Mafia #44 Christmas At ACville

[johnlarson66]

I hate to say it, but I agree with what jpap is saying.

I also think pig has kinda calmed down. I am wondering if he was told to do so by his teamates.

I would like to see either V2K or pig be lynched.

 

[johnlarson66]

I also see noods trying to blend in and hide in the shadow of other players.

Her vote on me and assuring herself it was good because I was on Mad's radar.

While her vote on 3L was understandable, but then she wants to include others in her reasons.

Really there seems to be no accountablity from noods. It is like she wants to blame others for her actions.

 

[Dangerdoll]

I never scrutinized you about pointing them out, just the level you took it to. But you never even commented on virt's excuse...which I find odd.

I wasnt trying to bring anything to any level, I was only answering questions or responding to responses... nothing more. If they dropped it, I did...

Virt's excuse, I find very very peculiar, because of the amount of posts he has but it has already been mentioned. There is the key point, it has already been mentioned... I find it odd that you seem to be trying to provoke me into making an issue out of something that was already pointed out. You asked me about it, I answered.... you ask again, or rather you make another statement about it.... so again, I am responding to it... tell me, am I making it an issue or are you.... rather am I taking it "to a level" or are you?

 

[dirtydawg10]

Not a lot has gone on since my last post so let's see what happens.

I vote to lynch Catfish

This vote shouldn't be a surprise to anyone who hasn't been skimming. As I have said before I am also up for voting DD or Noods but for now I am voting for Cat.

 

[plantling]

Also I would like to add that I don't quite agree with the notion that DD and Hn jumping onto 3L late isn't a mafia-like move...in fact, I find it is the opposite. What better way to hide than to jump onto a train that most of the town was in favor of voting? Not saying that it automatically makes them mafia as I said earlier that IMO a vote for 3L last night doesn't clue us in on anything, but writing them off is not a pro-town thing to do.

I want to make it clear that I have not cleared HN and DD. But of the 3 last and freshest prints in the snow I would still say I suspect Noodles the most. HN has been very quiet which is a bit troubling. He had a single vote on V2K and switched late when it seemed the whole town was against 3L already. DD bantered quite a bit with both 3L and Eddie. IMO and of what I have experienced w/her gameplay she would not turn around and hit Eddie if she were evil. I guess I just haven't seen DD be that devious. Maybe others have.

I wasnt trying to bring anything to any level, I was only answering questions or responding to responses... nothing more. If they dropped it, I did...

Virt's excuse, I find very very peculiar, because of the amount of posts he has but it has already been mentioned. There is the key point, it has already been mentioned... I find it odd that you seem to be trying to provoke me into making an issue out of something that was already pointed out. You asked me about it, I answered.... you ask again, or rather you make another statement about it.... so again, I am responding to it... tell me, am I making it an issue or are you.... rather am I taking it "to a level" or are you?

I can relate to not commenting on something if it's already been mentioned. I guess I can be called a lurker or voyeur, lol.

 

[jpappy789]

I wasnt trying to bring anything to any level, I was only answering questions or responding to responses... nothing more. If they dropped it, I did...

Virt's excuse, I find very very peculiar, because of the amount of posts he has but it has already been mentioned. There is the key point, it has already been mentioned... I find it odd that you seem to be trying to provoke me into making an issue out of something that was already pointed out. You asked me about it, I answered.... you ask again, or rather you make another statement about it.... so again, I am responding to it... tell me, am I making it an issue or are you.... rather am I taking it "to a level" or are you?

I'm not making an issue of it DD, merely responding to your responses. You on the other hand kept questioning Eddie's links going as far as to say how can we believe it's him, it could be anybody. Well DD, how can we believe anybody else's reasons for not being on the thread 24/7? You singled out Eddie and brought it to a new, ridiculous level.

I also find that you not posting because "it has already been mentioned" is not a satisfying enough answer. Sorry, but it isn't. You were called out before for questioning everyone's excuses and I think you decided to tone it down after last night because you were afraid it would come back to bite you in the butt.

I want to make it clear that I have not cleared HN and DD. But of the 3 last and freshest prints in the snow I would still say I suspect Noodles the most. HN has been very quiet which is a bit troubling. He had a single vote on V2K and switched late when it seemed the whole town was against 3L already. DD bantered quite a bit with both 3L and Eddie. IMO and of what I have experienced w/her gameplay she would not turn around and hit Eddie if she were evil. I guess I just haven't seen DD be that devious. Maybe others have.


I can relate to not commenting on something if it's already been mentioned. I guess I can be called a lurker or voyeur, lol.

I probably worded my response the wrong way. I didn't think anyone right now was giving Hn or DD a free pass. I was trying to say that the votes should be viewed in a similar way to other's votes after 3L came back. I think a mafia could have hidden anywhere, including jumping on at the end. It's a possibility but I feel that voting order in a train situation like that comes down to who was online when.

 

[Madcrawdad]

As for how I'm so specific,
First look at my post 549 and quit skimming. this will answer your question as to me being specific.
As for who I think well lets look at that.

T3L (6) mad 204 jl66 338 jpap 410 ndle 416 DD 420 hk 434

Mad- Unsure but leary why vote for a probable UD when it doesnt help the town one bit.

You might want to check your timeline there, Cat. I voted 3L pretty early, and never saw a reason to come off. IMO, 3L was never a 'probable' UD.... 'possible' UD, yes... 'probable', no.

To say that you already thought 3L was going to UD 30 hours or so before nightfall would not only make you crazy, but also flat out wrong, as obviously he didn't UD.

 

[catfish69hunter]

Thanks for answering my questions but it looks like you think 3 out of the 6 could be evil. I thought you said 1. So if you had to pick 1 who would it be? Give me 1 person 1 name just as you stated.

Oh...and I didn't skim. Maybe you should have read my post...

Well Dawg you want to know who is the most outstanding on my list I would prob be Hooked. He jumped in early with a quick vote to cover himself. Then he came in late and jump on an already sinking ship. I feel he isnt playing up to the Hooked standard. he would be my number one pick the more I look back.

 

[jpappy789]

Well Dawg you want to know who is the most outstanding on my list I would prob be Hooked. He jumped in early with a quick vote to cover himself. Then he came in late and jump on an already sinking ship. I feel he isnt playing up to the Hooked standard. he would be my number one pick the more I look back.

Can you explain this cat...what is the "Hooked standard"? He played last game very quiet and UD'd as an evil because of RL issues. He's out of town atm, or at least was, or did you miss that?

 

[Dangerdoll]

I'm not making an issue of it DD, merely responding to your responses. You on the other hand kept questioning Eddie's links going as far as to say how can we believe it's him, it could be anybody. Well DD, how can we believe anybody else's reasons for not being on the thread 24/7? You singled out Eddie and brought it to a new, ridiculous level.

I also find that you not posting because "it has already been mentioned" is not a satisfying enough answer. Sorry, but it isn't. You were called out before for questioning everyone's excuses and I think you decided to tone it down after last night because you were afraid it would come back to bite you in the butt.

I probably worded my response the wrong way. I didn't think anyone right now was giving Hn or DD a free pass. I was trying to say that the votes should be viewed in a similar way to other's votes after 3L came back. I think a mafia could have hidden anywhere, including jumping on at the end. It's a possibility but I feel that voting order in a train situation like that comes down to who was online when.

no, if anyone else posted links to where they were, I would have questioned the validity of them too.... the point is, I pointed out that the links proved nothing in his whereabouts. The reason I posted about the links in the first place is because of exactly what I explained to him..... the links proved nothing. It was an unusual move and seemed desperate to post links in the first place, IMO. I didn't know him from Adam, neither do most aeveryone else... how do they prove where he was... I questioned it and responded to his response... I still don't see how that is making a blowing up things out of proportion... but we all read things differently...

as far as you "not being satisfied with my response", that's fine and up to you... but pappy, it seems now someone else in making a huge issue out of something that is over and done with. Yes, you are correct about one thing... that I decided to tone things down and post more wisely, hence me not "mentioning points already mentioned".... I am posting more wisely because I find it a waste for people to be concentrating on me when there is mafia rooting around and unfortunate for you, at this point pap, I am sorry but it seems you trying to point me out as doing this or not doing that being a huge issue has only made you seem more mafia to me...