Mafia #44 Christmas At ACville

[Rbishop]

thru post #299...

to lynch....

jpap (1) jl66 13

virt (1) Hk 14

DD (1) virt 74

eddie (2) cat 110 DD 268

noodl (1) eddie 153

T3L (2) mad 204 plnt 283

jl66 (3) splk 282 ndls 290 pigy 298


11 of 15 have voted....

No vote from jpap, dawg, T3L, Fire......

Nightfall Game Day 1 is at 9 PM, EST, Saturday 12/06...

About 8 hours......PMs or e-mails as required....

 

[johnlarson66]

hmmmm,this is very interesting,i think johnlarson seems a little suspicious.

Here is pig's first post in the game.

Not much different than pig's last post in the game.

"In the game you will get accused, grilled, made to look like an idiot, and a hundred other things. IN THE GAME. Do not take anything personally or make ANY personal attacks."

 

[piggy67]

Oh,sorry noodles,my apologies,i meant to say "Firedancer's list".:duh:

 

[catfish69hunter]

OK JL not that I believe your Innocent yet but I believe that your not as bad off now as you were a bit ago. Look at this from the first post that piggy made they were out to gun for JL. Look at this I mean really if this isnt a Noob player being told to jump on one player and ride them to the ground I dont know what is. Only a few of piggys post have nothing to do with JL and they all are talking to noodles about his other avatar and thats it.

hmmmm,this is very interesting,i think johnlarson seems a little suspicious.

but then again,some of you others seem suspicious too,hmmmm.

Piggy is watching for a slip up from one of you evil scums.



WATCH THAT ICE EVIL SCUMS

i have this hunch about jl,i know that's not much,but sooon i will prove it!!!

just because i'm a noob doesn't mean i don't know an evil scum when i see one.and my vote will be in bold!!!!!

hmmmmm,coherts,you covering up for the slip about DD being the grinch.and in the sign up thread you and 3rd,suspicious imo!!!all evil,Piggy is watching you jl......

a vicious attack on me.why?i'm just a noob without a clue,and an anoying one at that!The hunch thing was just to see if you would take the bait.I believe you did..sooooo I vote to Lynch Jl

ok,maybe playing the "hunch"card wasn't the best idea for a newb,but if you look at noodles list,she list's Plant as a 6 "for no good reason",Me as a 6"because of a bad feeling",also voted to lynch Jl on just a hunch.Jl jumped me for saying the dreaded "hunch" word and im a newb,why did he attack me sooo hard when noodles has played the very same card.I keep my vote the same!I vote to lynch Jl

Now on to you piggy you couldnt just vote for Jl once but you had to vote for him twice and in back to back posts from you. Why????? If you tell us who your leader is well let you live an extra day.

I retract my vote for Eddie and I vote to lynch Piggy

 

[catfish69hunter]

Here is pig's first post in the game.

Not much different than pig's last post in the game.

Yea i agree with you they are no different at all. I will once again say your not clear of anything till your dead or the game is won.

 

[johnlarson66]

The day one list -

Here are my thoughts on this "list":

My responses will be in black

10, mafia --- 1, innocent

Madcrawdad - 3 - feeling ok about him right now what has you feeling okay about him. His giving V2K a pass because he joined late. His questioning jpaps motives on past roles. His catching V2K's vote for DD with no reason and then after seeing v2K's reason noting that it was false.

jpappy789 - 6 - the digging through past games thing nudged you up from a 5 while this is my main reason for voting jpap, it is a nudge from a 5?

noodles62 - 7 - maybe I just have to get used to your play style, but there's been an awful lot of confusion in such a small amount of time - I don't see how this merits a 7, I think noods has just been a vocal player and do not see much confusion from her, just lots of posts.

Hooked Newbie - 5 - missed you, too not much to go on, would think that this would have him leaning more evil.

