Mafia #44 Christmas At ACville

[johnlarson66]

A detailed list like that on day one? You have to be joking. The sad part about your list is that you are being serious. It is day one.

Your reasons and ranks serve no purpose. You have barely even particapated and then break out this scaled list. A day one scaled list. Based on what? The only purpose I see for this list is to create confusion. It is non-helpful because it is not based on anything besides day one posts. Have you even voted? The people that hold on to their vote until late into the day are the ones that harm the town the most. Place a vote. It is okay to change it. All those thoughts and no vote?

I would like to see more interaction from Brandy and not some sort of hit and run scaled list. The closer nightfall comes with a shortage of vote, the more everyones votes are spread out. I hope others place votes soon.

 

[Sploke]

I don't think you have a clue and it might be a good idea to get one. You tossing around crazy talk does nothing. If you want to vote for me, then do so. State your case while your at it. It is okay to say it is just a hunch. Just let the town in on what you are thinking and be some sort of help instead of being an anoying noob.

I do think because you are a noob does mean you don't know.

The above was in reply to Piggy

A detailed list like that on day one? You have to be joking. The sad part about your list is that you are being serious. It is day one.

Your reasons and ranks serve no purpose. You have barely even particapated and then break out this scaled list. A day one scaled list. Based on what? The only purpose I see for this list is to create confusion. It is non-helpful because it is not based on anything besides day one posts. Have you even voted? The people that hold on to their vote until late into the day are the ones that harm the town the most. Place a vote. It is okay to change it. All those thoughts and no vote?

I would like to see more interaction from Brandy and not some sort of hit and run scaled list. The closer nightfall comes with a shortage of vote, the more everyones votes are spread out. I hope others place votes soon.

then you go on to say, making a list is pointless, after reaming piggy out for not giving any reasons, even just a hunch.

So, I'm gathering that you think there is some acceptable middle ground for just how much reasoning behind a vote is enough, but not too much? So she put out a scaled list...I've done it before, more to organize my own thoughts than anything else. Even if the whole thing is based on hunches.

You are playing farily aggressively JL, but the whole "well if you don't give a reason then its not helful", then "well thats just silly, you're list has too much information so its not helpful" is pretty contradictory. I vote to lynch JL.

 

[plantling]

I hate first day voting. Not much to go on. I'm not sure how much I can be on today so will go ahead and put in a vote.

I vote to lynch 3L

It is very odd that he's posted in at least two other threads since the game began and not even a peep in this one. It makes me wonder if he's the lone evil elf and doensn't know how to play the role. He may UD in which case I will change my vote later.

This is only the 2nd time I've played w/Noodles and the first she was voted out early as an evil so I can't say I know how she plays but it seems she's fidgety though she has tried to explain her errors.

John seemed fidgety in the beginning also but I have played w/him b4 when he was innocent and going after pple or "kicking weasles". He can be quite relentless going after anything that moves...but it could be an evil trying to lead others astray. Haven't decided yet.

If I recall correctly it is not unusual for Brandi to put out early lists. I keep notes at home too w/the list of players and jot down little things here and there just to keep myself organized, but atm I don't have enough to publish it. And Brandi, I would be much more concerned about you if you were leaning me innocent. I'm used to not being trusted, lol.

 

[johnlarson66]

A scaled list on all of the players at this point in my opinion is without merit. Then not following it up with a vote, well that concerns me.

Voting and stating your reasons why and naming others that you suspect has merit.

There is a major difference between the two.

sploke, do you think the scaled list has merit? Do you agree with what was posted? The more I read it, the more I see it as an instrument of confusion. What parts of the list do you agree with?

 

[johnlarson66]

Here are some quotes from jpap,

First he asks a simple question -

Noodles have you been evil yet?

She answers -

Yea, I can't recall the exact game ATM (my memory sucks = old age!) but I have been evil (will try to research later - but now I must shower...). I think it definitely is the turn of some of the older/returing players to be evil.....

I chime in (and stir it up a little) -

Good question, has noodles been evil yet?

Noodles is this your first time being evil?

Now jpap states he was wondering and interested, but it doesn't determine anything -

K...just wondering. I usually don't like to go by who's been what last because it doesn't determine anything really. I was just interested.

I chime in again, stirring it up -

So noodles has been evil before and this is not her first time being evil.

Then I ask jpap basicly the same thing he asked noods -

When was the last time jpap evil? I am not sure if I even remember jpap being evil or how he plays when evil. I am guessing he plays just like he is playing now.

