Sand in Freshwater 55 gallon Tank

when I've changed substrates, it did cause something of a mini-cycle, but ammonia never really became a problem, and only lasted maybe a day or two. The idea when you do this is to not disrupt the bacteria bed too much. Only change the substrate, don't mess with the filters bio-media at all.
 
If you change the substrate with fish in the tank will it cause the tank to cycle?

i don't think so. mine are doing fine. the bacteria in the filter material is still there
 
I doubt it would actually help in the cycle, and unless your keeping inverts or africans, why bother?
I am doing africans, that is the reason this sand caught my eye.
 
I did the same thing over the last couple of days with my 12g. A local pool supply company sold me a 50lb bag of filter sand for $7. (too bad I only needed about 10lbs of it!) I put my fish, filter, decor, plants, and siphoned water into a rubbermaid tub as suggested in another thread. It worked great as a temporary aquarium! I took all my old colored gravel and put it into three bags made from nylon hose. After rinsing out the pool filter sand (I used a 5g bucket and sprayed/overflowed water till it ran clear) I put it in the bottom of the tank and slowly added everything back in. I put the three bags of old gravel back in the tank and let it sit overnight. Everything was good this morning when I checked parameters, so I took one of the old bags of gravel out. I'll do this over the next few days as long as my levels stay the same. I really like the way the filter sand looks. And it has larger grains, so they don't suspend in the water very long at all. Water was crystal clear after the first hour!

BTW, I saw something cool at Walmart last night... Crayola (as in crayons) play sand. This may be old news to everybody else, but I'd never seen it before. They had all kinds of colors. I didn't get a price because it wasn't marked and I was in a hurry. It looked like a neat idea, but I prefer the natural look of the filter sand.
 
This thread could not come at a better time. I've been considering doing this myself. Because I don't have a substrate, it would not affect anything. I'm finding myself not impressed with my gravel-less fish tank.

I'd be cautious with the colored sand because of the dye that is used to make the color. If it is a safe process (as with tank gravel), then my concerns would be nullified. I'm very cautious with what I put in my fishtanks. Stuff out there can give your fish cancer! Another concern of mine was whether or not my guppies would choke on any sand grains. Long time ago I found a dead guppy with a food pellet lodged in its mouth! The horror!!! I stopped feeding my fish that food. I believe they were small cichlid pellets so shame on me.

Finally, would it hurt to boil the sand prior to use to prevent bacterial contamination? Am I paranoid?
 
AquariaCentral.com