Mafia #48 - Blarney Castle

No offense taken opi. I have been busy and not around a lot but i would not forget the hit twice.
Ok so heres what i think

I agree with Ice where i dont think Opi would miss a hit twice but i was team mates with both of them last game and Ice enjoys being evil more then being an innocent. If there were 2 evils right now i would not put it past Ice to come up with something like this, but seeing that i feel there is only 1 evil right now i dont see why he would protected Opi like he did in post 186. So because of Ice vote history and the fact i dont think Opi would forget about the hits i would put then on the innocent side right now.


rich311k said:
Well I can guarantee you that Jpap is telling the truth. I have OPI at the top of the list, but what Ice says about her not forgetting to send in a PM rings true with me.

Which kind of leaves me without a top suspect. I need to see the list of possibles and read there posts.

Right now I would say Ice is not evil and I know Jpap is not.

Everyone else is fair game in my mind.
Click to expand...

I dont like this post by Rich it seems like he is saying he is the other clansman but why would he say this with no real heat on him it just draws attention, I understand why Jpap would tell everyone but not Rich. So i would like to hear Richs reasoning for (if i am right) hinting that he is the other clansman

Like Opi said Lucky dose not seem to be Luck in this game but is seems like no one is really in this game, a lot of uncharacteristic things going on so idk. I dont really see anything else that screams evil to me

And for right now i feel JL is telling the truth so he is off my list.

So my vote will most likely be for Rich if JL dose not somehow confirm what Rich is saying or if Rich can convince me i am wrong.
 
cjtabares said:
I dont like this post by Rich it seems like he is saying he is the other clansman but why would he say this with no real heat on him it just draws attention, I understand why Jpap would tell everyone but not Rich. So i would like to hear Richs reasoning for (if i am right) hinting that he is the other clansman



So my vote will most likely be for Rich if JL dose not somehow confirm what Rich is saying or if Rich can convince me i am wrong.
Click to expand...

Simple I know that Jpap is right and I did not want a know innocent to be voted off so I backed his story up. I was not worried about heat on me I was assuring that we did not waste a vote on an innocent by confirming Jpap's story.

I was not worried about my survival I was doing what I thought would help find the last evil.
 
I will be traveling tomorrow and I will be busy tonight so I want to get my vote in.

Based on what Ice said about the PM's I'm moving Opi down and Lucky up. But we also don't know who is communicating/non communicating so we could possibly be left with the lep who can't send in hits. Either way I think Lucky is a better candidate now.

I vote to lynch Lucky

I have Ice as innocent as well as Rich. JL and Opi are next in line. Unless Lucky comes out as a PR and I am around I will not be changing.
 
jpap, the only power role left is the bartender and I am hoping that they send you the green beer.

It would be very odd for the bartender to come out, but I would have thought the same thing about the other cletic clan member, but that did not stop rich.

I would like to see some sort of reaction from Lucky.
 
So Rich and Jpap, care to share who you sent the shamrock to after night fall? Possible you could turn someone evil and we'll need to know who it was.

Everything points to Lucky for me. I haven't seen anything to really change my mind except maybe CJ post about Rich.

It would have been stupid for Rich to lie because Jpap would have nailed him and we'd have our last evil easily pegged.

I think we should split the votes on Lucky and whoever they shamrocks were sent to. With that person on Lucky and Lucky obviously on the other person we'll know if they got turned or the double vote or nothing.

8 Players so 4 on each. The shamrock recipient needs to vote Lucky.

If Lucky dies from votes we know it was double votes.

If it goes to a tie breaker we know that either the 50/50 failed or the player was turned. If turned an evil goes home anyway.

If its just failed we risk an innocent but can go after Lucky again.
 
I retract my vote for Lucky

It was a 4 to 4 tie. Two players had not voted yet, 20 mins before nightfall Lucky voted DD. Lucky saved it jpap from being lynched.

Lucky could be the loan evil, but serisouly doubt part of the team.
 
johnlarson66 said:
I retract my vote for Lucky

It was a 4 to 4 tie. Two players had not voted yet, 20 mins before nightfall Lucky voted DD. Lucky saved it jpap from being lynched.

Lucky could be the loan evil, but serisouly doubt part of the team.
Click to expand...

Or DD was the lone and Lucky wouldn't be the wiser to who was who. Didn't Jpap look more evil then DD based on posting?

If you were the last evil left on the team who would you have saved?
 
Here is my scaled list (1 = evil; 10 = innocent)

JPappy - 9 - came out as Celtic Clan - voted DD
Rich311k - 9 - came out as Celtic Clan - voted DD
IceH2o - 7 - has led the charge on the evils - voted DD
Johnlarson - 5 - can never tell - voted jpap
Luckydud13 - 6 - late vote on DD instead of saving DD, could have lynched jpap instead. Was online when dawg asked for PM's, most likely would have placed hit. Could be lone evil
Sploke - 3 - playing under the radar - could be lone evil - voted jpap
Opicana - 3 - atempts of being helpful, but really not adding much, passing the blame of her actions on others - voted jpap - best canidate for communicating evil - I have no clue why the hit was not put in.
cjtabares - 7 - second vote on DD - could be lone evil.

I really can't think of any reason why hits have not been put in. I gave DD a pass becuase I would think she would have made sure the hit was in and she was evil.


 
IceH2O said:
Or DD was the lone and Lucky wouldn't be the wiser to who was who. Didn't Jpap look more evil then DD based on posting?

If you were the last evil left on the team who would you have saved?
Click to expand...

I think Dawg would tell us if it was the lone evil or not, but that is an assumption. That would make sense.

I do agree that jpap looked more evil.
 
The Celtic Clan, Innocents, have 2 magic shamrocks that can be delivered. One of the shamrocks doubles a persons vote for one game night. One of them changes good to evil, or evil to good. These two (2) Innocents can communicate outside the thread. When they decide to send the magic shamrocks, they must say to who they want it delivered, at the start of the new game day; Both must let me know the chosen. There will be a 50/50 chance that the magic shamrock will work and it will be decided by a coin flip. The shamrocks must be used on game nights 2 or 3. If the magic shamrocks have not been delivered by nightfall on game night 3, I will use a random number generator to decide who gets one on night 3 and one on night 4.
Click to expand...

I need to read more of what jpap posted, but I thought they had not put it in yet. It would be good to know who they sent it to.

I am also guessing that dawg would send out a PM to whoever got it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom