Mafia #47 "Ghost Hunters"

jpappy789 said:
I just have this odd suspicion that you're trying to get me on your side. I don't know...maybe I'm just paranoid...



Huh? Why would JL jump off of Lucky, then flat out call him innocent, just to save Rich?

Rickets thoughts about Ice's wording is messed up if you ask me. Somehow he missed the whole hypothetical nature of the situation. A Lucky-JL-Rickets team seems more plausible once Rickets jumped in and went after Ice. But I'm still unsure.

I just don't like how JL's story magically falls together. First two GH's investigate another in one night bringing three together, then the murderer recruits two GH's out of two posisble nightly turns. That's too unlikely.

here are some hypotheticals I've been working out...

if we lynch lucky and he is innocent JL could be telling the truth about Ice, but at the same time if JL is a troubled soul he would know that lucky was innocent anyways

if we lynch Ice there is the chance of him being a turned GH according to JL. But also is there the possibility of JL and his team trying to get Ice killed because they suspect him of having a role or investigated, and Ice doesn't want to come out and say that thus comprimising his role?

if we go after JL we either get a GH or a troubled soul. Not an ideal situation in my mind because the first one would help the other team and we need to get the murderer so a troubled soul wouldn't help us right now.

I see Lucky as the best option fo murderer atm. Neither Ice nor JL are it and I don't think Rickets is either based on his play lately. Rich has been acting shady and Ogre is laying low too. But I don't see them as good votes right now.
Click to expand...

I understand the hypothetical nature of Ice's posts. I'm not questioning that. I'm questioning his choice of words in describing the hypothetical. As I said it seems Ice is taking things to a more personal level than I would if I was questioning someones theories. Ice sounds like he believes much of what JL was commenting on. I guess I am over thinking it...:huh:
 
jpappy789 said:
Keep in mind that CJ also was a GH day 1.

One thing that is leading me to think that Ogre is NOT the murderer is that he has always been one to go after low posters in the past. Why would he suddenly do that himself? I'm thinking RL is the issue here, not a role.

My thoughts...
Click to expand...

If I recall correctly, Ogre said he was moving into a house this weekend; that obviously takes a lot of time. I hope he makes it back in time to read and make a good vote before he UD's. well, that is if he is on the GH team - if he is evil than I hope he UD's! :lipssealedsmilie:

I am in and out right now - gotta feed the man dinner. not much has changed on my thinking yet. I am inclinded to not fall for JL's story so my vote on Lucky is a good bet in my mind.....more later......
 
jpappy789 said:
Keep in mind that CJ also was a GH day 1.

One thing that is leading me to think that Ogre is NOT the murderer is that he has always been one to go after low posters in the past. Why would he suddenly do that himself? I'm thinking RL is the issue here, not a role.

My thoughts...
Click to expand...

It very well could be...but I don't always make a habit of believing RL claims either.

So according to both Ice and JL's theories neither Ice nor JL could be the murderer. There is a 50/50 chance that Lucky is the murderer according to their theories (Ice says yes JL says no). You say Ogre is not the murderer in your opinion. So if JL turns out to be telling the truth...who is the murderer in your opinion, JPap?
 
[AC] RICKETS;1856220 said:
It very well could be...but I don't always make a habit of believing RL claims either.

So according to both Ice and JL's theories neither Ice nor JL could be the murderer. There is a 50/50 chance that Lucky is the murderer according to their theories (Ice says yes JL says no). You say Ogre is not the murderer in your opinion. So if JL turns out to be telling the truth...who is the murderer in your opinion, JPap?
Click to expand...

good point! I guess I am gullable; need to work on that!
 
[AC] RICKETS;1856220 said:
It very well could be...but I don't always make a habit of believing RL claims either.

So according to both Ice and JL's theories neither Ice nor JL could be the murderer. There is a 50/50 chance that Lucky is the murderer according to their theories (Ice says yes JL says no). You say Ogre is not the murderer in your opinion. So if JL turns out to be telling the truth...who is the murderer in your opinion, JPap?
Click to expand...

Rich would be my top suspect. However as I already said unless Ice is lynched and found to be a turned GH (which I'm not sure is a good idea) there's no way of telling if JL is a GH because the evils know lucky's role too.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom