Mafia 52: Killer Comes A Courtin' (The Play)

[johnlarson66]

What is your reasoning for thinking I am mafia Ice? Is it still over the pizza comment? Truly the only reason I said you (Ice) and DD only got it is because no one else referred to the joke directly. Everyone else seemed to just be chiming in with what they liked on their pizzas. I wasn't even sure if Kash got it. Maybe I didn't give everyone else enough credit.

Here is my list:

DD: Didn't vote at all last night, but kept pointing towards me all day yesterday saying she would probably vote for me. I think that DD is mafia. She knew Noods, me , and MC weren't mafia (she couldn't have known MC was the SK) and therefore didn't wanna draw too much attention to herself by making a tie breaking vote. None of them were mafia, so she wasn't gonna lose any buddies, so she didn't care.

Kash: Very quiet this time around. Don't know if that is just because she isn't having to defend herself from the get go or not. Still up in the air.

Rich: Looks like he is defending DD today. Hmmmm.

JM: Hmmmmm...

Noods: Has totally fooled me before. I thought for sure she was mafia my first game, but she was communicating innocent. I don't know what to think, but does seem like she is trying to help the town; more so then some.

Ice: The whole Coler/Ice thing yesterday was weird. Don't know if he is riding Coler's innocent coat tails or is truly trying to help the townies. So far, has been makin some great points and been somewhat helpful.. Dunno..

JL: Doesn't post or vote first day. Comes in outta the blue on the second day, votes DD first thing. Gives what I think is a decent reason for not being on the first day. Up in the air.

TRS: Usually comes in guns a blazin' to every game. Where is he?

Dopehand: ?????

I was reading back looking into the whole DD/FD/Luv connection and found this post.

Now this is not a list of all of the players. As a matter of fact the bottom two had not even posted yet. I think there were 3 all together that hadn't posted. Does anyone else think her bringing up Dopehand at this time was odd? I understand TRS, there is some past playing - but why Dopehand? It would be different if it was a list of all of the players. There are players that signed up that I don't even remember their names.

 

[Luvbugz]

Now you are gunning for me JL when you wouldn't vote for me when I asked you to earlier?? Wha?? I love how you are lobbying for Ice's vote.

 

[IceH2O]

Sorry was looking into Jm, So far really only the Dr thing bothers me.


From the quote JL pulled from Luv.

Here she ties herself to MC and Noods saying all 3 innocent and DD mafia. Do we assume Noods is innocent now that we know DD and MC were?

Rich got a defending DD hmmm.... should we assume innocence here also?

I do see the point about naming only 2 of the new players. Why not name Agi and Mav also which are new and pretty new to the game?

 

[IceH2O]

Now you are gunning for me JL when you wouldn't vote for me when I asked you to earlier?? Wha?? I love how you are lobbying for Ice's vote.

Right now I'm more concerned with FDs voting. With the limited posts its hard to build any case.

You've been a suspect of mine since Day 1, don't think anyone needs to lobby a vote for you from me.

I'm to the point where I need to try and see innocence to narrow the field, just been hard with the voting patterns to do that without lynching mafia yet.

But thats why we need early votes and reasons for those votes. That way we can see a trend of protection or scum moves.

 

[johnlarson66]

There are a bunch of quotes, this was also in the middle of jm1212 wanting to know who I thought the doctor was.

Here Luv states about DD not voting for her and placed her vote for her and is okay with the excuse from FD (noods was not btw) -

No one more than me is shocked that DD did not vote for me. I waited all night for her vote. I truly did not think I would be here today hence my vote for her.

Where does that put FD then? I dunno. I truly think she is busy with her baby and didn't get to vote until the last second. At least she did vote.

Here I point out the defense of FD -

Hmmm, FD saves you from a coin flip and you defend her.

Was a last second vote better than a no vote? Since it was your rear she was saving, I can't see you having an abjective comment.

What also has me concerned is that FD clearly stated that she did not like the votes on Luvz. If you look at the votes on MC, they are even weaker than the ones on Luvz. Really when is there a real good reason for voting someone on Day One. There was no good reason to save Luvz or lynch MC.

This Luvz and FD connection needs watched.

Here is when I add DD into the mix -

I agree that MC's post and vote switch was just a way of saying good-bye.

The tie was over. When there was a tie, DD and FD both were non-voters who had posted in the thread. DD had a suspect. I am not sure of FD. FD did save Luvz and stated that she was doing so. (no save for noods - but she saved noods also from a coin toss)

Since I was not playing at the time, and I know that MC was the SK, it is hard for me to be too abjective about the votes on MC.

Hindsight is 20/20.

mav makes some points -

I vote to lynch Luvbugz

not only has luv looked scummy to me from near the beginning but i think knowing her role will give us insite into FD and DD voting/nonvoting. I know noods was in the same position as luv was but the fact she had jpaps vote makes me hesitant to vote on her and i don't think she looks a scummy as luv does

Here is where I connect the three -

I see this also. Luvbugz is no longer leaning innocent for me. I do have noods more innocent and think it is strange that FD spoke to save Luvbugz and not noods. There was no reason to even mention Luvbugz. FD's vote was more of a save than a lynch. Maybe this was to win Luvbugz over or protect them.

I am more for getting to the bottom of DD first, then looking into Luvbuz. I think all three of them (DD, FD, and Luvbugz) are somehow connected.

Now we know that DD was innocent and was in a close lynch with Luv. FD comes in and posts a worthless vote for Kash being unwilling to vote for either.

 

[Luvbugz]

I ask again JL if you think I was mafia from the beginning why not go ahead and vote me out when I asked??

 

[johnlarson66]

Now you are gunning for me JL when you wouldn't vote for me when I asked you to earlier?? Wha?? I love how you are lobbying for Ice's vote.

Luv, how I am gunning for you?

Seems like I am voting for Dopeland and think jm1212 is a good suspect.

If you want to explain you post, then explain it. Asking questions is not "gunning". Your defensiveness and drama is quite tiring. You are not a noob.

How in the world am I lobbying for Ice's vote. I am fairly sure me voting for someone will be a good enough reason for Ice not voting for them.

 

[IceH2O]

If I were to take that list and pull off every name as innocent

DD:
MC
Kash:
Rich:
JM:
Noods:
Ice:
JL:
TRS:
Dopehand:


That leaves mafia as

Luv
maverickbr77
Agassizii
FireDancer7905
Jpap who we know was.

Agi as I said was on earlier but decided to not post or vote.

 

[johnlarson66]

I ask again JL if you think I was mafia from the beginning why not go ahead and vote me out when I asked??

Luv, in the beginning I had you leaning innocent.

Why would I vote for someone when they ask? If you wanted to die so bad, then vote for yourself or quit for that matter.

 

[IceH2O]

Wonder what happens if we match up Fires list with Luvs. I'll have to see if she even made one yet but she is usually good for one. We know the others haven't.