Mafia #47 "Ghost Hunters"

[noodles62]

It wasn't as soon as I jumped on. Rickets jumped on as I was posting then my comp posted my post and I had to add the vote. Then a couple of minutes later Opi voted for DD. So in a span of 5 minutes 3 votes fell on DD. I'm pretty sure it wasn't a right away vote either. Somewhere she says she waited 4 hours and wanted to make sure she had a vote in for night fall.



Seriously? Did you even go back to see if he was telling the truth or not?


Its funny, I still feel good about either DD or Jpap for a vote. I'll stick on DD but if anyone thinks one over the other for murderer I'll switch. At this point I'm not sure enough of which is which.

The reason I'm staying on DD is I feel she is being more aggressive then normal, if I remember correctly that usually means she is evil.

Any vets want to vouch if DD is innocent or evil when aggressive? I truly can not remember at this time. Seems like forever since I actually paid attention to gamestyle. If I can be convinced she is aggressive innocent I will switch to Jpap without a 2nd thought.

1. Well, no I guess I did not, but I was speaking from the gut, as I also have some supsicions about Opi.....

2. I am always suspicious of DD just because she is "notoriously" good at playing bad. Do I have the experience to "read it"? no!


if my vote would serve the innocents better elsewhere I would be more than happy to change it. I am afraid I am not thinking too clearly on my own tonite and do not want to "follow" the wrong lead...my suspicions are on JL, DD (of course!), Lucky and Opi.....pfft! hows that for narrowing it down for ya?!

 

[rich311k]

DD has been very active and out there. Few games I played with her she did not post nearly as much. Same reasoning I used on john.

I do not get a feeling for Pappy at all.

Some interesting points raised about OPI. I nee to back and check the times on all the votes.

I think I will stay where I am for the moment.

 

[jpappy789]

Well, I waited for awhile (4 hours) but I wasn't sure how much time I would have (I've managed to hop on more than expected, as things are taking awhile in the lab, but as soon as they are done I will be MIA for awhile)...so I voted my top suspect to make sure I didn't get a UD. If you'll notice, that post was a bit long, and it took me a few minutes to write it (I was also reviewing my notes). I actually hadn't seen Ice's post for DD until AFTER I voted. Still, I said that if she provided a reasonable response, I'd switch to Rich. However, her response hasn't changed my mind, so my vote still stands.

I really don't see voting for the person I said I was GOING to vote for several posts prior is a "mafia following"...I accused DD before there was a train, because that's what I thought was right. If anything, the people who voted for her after my accusation were "following".

I understand the timing issue, and I probably should have thought about that more in depth. 4 minutes... it's hard to say whether you were typing at the same time Ice posted.

I only said it's "mafia-like" following because it seemed to me as you waited for someone else to commit to the vote even though you said quite a bit that DD was your top suspect and probable vote getter. Sort of a "look at them, not me. I didn't start it!" sort of thing. You had DD as pretty much a done vote unless she responded but it looked like you decided that if other people would vote for her, you might as well get it in, even if her response later was good enough to make you switch thoughts.

Kind of weak reasoning but it's all I got at this point.

ok - so now I have to wait even longer than I thought to see who was right/wrong!

Well, I just had a good cry in the shower and now i am going to spend some time with the doggie....my son leaving really hit home tonite when he called to confirm my address, "in case his C.O. should need to contact me"... Hard for a mama to handle.....:cry:

Sorry to hear this Noods

It wasn't as soon as I jumped on. Rickets jumped on as I was posting then my comp posted my post and I had to add the vote. Then a couple of minutes later Opi voted for DD. So in a span of 5 minutes 3 votes fell on DD. I'm pretty sure it wasn't a right away vote either. Somewhere she says she waited 4 hours and wanted to make sure she had a vote in for night fall.




Seriously? Did you even go back to see if he was telling the truth or not?


