Mafia #44 Christmas At ACville

That was in response to Jpaps post - did not want to quote the whole thing.....
 
Madcrawdad said:
Sorry for being MIA today, guys. We had breakfast with Santa this morning, and are decorating the house and tree with the kids this afternoon. I'll hopefully be on sporadically before nightfall tonight.

@JL

JL, I know that folks have already questioned you for attacking FD's list, but I have a question for you.

In this post, you say that the sad part of FD's list is that she's being serious. That would imply to me that you're saying Brandy believes what she's written about each person, which would seemingly make her innocent in your eyes, as if she were scum, it would have been made up (ie, not serious), right?



Now in this follow-up post you mention that one of the reasons that you are bothered by FD's list are you don't recall her doing a scaled list on day one... this seems to be saying that the list is tweaking your radar, and that FD might be scum.


You've brought much attention to the list, but seem to be standing on the fence about it.... saying that Brandy believes her list (implying IMO that she's innocent), but at the same time questioning her motives, in saying that she's never done one on Day One (implying that she's done something scummy here).

What bothers you more? The fact that you disagree with the list, or the fact you can't recall FD doing a scaled list on day 1?
Click to expand...

I am most bothered by the list because I disagree with the majority of it.
 
noodles62 said:
I am gonna go ahead and get my vote out there. I hate to wait til the last minute.
I vote to lynch JL

It may only be a hunch, but I think it is a pretty good one. He seems to be kicking a lot of bushes, which I guess is his style, but most of what he is accusing people of I don't agree with. (I will go back and post quotes later when I have a little more time) He seems to be playing pretty aggressively and yet his reason for voting against Jpap was for the use of an evil smilie.........
My other option at this point is Eddie but I also do not want to vote a noob on the first night. Being night one there usually is not much to go on so that is where my vote is for now.....
Click to expand...

This vote caught me by suprise and was unexpected. I am still waiting on the quotes to back it up. I am unsure what she doesn't agree with. My whole interaction with jpap is based on conversations that included her.

I am "playing pretty aggressively", which I can understand as a reason to suspect me, unless you played last game, where I was accused of playing aggressively. Which is normally out of character for me. This style of play to noods should not be a suprise, it is the only style she has ever played with me - last game. Other players might be set back from it, but for noods to have this as a reason is a stretch.

The fact that noods was the third person to vote on me is a concern. Like I said it was a suprise. The fact that she said she was sorry also is odd. I am not sorry for my vote on jpap. I have given him a pretty hard time. It is all part of the game. I would expect no less from anyone else.
 
piggy67 said:
wait,which is it,you say i stand out because i said i had a hunch about Jl,well take some time to read other ppl's post,i'm not the only one who had a hunch and voted on said hunch.you want a full explanation,didn't you just say i voted on a hunch.hence there would be no explanation,but i have stated my reasons,and as far as backing off my hunch,did you see who i voted for?
Click to expand...

See my problem is that anyone can have a hunch but a hunch has to have something of value to make that feeling good. I mean really its like me saying the pope is working for the devil just cause i have a hunch. I have no basis for it but its a hunch should I ask to have him removed from his possition? NO I have to get proof. This is what I'm asking for if you cant provide proof then you aint got chit on him. so proof or lynch its your choice.
 
piggy67 said:
i have this hunch about jl,i know that's not much,but sooon i will prove it!!!
Click to expand...

I think it was all a trick and I fell for it. You got me piggy, I fell for the bait. Your mafia skills are too much for me.

The force is strong in this one.
 
johnlarson66 said:
This vote caught me by suprise and was unexpected. I am still waiting on the quotes to back it up. I am unsure what she doesn't agree with. My whole interaction with jpap is based on conversations that included her.

I am "playing pretty aggressively", which I can understand as a reason to suspect me, unless you played last game, where I was accused of playing aggressively. Which is normally out of character for me. This style of play to noods should not be a suprise, it is the only style she has ever played with me - last game. Other players might be set back from it, but for noods to have this as a reason is a stretch.

The fact that noods was the third person to vote on me is a concern. Like I said it was a suprise. The fact that she said she was sorry also is odd. I am not sorry for my vote on jpap. I have given him a pretty hard time. It is all part of the game. I would expect no less from anyone else.
Click to expand...

The apology was meant as a personal remark because you seemed to take such offense of my vote. Sorry for being nice - I should have posted a "game off" or something....
Also as I said, my vote may change as the events unfold before nightfall, but thus far, this is all I got. If it was night one and there was more posting from the noobs I most likely would be voting for Eddie.

I feel pretty good about the explainations I have given of my vote. Whether the conversations wiht Jpap included me or not has no bearing, Jpap was simply asking a question and you jumped right in to elevate to a new level. In fact it you that stated I lied, not JP. I never said I did not know if I had played evil, I said I did not know what game off the top of my head.

Besides looks like I am tied w/ you for votes so don't sweat it - I bet I will be outta here at nightfall......
 
On a serious note, jpap did not call noods a liar as I had posted.

My case on jpap is weak and not much of anything.

I retract my vote on jpapy789

If 3L votes, I am voting 3L, my guess is 3L will not vote unless it is right at nightfall.

Just to keep 3L from even thinking about voting:

I vote to lynch TH3RD_LEG.

I hate to waste it on someone that might UD, but I also do not want him to vote late and save himself. I think I have posted good reasons on why I suspect him. Besides him being a UD, I can't think of a reason not to vote for 3L.
 
^^^ should read "if is was NOT night one"
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom