Mafia #44 Christmas At ACville

[catfish69hunter]

1.) I quoted this only because you were the very first to post in the thread.

2.) So you decided to lash out at people who were looking at any information or details possible. You called Pap out on it, but I was the one that originally posed the question. Why?

3.) Asking JL's opinion early (and you do in later posts as well). Not distancing, but are you trying to befriend someone you know isn't evil?

4.) Going HARD at Eddie. He did look bad, but if any charge was led it was you in the lead.

5.) Randomly mention 3 players, but your still convinced of Eddie here.

6.) What changed your mind about Eddie so suddenly? Did someone tell you to go from one noob to another? You accuse them of EXACTLY what you were doing with Eddie. Were you told that he was going to be hit and to move your vote?

7.) Let me use and reword your question and comment bolded above... Well Cat, what made you jump onto Piggy and not anyone else? You seemed pretty convinced of Eddie's guilt.

8.) Now you are questioning Dawg and Plantling. Can't make up your mind? Shotgun theory is usually very effective at leaving little traces to get caught on when evil.

9.) That sounds like you may have had some inside info. Personally, I think killing Eddie was stupid. He would have been hard to not lynch today. Your vote ended up where it didn't matter. As night came close it was a horse race between JL & 3L. Yes, I did move my vote onto a train. I always do if it may matter. I chose an innocent, but at the time (and probably still now) I viewed JL as less likely evil and/or at least more helpful.

10.) I'm going to reread some stuff after lunch and I'll come up with a weighted list in a bit... I'll use a system of A-F with A being innocent so that it'll be a familiar system and grade for Virtu. You, I'm not sure about yet but you have changed your mind an awful lot and that I always find concerning.

Ok Hooked we will go through this number by number.

1.) Ok I posted first. seeing its my first game in a while I was ready to go. If thats a bad thing next game I will wait and pull a T3L.

2.) I felt that at the time what they were going after was chasing something that was unimportant and wasting time on something like that is just usless in my mind.

3.) Well I was agreeing with what he was saying and I was trying to get some one to prove what I was looking at. If you notice I do that every game. Its something that has got me lynched before and very well could again.

4.) Your right for quite a bit of time I felt eddie was evil. He just seemed to be playing to well and knew how to state thing too well not have been coached.

5.) Not quite at random there Hooked I looked at 3 of the most prodominate players that talked in the time from when I last posted till the time I posted that statement.

6.) Ok this will take some time to answer. What changed your mind about Eddie so suddenly? My mind didnt change about eddie. Pig came into the game and just jumped right on the Jl bandwagon of people and he did it preatty hard and fast to the point that he seemed more coached than eddie did at the time. This made me extreamly nervous.
As for the rest of the questions NO I was not told anything hard to be told anything when you are infact not connected to anyone.

7.) Once again if you go back and look at how pig entered the game and see what all was happening it seemed very set up. Plain and simple.

8.) Well I was about to vote for pig when I got back on late and found eddie to be innocent. But seeign plant and dawg both on nood then they both try to point the finger back at nood right away after the night fall seemed strange to me. It seems like your suspect list usually changes a bit after night fall. Also if you go look now since I brought that to light they both see to be picking other people to try and kick but keep stringing the name of nood along just to CYA

9.)Well here we are again. I give my thoughts on what I would have dont to try and work thru what the mafia did and now I'm slipping up and telling the whole mafia plot. First off I've played this game enough to know better than that. Second yes I have screwed up a few times in the past but never would I have done that. Third do you really think me stupid enough to post that?

10.) Yes I am concered as well that I'm changing my mind. But, That is because I see so many things that just scream evil. Just as you and a lot of others see me and what I'm saying and doing as evil. Dont know what more to say to that.