Now, jpap who was just wondering and was interested, looks through the games she has played. After he says that it doesn't matter. Why research it and then call her a liar, if it doesn't matter? I also get an answer to my question, glad he is being "honest". -

Noods I just looked through the games you played and you haven't been evil, unless I missed something...why would you think that you were???



Not sure to be honest.

Now jpap discovers noods had been evil before (as she claimed) -

NEVERMIND

Mafia #41 you were mafia, my mistake...

dawg points out she was evil before (posted at the same time as jpap) -

I thought she was evil in her 1st or 2nd game? I'll have to look.

My response to the "lying" (posted while jpap was posting) -

I am curious about noods lying about being evil before. What a strange thing to lie about.

Did jpap miss something or catch something, noods?

I note that it was 3 games ago when noods was evil -

Looks like, jpap missed something. A whole 3 games ago.

:headshake2:

More and more I like my day one vote.

Here jpap explains his mistake, but never really addresses the fact that he called noods a liar or why he continued to persue it if it doesn't determine anything.

Yes, it was a mistake. I went through the previous games where noodles played and looked at the end for a summary post of roles. I couldn't find one for #41 so I looked at one of Dawgs posts, I think, that listed Z, Jm and someone else...but not noddles as communicating mafia with him. I went back another page of posts and found a post of G's that noodles had been lynched earlier and was found mafia. Just a mistake on my part...and for one I didn't play that game. I can pull up the posts if you wish but I find it interesting that you see this as a possible sign of my evilness...which has me worried about you. Too much certainty over nothing IMO...

I see this as a sign of jpap's evilness because he persued even after he discredited it.

This is my case on jpap. It is weak at best, but of concern to me.

 

[piggy67]

I don't think you have a clue and it might be a good idea to get one. You tossing around crazy talk does nothing. If you want to vote for me, then do so. State your case while your at it. It is okay to say it is just a hunch. Just let the town in on what you are thinking and be some sort of help instead of being an anoying noob.

I do think because you are a noob does mean you don't know.

a vicious attack on me.why?i'm just a noob without a clue,and an anoying one at that!The hunch thing was just to see if you would take the bait.I believe you did..sooooo I vote to Lynch Jl

 

[catfish69hunter]

I have played with Brandy just resently as an evil. In the new school old school game and as for her and a list with no vote I dont buy her being evil. When we worked together she wanted me to get my vote in early so that it would make us look just the opposite. So a late vote from her does NOT concern me. As for her list I feel she has a several people misread myself I feel that Mad is higher than she feels and as for Sploke I dont feel that his statments are as threatening as others.

 

[johnlarson66]

I have played with Brandy just resently as an evil. In the new school old school game and as for her and a list with no vote I dont buy her being evil. When we worked together she wanted me to get my vote in early so that it would make us look just the opposite. So a late vote from her does NOT concern me. As for her list I feel she has a several people misread myself I feel that Mad is higher than she feels and as for Sploke I dont feel that his statments are as threatening as others.

cat, when the two of you were evil, a) did she post a scaled list on day one? and b) did she vote late while you voted early?

I think her list has most people mis-read and can't really find anything that I even remotely agree with. Me being a 7 is not the issue, the reason I am a 7 is the issue. I preffer playing "leaning evil" and having a few votes does not bother me.

Also the fact that Fire did not vote after presenting us with her list bothers me greatly.

 

[catfish69hunter]

cat, when the two of you were evil, a) did she post a scaled list on day one? and b) did she vote late while you voted early?

I think her list has most people mis-read and can't really find anything that I even remotely agree with. Me being a 7 is not the issue, the reason I am a 7 is the issue. I preffer playing "leaning evil" and having a few votes does not bother me.

Also the fact that Fire did not vote after presenting us with her list bothers me greatly.

Well I agree that her note voting after the list is a bit odd but as for the vote late while I voted early NO we both voted early. As for a scaled list personally right now I cant remember off hand but I dont believe so. As for your heavy mafia level on her list, like i said I dont fully agree with it.

 

[noodles62]

I am gonna go ahead and get my vote out there. I hate to wait til the last minute.
I vote to lynch JL

It may only be a hunch, but I think it is a pretty good one. He seems to be kicking a lot of bushes, which I guess is his style, but most of what he is accusing people of I don't agree with. (I will go back and post quotes later when I have a little more time) He seems to be playing pretty aggressively and yet his reason for voting against Jpap was for the use of an evil smilie.........
My other option at this point is Eddie but I also do not want to vote a noob on the first night. Being night one there usually is not much to go on so that is where my vote is for now.....