Mafia #44 Christmas At ACville

[Hooked Newbie]

Ok, I have some time this evening while she is studying for finals.

I'd like to propose something and am totally open for feedback. The best chance we have to turn this around and score a town victory is to play as a team and by consensus. With Cat's claims confirmed, we need to follow his lead. I am willing to vote for whomever on his list he is most sure of as evil (even if that's me). If his list is good, it should work out easily in our favor and based on what I've seen I think it's a pretty good list.

Would everyone else be willing to follow that plan? Why or why not? Feedback? Better ideas?

 

[piggy67]

in light of this new evidence,i feel i must apologize to the town.first a voted for DD,then i thought cat and plant was decieving the town.finding evil's is harder then i thought.for the reason dawn switch his vote at the last min against dd.i vote to lynch dawg

 

[Hooked Newbie]

in light of this new evidence,i feel i must apologize to the town.first a voted for DD,then i thought cat and plant was decieving the town.finding evil's is harder then i thought.for the reason dawn switch his vote at the last min against dd.i vote to lynch dawg

Did you read my post made 20 minutes before your's piggy? Any thoughts or opinions on what I propose?

 

[piggy67]

Did you read my post made 20 minutes before your's piggy? Any thoughts or opinions on what I propose?

well,base on cat being honest,and turning out to be an innocent.i did retract my vote,as far as his list,i don't agree withit,tnot because i'm at the top because i'm at the top and am innocent,but simply because of dawg switching his vote ,effectively lynching santa,i think DD investigated DAWN thats why he changed his vote at the last min.

 

[piggy67]

sorry can't type for some reason,but you guy's get what i'm tring to say

 

[catfish69hunter]

Hooked if you still around my opinion on you is as follows. I believe just following my list right off the bat is wrong. Now we have one less to worry about in me I want to hear everyones reasons for who they think are their top suspects. I feel that this will bring to light a lot of peoples ideas and It will bring out the liars.

SO everyone who is your top 3 and why?

 

[dirtydawg10]

Ok, I have some time this evening while she is studying for finals.

I'd like to propose something and am totally open for feedback. The best chance we have to turn this around and score a town victory is to play as a team and by consensus. With Cat's claims confirmed, we need to follow his lead. I am willing to vote for whomever on his list he is most sure of as evil (even if that's me). If his list is good, it should work out easily in our favor and based on what I've seen I think it's a pretty good list.

Would everyone else be willing to follow that plan? Why or why not? Feedback? Better ideas?

I agree with this plan.

well,base on cat being honest,and turning out to be an innocent.i did retract my vote,as far as his list,i don't agree withit,tnot because i'm at the top because i'm at the top and am innocent,but simply because of dawg switching his vote ,effectively lynching santa,i think DD investigated DAWN thats why he changed his vote at the last min.

I would have no idea if DD investigated me. Grasping at straws hey Piggy? I have no problem with your vote for me but the reason behind it is flawed big time. I think DD investigated you and that's why she voted for you.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Hooked if you still around my opinion on you is as follows. I believe just following my list right off the bat is wrong. Now we have one less to worry about in me I want to hear everyones reasons for who they think are their top suspects. I feel that this will bring to light a lot of peoples ideas and It will bring out the liars.

SO everyone who is your top 3 and why?

Good point Cat. I'll get back to you. Of course my top suspect is Piggy for reasons already stated.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Hooked if you still around my opinion on you is as follows. I believe just following my list right off the bat is wrong. Now we have one less to worry about in me I want to hear everyones reasons for who they think are their top suspects. I feel that this will bring to light a lot of peoples ideas and It will bring out the liars.

SO everyone who is your top 3 and why?

I can see that. I'd have to say my top 3 right now would be...

1. piggy- based alot on voting you before confirmation or denial of your claim was provided. Also had some weird interactions before hand.

2. Dawg- Could have been nothing, but I can't dismiss the way he and DD went at it.

3. Plant- Got a bit overly defensive IMO even though I do think the present controversy was blown a bit out of proportion and based mostly on misunderstanding.

3. Sploke- He and Plant are sorta tied in my eyes, but I haven't seen much to say either way.

I do need to reread through some of the posting that I had to speed read over, I've had a terrible read on the game so far. I was sure that Virt was noob mafia.

 

[plantling]

Ok, I have some time this evening while she is studying for finals.

I'd like to propose something and am totally open for feedback. The best chance we have to turn this around and score a town victory is to play as a team and by consensus. With Cat's claims confirmed, we need to follow his lead. I am willing to vote for whomever on his list he is most sure of as evil (even if that's me). If his list is good, it should work out easily in our favor and based on what I've seen I think it's a pretty good list.

Would everyone else be willing to follow that plan? Why or why not? Feedback? Better ideas?

While Cat is a confirmed innocent, and granted he has someone to share thoughts with, he doesn't have investigative abilities. I think we all need to look at the thread and not just follow along. R U trying to blend in, HN?