Mafia 37 (35?) 50/50

[AC] scoop411;1506205 said:
Ok, In a matter of 10 mins you go from wanting to lynch NJ to retracting your vote. Why? My thoughts are as follows

1) This could have been distancing so it looked good. That way later you could have claimed you knew she was evil when she got lynched.

-OR-

2) You were told by LG that you needed to get off NJ because there are plans for her.

-OR-

3) I'm just an idiot following a dead trail.

So which one is it? My bet is number 2
Click to expand...

LOL, you are funny that is one thing you have going for you! I don't think I've ever told anyone what to do in a game before...so that made me laugh.

I retract my vote on Hooked
 
Day 1

Scoop -1- Z (11)

Dawg-2- HN(30) NJ(35)

NJ-1- Dawg(34) Chill(50) DD(57)

HN-1- LG(37)Dawg(63)

RB-1- Scoop(47)

DD-1- Ogre(61)

5 no votes: RB* Fire* JC* Chill* JM*

*- number of day/night cycles with no votes
 
NeonJulie said:
Guess I should have used the dead fish puzzle for my example... I need to go back and see who jumped bandwagon votes on me I think. There may be some Bobbie's and Charlies among us already...

Btw my dear Lady G... you said "studdering." Since I think you meant stuttering, I simply conjured up what that might mean exactly. *lol* Wow not a lot of deep thought so far all - even that joke fell flat. Maybe the sausage ended up a distraction - funny since the whole point of the exercise was how one goes about logically eliminating suspects based on relationships and if that person's statement is a lie, whether it actually reveals the truth. Heaven forbid someone actually try to move the search in some type of helpful direction. Well, other than Ogre who usually seems to do ok theorizing, while rarely being lynched as a result. It doesn't look like I have that knack for some reason.

The interesting part to this game is that with the numbers being the way they are, we don't have a whole lot of lynches to waste on innocents until we accidentally happen on a deserved hit. So that means more strategy will be involved instead of suicide pacts and "lynch me to find out if I'm innocent" or "let's lynch so-and-so, if they're innocent, oh well." type of votes. That being said, obviously this is way early in the game. But if someone doesn't get some discussion going, this will be a pretty boring game - possibly a short one. Or maybe a long one. We want an interesting game, but I begin to get tired of being the only one to stick my neck out to discuss potential thoughts, and being rewarded by the entire town lynching me for pretty much no reason, other than that I had the courage to be one of the few to speak up?

Any way town, ball's in your court, have fun finding things in this response to build some kind of case around. Considering that this is meant to help the town rally and communicate better, instead of the mudslinging of past games, I would have to think seriously about anyone coming out of the water with strategy talk as some reason why I should be lynched. Instead, one would thing they'd look at those afraid to speak up and draw too much attention to themselves, in case it turns out they're actually found guilty?

Food for thought. Spicy, seasoned food for thought...

(Chill you make me laugh. *lol*
Click to expand...
I won't even comment on what dead fish mean to mafia.... that would put more suspicion on me in your eyes, wouldn't it Ogre or would it push you further into trying to my suspicions off of NJ?
 
Craziness!!! I've got no real suspicions, so far it all seems like day 1 chit-chat. For now, I vote to lynch LadyG, just because I couldn't last round. Vote is subject to change, of course.
 
FireDancer7905 said:
Craziness!!! I've got no real suspicions, so far it all seems like day 1 chit-chat. For now, I vote to lynch LadyG, just because I couldn't last round. Vote is subject to change, of course.
Click to expand...

:silly::silly:
 
Dangerdoll said:
I won't even comment on what dead fish mean to mafia.... that would put more suspicion on me in your eyes, wouldn't it Ogre or would it push you further into trying to my suspicions off of NJ?
Click to expand...

This is your second attempt to get me to think of someone other than you. What's the matter? It's not like you have the most votes or anything. Am I a little to close a communicating mafia?
 
ummmmmm attempting to get "you" to think of someone else? It's a little presumtuous to think I was aiming my posts at you, isn't it Ogre? I was placing my thoughts out because it's the only thing I am picking up on. Now, after you are posting this assumption, it makes me wonder if you nervous that NJ spilled such obvious clues so early in the game. Did you tell her you would fix it or are you just trying to shift thoughts yourself all on your own?
 
Dangerdoll said:
I won't even comment on what dead fish mean to mafia.... that would put more suspicion on me in your eyes, wouldn't it Ogre or would it push you further into trying to my suspicions off of NJ?
Click to expand...

Dangerdoll said:
ummmmmm attempting to get "you" to think of someone else? It's a little presumtuous to think I was aiming my posts at you, isn't it Ogre? I was placing my thoughts out because it's the only thing I am picking up on. Now, after you are posting this assumption, it makes me wonder if you nervous that NJ spilled such obvious clues so early in the game. Did you tell her you would fix it or are you just trying to shift thoughts yourself all on your own?
Click to expand...

Let's see... I thought you were aiming your comment at me because, well, you asked 'wouldn't it Ogre?'.

Let's face it, IMO, you are the only one who has a legit reason to be voted upon. I made a comment about your voting pattern, then you tried to deflect me twice and now trying to get me to feel guilty or make someone believe that I'm nervous about NJ.

If you think NJ is mafia, then vote her. If you think I'm mafia, lynch me. But don't go trying to turn things around like you did in your last post (quoted above). That just screams mafia to me. I'm quite happy with where my vote is.
 
Seriously if I was mafia, would I honestly use something like the dead fish riddle to out myself? I mean I'm no star here, but hopefully I'm a little smarter than that. There really IS a fish riddle, I can find it for you. It was either that, or the sausage. I had a bad feeling about the dead fish one. This is a fish forum after all. Riddles about dead fish just didn't seem right?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom