Chill]

Well Dawg this one is a team game and the dynamics will probably be different. Group votes should be interesting. I expect there will be some teaming up. If I am lynched it will be good to remember who jumped on this when I turn up innocent.

 

[IceH2O]

Ice how do you KNOW that chill wasn't including the sniper? How do you come to the absolute conclusion that he automatically subtracted 3 from the overall list and forgot that the sniper was really on his side???...it was a nice find but it seems like you keep trying to push this without any clear proof.

I don't know he wasn't counting the sniper. I hope if he is a terrorist that he was so its 1 less person to have to look for. I was just going by numbers that a total of 3 terrorist plus a turn wouldn't be enough versus a SWAT team and Dr. I guess I automatically see this stuff from a modding viewpoint.

 

[OgreMkV]

I'm never a fan of lynching for the sake of lynching. However I would like to know the odds of hitting a bad guy and that's why I asked.

Then ask about the odds of hitting a bad guy. That explains why you want something. It's waaay less suspicious that way.

The odds, are approximately zero because the bad guys are constantly trying to make other people look suspicious and jump on anything that an innocent says that looks suspicious.

That's why innocents have to be very careful what they say and how they say it.

That's why I'm not counting Ice as innocent for questioning this. He's too aggressive and good a player too miss something like that and take advantage of it as good or evil.

Ice how do you KNOW that chill wasn't including the sniper? How do you come to the absolute conclusion that he automatically subtracted 3 from the overall list and forgot that the sniper was really on his side???...it was a nice find but it seems like you keep trying to push this without any clear proof.

So you think that Ice could definitely NOT be a terrorist because he questioned Chill?

See above, but it's my opinion, that and $5.95 will get you a cup of coffee at Starbucks.

 

[jpappy789]

I don't know he wasn't counting the sniper. I hope if he is a terrorist that he was so its 1 less person to have to look for. I was just going by numbers that a total of 3 terrorist plus a turn wouldn't be enough versus a SWAT team and Dr. I guess I automatically see this stuff from a modding viewpoint.

So basically you are going on a hunch that chill accidentally slipped by revealing the number of his teammates because he misread a post and stated that there were less players than there are?

 

[jpappy789]

Thanks Ogre for answering for DD...

 

[OgreMkV]

DD can still respond. She's saying the opposite of what I think. So, what up DD?

 

[ZSandmann]

Holy cow, three pages already? I was out of town this weekend and didn't think the new round would be ready so quickly. I am not going to have much time tonight so I will read to try and catch up. So don't lynch me