Dangerdoll - 4 - seems to me to be playing like DD, guns blazing no matter the role - not comfortable with a higher or lower rating yet what guns are blazing. She gets a lower 4 (as low as the list gets). I see her mostly being defensive and defending other players.

johnlarson66 - 7 - for trying to predict rb's behavior in terms of roles I mentioned that roles might be tweaked - others have agreed. I have not stated that they are, but could understand if they were. Stating that I did not think all of the evils would be noobs. There are much better reasons to have me a 7.

dirtydawg10 - 5 - no read dawg has had pretty good input and has been helpful. I think he even agreed about the roles being tweaked. I can't see how one would not have some sort of read on him.

Eddiecorrea - ?!?! - Gah! I think he is innocent. I keep flashing back to lasbianchap's first game, and catfish's first game, and how being a vocal newb, talking in the game like the "vets" do (in terms of joking around, etc), got them lynched, though they were innocent........ i just don't know hard to read noobs. I am assuming since there is no number that it is a 5 leaning innocent. I think if a noob is evil - Eddie would be on that list.

catfish69hunter - 4 - for no good reason other than you don't stick out cat has been active and has stuck out more than some others. Has had input.

TH3RD_LEG - ? all jacked up about playing - was a total noobatard in his first game, posting in sign-up thread knowing the game has started. if this guy does not UD - he will have my vote.

plantling - 6 - no really good reason, sorry so planting must stick out if cat doesn't. Can't see what plant has done either way.

FireDancer7905 -

piggy67 - 6 - kinda a bad feeling, but that's all I got a noob, but not given the same pass as eddie and v2k?

sploke - 7 - ok, there was a moment when you called a theory ridiculous and declared te opposite to be more likely (about the late-comer being an innocent or mafia). It screamed mafia to me, and just gave me goose bumps, I think discussing what rb might do with a late-comer is important - I don't see how this screams mafia.

Virtuoso2K12- 5- for the same reasons as eddie above his vote for DD with no reason and then stating a reason based on DD's one posts really bothers me. I think rb added an evil to the game.

 

[piggy67]

if you'll will look,i did post about noodles,and sploke too.as far as gunning for JL,your right i have been looking at him pretty hard,and posted back to back,a)i wanted every body to know for sure who i voted to Lynch,b)from Jl's earlier post he tried to confuse a noob,he also attacked me with a vengence for just saying "i had a hunch".i think he's tring to point the finger,drawing attention from himself.now it seems you are protecting him for some reason.are you both evil?hmmmm

 

[johnlarson66]

As one can see, I have plenty of free time today. Looks like it is time to take a lunch break. Be back soon.

 

[piggy67]

Oh,sorry noodles,my apologies,i meant to say "Firedancer's list".:duh:

but you did vote Jl on just a hunch!!!

 

[FireDancer7905]

OMG! It's a list. I like lists. And numbers. I post lists a lot! The fact that they are often wrong (except once when I listed the entire mafia team, then got whacked) means nothing to me. At least you know that I am reading and paying attention, whether or not you think I take very good notes, lol (not ever one of my strengths). As has been said, it's day 1. I would imagine everyone is going on "just/mostly a feeling" for their vote, with or without being able to make a case. As for a vote, I think I feel comfortable voting now. I was thinking that cat is a kool kat (innocent-ish) and I like his thoughts on piggy (and myself, although this may be a smoke-screen of flattery and warm fuzzy feelings, you never know) who I feel I have a better read on now. I'm gonna vote. You ready JL?

I vote to lynch piggy.

For reasons, see cat's post just above here somewhere.

And jl, though you may disagree with it, and I can see why now, there is no reason to put the list in quotes. It is a list, and not a paragraph or novella or anything else, but a list. I suppose one could call it the ramblings of an exhausted pregnant lady, but those ramblings do indeed take list form.... (btw, I have missed playing, and want you to know that I enjoy being poked at and being allowed to poke back :evil_lol: )