Mafia 52: Killer Comes A Courtin' (The Play)

[Dopehand]

I hate to say it, but I don't really think TRS is mafia. Working evenings sure makes things interesting seeing as I don't get to see the lead-in to nightfall.

TRS might be ineffectual in his voting, but guilty? I don't really think so.

 

[IceH2O]

I hate to say it, but I don't really think TRS is mafia. Working evenings sure makes things interesting seeing as I don't get to see the lead-in to nightfall.

TRS might be ineffectual in his voting, but guilty? I don't really think so.

So maybe you want to take the lead here give us your suspect and why then vote them?

The way you point fingers without actually pointing to someone makes me nervous.

 

[IceH2O]

You guys fail, and mafia is going to take over this town. Ice me and you are not mafia, were innocents. rich and JL are mafia. Yet I am the only one who didn't vote for kash?? I didn't vote for agas, but didn't for for a innocent either. I also said luv is a innocent, but then again no one listened. Noodles, you can vote for all JL.

I am not going to sit here and waste my time anymore, as in we lost. Good game, as in a prediction as in ice is going to get with me being lynched, which leaves mafia in charge.

You knowing all these people are innocent is what scares me and why I did vote your way. Show me that JL is mafia that Rich is mafia and maybe I'll lift my vote but feelings don't work. Show me the post that made you think mafia then a post that solidified your thought.

 

[noodles62]

I agree that TRS's "feelings" are not proof in my mind and the idea that he seems to know all, scares me a bit, but I am not so sure he is mafia. I am more inclined to look at the others on the poster; JL, Ice & Dope. Agass was on the poster and found scum, Kash was on it and found inno. I do not want to claim that TRS and Rich are innocent, I just want to look at everyone..... I have the day off so I can spend some of it reading over this HUGE thread again to see what I come up with.

 

[noodles62]

Want to post my thoughts while they are fresh on my mind.....
I vote to lynch Dopehand.
I have been looking over my spreadsheet of the votes and here is how Dope has been voting:
Night 1 - no vote
Night 2 - late, kill vote on DD, (known inno)
Night 3 - pulled off FD (known mafia) for lone vote on Kash
Night 4 - first vote on Agass (known mafia), did not move but posted that mafia might hit him cause he was not playing anyway. (will find quote later)
Night 5 - kill vote on Kash (known inno)

I am thinking that Dope is the last mafia, however if there is one more left I would guess it is JL....

Will post more in a bit, I need to get some things done around here.

 

[noodles62]

OK! I have to post these and then go! LOL

Even though we were correct about Ag, his(?) behavior mystifies me. I just don't understand why a mafia member would view the thread periodically and only throw in a couple posts. Backfired silence strategy, mayhaps? Luvbugz was my third pick..........I still don't feel rock solid about JL being mafia. TRS is still a favorite of mine, as I could see the mafia hit perhaps being orchestrated by him(?).

Covering, distancing himself from Agass, maybe?

Conversation between JL & I:

Isn't it possible that a mafia member hid among the votes for Agas? I personally do not think you not voting Agas makes you suspicious - you were not here to make any moves or comments regarding your vote.....

Since Agas was mafia, I think the numbers favor us. I can't see there being more than two left. I am guessing there is just one.

If there is just one, I can't see a mafia member voting for a teamate. Maybe if there were two left. If we are still going after me, TRS and Kash are gone then that will mean that a mafia member voted for Agas.

If JL is involved, he was not around to tell Dope to move off of Agass....plus Dope works evenings and is not around at nightfall....just a thought

If agas' explanation is to be held as completely sincere, I would think that a mafia member would hold no compunctions about voting for them since they were largely inactive anyway and didn't understand how the game works. I don't think you could definitively say that the folks who voted ag aren't mafia themselves. While it would be nice to have the extra person, you could certainly gain credibility by lynching ag as well.

I'm pretty neutral on the ag lynch, I don't think a whole lot of conclusions can be drawn from it due to his inactivity.

This is the quote I was referring to in my last post....Dope does not seem to think it is a prob for mafia to vote for agass due to his inactivity....things that make ya go hhhmmmmm.

Not sure on JL, but I am pretty sure about Dope. Just wanted to put it out there to see what others think.

 

[noodles62]

OK! I have to post these and then go! LOL

Covering, distancing himself from Agass, maybe?

Conversation between JL & I:



If JL is involved, he was not around to tell Dope to move off of Agass....plus Dope works evenings and is not around at nightfall....just a thought



This is the quote I was referring to in my last post....Dope does not seem to think it is a prob for mafia to vote for agass due to his inactivity....things that make ya go hhhmmmmm.

Not sure on JL, but I am pretty sure about Dope. Just wanted to put it out there to see what others think.

Correction - the last 2 quotes from Dope are the ones I was referring to. My red highlight did not catch both.

 

[rich311k]

Some pretty good points Noodles. Both TRS and Dope have pretty interesting voting patterns. So TRS was a prime suspect of his but now he is not mafia.

Dope do you have a reason for that or a necessity now since it is crunch time?

 

[Dopehand]

Do I have a reason for my voting pattern?

Prior to night 1, swamped at work.
Night 2, thought I was far more clever than I actually was.
Night 3, after my rather in-your-face failure with the DD tiebreaker, I just didn't want to tie it up or again have my vote be instrumental in the lynching death of a citizen. Who turned out to be mafia, which made me look shady.
Night 4, I really wanted Ag gone as I figured regardless of his citizen/mafia status, the damage to the team would not be significant.
Night 5, By this time I figured that Kash was mafia, along with Ag and FD, and thought it probable a more experienced player was guiding them.

I said a mafia member would have no problem voting for ag due to his inactivity. I was merely pointing out that maybe a free pass for us was not in order. I wasn't trying to implicate myself. I certainly wouldn't have pointed out something for you if i were mafia.

 

[Dopehand]

So maybe you want to take the lead here give us your suspect and why then vote them?

The way you point fingers without actually pointing to someone makes me nervous.

I'm not pointing fingers at anybody, I just find out of the remaining players, that TRS is an odd choice to go for so quickly when it's just as likely it's one of you crafty, experienced types.

It's hard to say that TRS "knew" things when it happened that his impulses lucked out and he happened to be right a few times. I just find it less likely that unless he's being coached he would point out innocents and then hit them or something.