Mafia #43 Bio Badlands #2

[jpappy789]

BTW, yes I have Z on my radar from day one but nothing really concrete to go on. He always seems "dirty" to me (no offense Z!) but I cannot put my finger on anything specific. It is difficult to read the tones of posts so I just have to interpret them in my own way when reading and Z just doesnt sit right with me. I know, "that is a lame excuse" but whatever, it is the truth. You know, sometimes you have to go with what you "feel" cause experienced players are good at hiding their true roles.....it is not all about slip ups, is it?

This completely contradicts what you just said. You say that Z isn't sitting right with you but feel that have you nothing concrete to go on...but then you say that sometimes you just have to go with you're feelings? Then why not go all the way through with the vote?

 

[noodles62]

This completely contradicts what you just said. You say that Z isn't sitting right with you but feel that have you nothing concrete to go on...but then you say that sometimes you just have to go with you're feelings? Then why not go all the way through with the vote?

I am still on the middle of reading but thought I would see what was new - concrete and feelings are two very different things - are they not?!!?!? Back to reading...........

 

[Lady G]

IF you are tested Noodles, and if fact DO come out as innocent...well Z definately would be my top.

Since you haven't played with BKW very many times, I can tell you he normally is a VERY low poster.

I don't think you can ever have "concrete" in this game unless someone comes out and says "hey, I'm evil"

 

[noodles62]

IF you are tested Noodles, and if fact DO come out as innocent...well Z definately would be my top.

Since you haven't played with BKW very many times, I can tell you he normally is a VERY low poster.

I don't think you can ever have "concrete" in this game unless someone comes out and says "hey, I'm evil"

I agree, so I do not get how my post is contradicting?!!?!? Maybe I am jsut blonde this week? (no offense G)
If I go thru w/ my vote based on "feelings" that will be called out ........WTH?

 

[jpappy789]

I am still on the middle of reading but thought I would see what was new - concrete and feelings are two very different things - are they not?!!?!? Back to reading...........

Obviously, but that's not my point. I asked why aren't you following through with your suspicion of Z when you said, and I quote, "you know, sometimes you have to go with what you "feel" cause experienced players are good at hiding their true roles....." Apparently you think Z has been up to something the entire game yet you haven't had the courage to go with your conviction. Instead you jumped on the 3L train night one and then onto Ct for night 2. Granted Ct was scum, but I think A) it was part of a plan or B) you were trying to blend in after getting votes. Either way I still see you as an evil scientist.

 

[jpappy789]

I agree, so I do not get how my post is contradicting?!!?!? Maybe I am jsut blonde this week? (no offense G)
If I go thru w/ my vote based on "feelings" that will be called out ........WTH?

I am saying that you contradicted yourself because...

First you say you want something concrete rather than just feelings.

But then you say sometimes you just have to go with your gut. That means to me that a vote for feelings, in your mind is justified.

But now I sense that you'd rather not vote for your top suspect because it might bite you back. Very scummy.

Noodles all you say is "Z is on my radar" constantly but never vote. Pure fluff.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Well my gut feeling last night was Noodles. After all the good points by JPap and Z about Noodles (some of which I was wondering about myself) like not yet throwing a vote Z's way. Then the posts about not being able to post because you are at work and then posting every half hour anyway...How can I not...

I vote to genetically test Noodles

 

[jpappy789]

IF you are tested Noodles, and if fact DO come out as innocent...well Z definately would be my top.

Since you haven't played with BKW very many times, I can tell you he normally is a VERY low poster.

I don't think you can ever have "concrete" in this game unless someone comes out and says "hey, I'm evil"

On that note I checked the past games...

Mafia #40 Bkw, I believe, was changed to scum during the course of the game. He was in the middle of the pack for post count.

Mafia #42 Bkw was at the way bottom for posting and was innocent.

Now usually I very much dislike bringing up post counts and such from last game but I don't see how Noodle's reason holds up. He's possible scum because he's a low poster yet based on your experience shouldn't it be the opposite? I strongly think that you are trying to distance yourselves...

Well my gut feeling last night was Noodles. After all the good points by JPap and Z about Noodles (some of which I was wondering about myself) like not yet throwing a vote Z's way. Then the posts about not being able to post because you are at work and then posting every half hour anyway...How can I not...

I vote to genetically test Noodles

Also she posts that she is reading yet posts replies every half an hour to posts that were just typed...weird.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Z, I went back and read again and am wondering why with all your concerns about Noodles and your vote for her last night...yet you haven't cast your vote for her yet. You and Noodles seem to like to point at each other but hesitate when voting. Granted you voted for her yesterday but maybe are having second thoughts because your partner almost got voted out last night?

 

[jpappy789]

Z, I went back and read again and am wondering why with all your concerns about Noodles and your vote for her last night...yet you haven't cast your vote for her yet. You and Noodles seem to like to point at each other but hesitate when voting. Granted you voted for her yesterday but maybe are having second thoughts because your partner almost got voted out last night?

Interesting point. Z was the first on Noods for last night's testing yet nothing as of now. But I would think that second thoughts would make him back off more...let's see how he responds.