 

[Dangerdoll]

from what I can see so far, I would have to say v, piggy, paps, and cat have my attention...
V - because of as mentioned, he is all over the place. Call it noob, I call it suspicious.

piggy, VERY confrontational and also, all over the place...

paps, I just cant seem to figure why you are poking at me as much as you are, accusing me of the very things you are doing to me.... and then you still won't drop things. I can't answer you because you won't accept any explanation I give you, or rather you do, but you seem to twist it into some kind of magical manipulating theory of how I am trying to wing things. I have news for ya, and I am sure lots of others already are aware of this, I don't put that much thought into the game.

and finally cat... for the host of reasons that have already been explained.

Out of these 4 people, I really am on the fence of who to vote for..... I need to see more, to feel what is most damaging..... every time I want to go one way, I see something new...

I also want to note on Sploke and Plants light posting habit. Makes me very uncomfortable as I am used to seeing a lot more from both of them.... Hooked, I understand he was involved with considerable RL issues.... now, I hear sploke with Wii... ok.... how about you plant?

(yes, pap.... I seem to be letting people off easy on their absence excuses... care to dagger me now or would you rather do it slowly?)

 

[piggy67]

game off,hey guy's this is a blast,i agree with cat,addicting!!!game on.ok,i'm catching on how to spot discrepancies(ie,slips)in your posts,also i have yet to figure out how to do the multiple post in a post thing,you guy's can drill me on why i haven't backed up my thought's with quotes,but that's why.Im not tring to play the newb card or give excusses, I AM LEARNING, sooo all you evil's beware!!!!!

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Interesting case, HN. I do believe, however, you've got a vote on V2K that you've yet to give a reason for...unless I missed it.

I simply don't buy the lame excuses... I think he got called out for trying to lay low after garnering attention and choked when trying to come up with a quick excuse.

Come to think of it... I could have missed it so far, but who are YOUR top suspects right now and why?

 

[Sploke]

Overall this game has been a bit slower than others I've played in I think.

DD, no response to my vote??

 

[johnlarson66]

Where is noodles?

 

[Dangerdoll]

not at all, sploke. Not sure I understand the reasoning but don't want to be accused of throwing things out of proportion, either. Since you asked though, as you say "just to bring me into the race".... my thoughts are that it doesn't seem to be very towny like but you haven't been a huge part of the game anyhow so why would I expect you to have any weight in anyone you might decide? You give no reason other than that which proves the point and then you say it is in risk of aligning yourself with piggy... that, to me proves you are not so involved in the game... have you seen piggy's posts? I'm guessing, no.

On another thought, because you haven't been so involved, I can see you might be trying to shake things up dramatically in the game, maybe to bring you out in the spotlight... knight in shing armour... whatever but I just don't think it was wise to side with piggy on it but again, your choice.

Am I ready to say you are mafia because of it, no.... I don't think you'd be that silly to make such a move. That's why I am thinking you are more trying to add something to the game rather than work on taking it over.

 

[catfish69hunter]

Any other questions for me today? If not I would like to go get some work done. dont want ot get fired for being on the computer all day. I also dont want to acused of not being on to answer anyones questions of me today.

 

[Sploke]

not at all, sploke. Not sure I understand the reasoning but don't want to be accused of throwing things out of proportion, either. Since you asked though, as you say "just to bring me into the race".... my thoughts are that it doesn't seem to be very towny like......

Not very townie-like to initiate discussion of people I think my be mafia??

...but you haven't been a huge part of the game anyhow so why would I expect you to have any weight in anyone you might decide?

I've got as much weight as anyone.....one vote.

You give no reason other than that which proves the point and then you say it is in risk of aligning yourself with piggy... that, to me proves you are not so involved in the game... have you seen piggy's posts? I'm guessing, no.

On another thought, because you haven't been so involved, I can see you might be trying to shake things up dramatically in the game, maybe to bring you out in the spotlight... knight in shing armour...



whatever but I just don't think it was wise to side with piggy on it but again, your choice.

like I said, I'm not thrilled about it either, but i want to hear others opinions more than I don't want to look aligned with piggy.


Am I ready to say you are mafia because of it, no.... I don't think you'd be that silly to make such a move. That's why I am thinking you are more trying to add something to the game rather than work on taking it over.

thoughts in blue.

 

[Sploke]

thoughts in blue or in failed color tags.....