Mafia 52: Killer Comes A Courtin' (The Play)

[Luvbugz]

My top suspects are Kash, JM, JL, and Ice. Townies need to go back and reread from the beginning. Watch for who follows who, who agrees with who, and who points a finger one way but then votes another. I am not surprised there was a split first day. I think it was intentional. I think it was intentional tonight as well.

 

[IceH2O]

Things started to dawn on me about 2 hours before nightfall. The thing that really struck me was DD saying I was playing a good game. Wha??? All the sudden it started to dawn on me. Maybe I have been set up. Maybe I have been made to look like I am on a team with the whole FD thing on purpose. Maybe DD was just and innocent bystander in all of this. She wasn't putting up much of a fight for herself. Course, I couldn't say for sure, but it started me thinking. Who was the first to start throwing the FD and Luv connection? Who took it to the next level of DD, Luv and FD? They probably would have known that DD and I were both innocents. They got everyone to put us up against each other. I know I had been gunning for DD all day and it would have been easy to vote DD off and then turn right to me. Pretty much making nightfall 3 as a probably mafia win. I didn't want the vote to split again and magically get "saved" again by FD. I wanted to everyone to vote for me and screw up their plans. I think that that is why some of you are really fishing for votes right now. I think I threw a wrench in your plans and now you are back to square one. Now the accusations and scum flinging has to start all over.

The logic here is flawed. If the entire attempt was to make you 3 look like a team then when DD was found innocent logic dictates you are also innocent. So you wouldn't be voted off. Now if DD was mafia then your situation above would absolutely be something to look at.

 

[Luvbugz]

Kash and JM are high on my list.

JL and Ice are a little lower, but still not off of my list.

 

[Luvbugz]

I have to go dig up the post Ice, but you already tried to implement me before the vote was cast. If DD comes up innocent then it musta been yadda yadda.. Lemme go find it.

 

[johnlarson66]

Some of jm1212 input -

Before nightfall asking someone about their vote -

any reasoning behind this?

Then after nightfall (where we lost two citiznes) this is his first post -

I vote to lynch LuvBugz

Now he gave no reason for his vote, but has the nerve to ask someone about their vote -

what is your reasoning behind this?

Kash, ignores jm1212 request for reasoning but answers Ice -

Ice, everything I was counting on to be accurate and reasonable has just been proved wrong. Tonight has been a total disaster. And there's nothing I can do to change that. While I do all I can to read through everything looking for clues and evaluating strategy from every angle I can think of, there's obviously a lot going on that I miss. It's still easy enough for me to be mislead or for me to just misread things all by myself. But one thing is certain...

There is no way under the sun that ANY mafia team in this game would hit both Coler and then DirtyDawg while still leaving you active and alive to continue playing... UNLESS you had a chair at that mafia table.

jm1212 seems to agree with Kash -

this is a very valid point...all three are veterans. but then again, only two night have gone by

I can't see how jm1212 can't be towards the top of anyones mafia list.

Besides talking about Dopehand I would like to talk about jm1212.

 

[IceH2O]

Well it doesn't dictate absolute innocent.

You still could be mafia with FD.

Depending on who grouped the 3 together you could have been grouped with DD so when she showed innocent we'd think you were also.

I know I had thoughts of you 3 being together. Not sure if I was the 1st to let that thought be known or not though

 

[IceH2O]

I have to go dig up the post Ice, but you already tried to implement me before the vote was cast. If DD comes up innocent then it musta been yadda yadda.. Lemme go find it.

I said something to the effect of you trying to pull votes because DD is more valuable to mafia team then you.

 

[johnlarson66]

Things started to dawn on me about 2 hours before nightfall. The thing that really struck me was DD saying I was playing a good game. Wha??? All the sudden it started to dawn on me. Maybe I have been set up. Maybe I have been made to look like I am on a team with the whole FD thing on purpose. Maybe DD was just and innocent bystander in all of this. She wasn't putting up much of a fight for herself. Course, I couldn't say for sure, but it started me thinking. Who was the first to start throwing the FD and Luv connection? Who took it to the next level of DD, Luv and FD? They probably would have known that DD and I were both innocents. They got everyone to put us up against each other. I know I had been gunning for DD all day and it would have been easy to vote DD off and then turn right to me. Pretty much making nightfall 3 as a probably mafia win. I didn't want the vote to split again and magically get "saved" again by FD. I wanted to everyone to vote for me and screw up their plans. I think that that is why some of you are really fishing for votes right now. I think I threw a wrench in your plans and now you are back to square one. Now the accusations and scum flinging has to start all over.

I stated the Luv, DD and FD connection. I didn't create it, it is (was) there. I do think there might have been some sort of angle there, for what reason I am not sure.

 

[Luvbugz]

You are right it was JL who was linking DD, me and FD together.

 

[Luvbugz]

Wow it got quiet all the sudden here...