Its funny, I still feel good about either DD or Jpap for a vote. I'll stick on DD but if anyone thinks one over the other for murderer I'll switch. At this point I'm not sure enough of which is which.

The reason I'm staying on DD is I feel she is being more aggressive then normal, if I remember correctly that usually means she is evil.

Any vets want to vouch if DD is innocent or evil when aggressive? I truly can not remember at this time. Seems like forever since I actually paid attention to gamestyle. If I can be convinced she is aggressive innocent I will switch to Jpap without a 2nd thought.

I missed that too. Dang. I feel really iffy about my vote but my other suspects at the moment are rickets and DD. Another lone vote and a train, not an ideal situation to switch votes.

Your question to noodles brings up another point of mine. Noodles was one to voice her opinions on me once votes were first thrown out, then she kind of is suspicious of Opi for what I said...but she admits to a random-ish vote on JL...odd.

Ogre, I'm pretty sure you got me a few games back, too. I remember being po'd that I didn't see through it! Anyway, that is completely beside the point.

DD is still looking iffy to me: I think that jpap is innocent. Someone posted a theory that DD is evil, and would not vote him just to prove her innocence. Shortly thereafter, she does the opposite, possibly trying to deflect the suspicion away from herself.

I vote to take the soul of DD.

Fire, I'm interested in why you think I'm innocent (I know, before I was wondering why I was so suspicious to everyone else...) I only ask because you flat out say it, rather than lean me a certain way. Bold statement this early.

Also, could you give a post numbers of the stuff you referenced?

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

I feel good about my vote on DD. The only thing that troubles me is Pappy seems to have fallen off in his posting as of late. I see he's on but not posting.

 

[noodles62]

So let's see...if my notes are correct; We have 1 vote on Rich = CJ, who said he wont be back on tonite....1 on Opi = Jpap....and 1 on jpap = Doll
& 1 on Rickets = Ogre........any of you care to move to make a difference?

just lookin at the numbers since we have not gotten an official vote count.......

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

OK so he posted while I was typing. Why does that always happen in Mafia?

 

[OgreMkV]

Actually, my clarification...I didnt mean to invoke Rickets was attacking pappy or bringing him up, however you want to say it, I was talking of the the conversations between rickets and pappy... yes, there are only a few, 2 or 3 but they have my attention.

They peaked my interest because here...

you see the conversation is light...

before this post is where I mention the paps and rickets discussion... where I see this...

which makes me think twice... I don't know.... maybe it is because I worded it wrong and incited undue suspicions, I don't know....

Though I still suspect you both, I think I'll stick with Pappy as my vote...

I vote to take the soul of Pappy

Why not join a vote for rickets? I'd like my vote to count for something, but I just feel the votes on anyone currently with many votes.

 

[jpappy789]

I feel good about my vote on DD. The only thing that troubles me is Pappy seems to have fallen off in his posting as of late. I see he's on but not posting.

And that concerns you why?

I had quite a lot going on this afternoon/evening scheduling wise. I won't bore you with the details.

 

[jpappy789]

Why not join a vote for rickets? I'd like my vote to count for something, but I just feel the votes on anyone currently with many votes.

I would. I seemed to has misplaced your vote for him/her so I thought it would be another lone vote. Not sure if it would make a difference though and I don't really feel it that much.

 

[noodles62]

Your question to noodles brings up another point of mine. Noodles was one to voice her opinions on me once votes were first thrown out, then she kind of is suspicious of Opi for what I said...but she admits to a random-ish vote on JL...odd.

I thought the first suspicions due to your "defensiveness" were legit but after you "explained" yourself I believed you. Am I wrong??? I guess we will see;.....Opi.....I don't know. something seems fishy there to me and I could be easily persuaded to vote for her;......JL, as I said a little random but he is always agressive and kicking bushes and this time it is just a gut feeling that he is evil. It is night one and my guess is as good as anyones.....maybe I just really suck at this game and am just good at following?? Tell me now and I will bow out....:huh: