Mafia 56. An Unknown Evil. THE GAME....

[dirtydawg10]

Dawg is looking guiltier and guiltier to me. He is now backpedaling really hard from coming on so strong against me last night. I am not sure if all the names on the list are evil or not, but with your over the top reaction to it and now backpedalling when called on your reaction makes me really think there is something to that list. Seems like it has really struck a nerve with a few.

My list:

Rocker - has only come on and voted and then disappeared again doesn't nessisarily make a person evil, but def. suspicious seems like he is really trying to slide under the radar

Annie - Annie has been on my list since day one with his quick vote on Ogre when called on it his logic was very flawed yes, I know he wasn't possessed as of last night, but that doesn't mean he still couldnt be the KGB leader or something (I am flip flopping with this)

Dawg - His name on the list actually surprised me Dawg was completely off my radar his huge reaction to his name being on the list his bs theory about me being a newspaper reporter that has been turned?? or whatever it is is laughable had he not reacted so strongly I woulda been thinking the list contained innocent names as well as evil (him being the innocent) but he is now leaning evil to me such a strong reaction musta struck a nerve

JM- the cold water reference was just plain weird I am wondering if he isn't a lower evil and trying to pull attention off the list because it contains the name of his leader


I do think it is reasonable to suspect that either Kash or DD has been turned. I would suspect Kash more than DD because DD's powers are spent. At the moment, I am not seeing anything horriblely suspicious on their parts, but they are surely people to watch.

I would be happy to vote for JM, Rocker, Dawg, Annie With Dawg and JM being my top two ATM because of their weird reactions after nightfall


I retract my vote on Rocker and vote to lynch Dawg.

Not backpedaling at all. If you notice my vote is still on you Luv. I'm just trying to rethink my thoughts since I'm seeing where my theory was flawed. I'm still not convinced that all the exorcists are innocent otherwise why would their roles be revealed? Was that part of their power? If they use their power their role would be revealed?

What I'm finding much more peculiar about the list than my reaction is that everyone in the town seems to blindly following it based on Luv's comments...and not questioning the validity of it.

I guess there is no way to know unless someone from the list is voted off.

 

[Luvbugz]

Yes, it said that our roles would be revealed if we failed an excorism aka if the person we tried to exorcize was not possesed. My pm said I could do as many excorsisms as I wanted until I failed, then I would lose faith and be revealed as a failed excorsist.

 

[Kashta]

Not backpedaling at all. If you notice my vote is still on you Luv. I'm just trying to rethink my thoughts since I'm seeing where my theory was flawed. I'm still not convinced that all the exorcists are innocent otherwise why would their roles be revealed? Was that part of their power? If they use their power their role would be revealed?

What I'm finding much more peculiar about the list than my reaction is that everyone in the town seems to blindly following it based on Luv's comments...and not questioning the validity of it.

I guess there is no way to know unless someone from the list is voted off.

Dawg, I've been looking up those references and reading the thread over again from Day 1. In my book, Luvbugz has a LOT more credibility right now than you do. A lot of things she has been posting seem dead on.

Here's another example of this where she's talking about JM's odd behavior all of a sudden.

Somebody big is on that list. That is the only reason I can think that JM would be pulling what he is. He is trying to draw the heat off of someone. Dawg?? Annie??

Agree with this completely... JM's done that before too. He got rattled in the vampire game and made a similar slip. That lead to both vamps getting killed that night, one by town lynch.. the other by the hunter's shot.

 

[Luvbugz]

The reason I am following the list is because two known evils are on that list: Rich (who was turned) and Phoniex who was the KGB assassin. That right there leads me to believe there is AT LEAST one more name on that list that is evil. Also, two people that were already on my list are on that list. Concidence?? I think not.

 

[Luvbugz]

My theory: Our CIA assassin might be trying to give us some clues through the newspaper on who has been investigated and turned up evil. That's just my take on it.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Yes, it said that our roles would be revealed if we failed an excorism aka if the person we tried to exorcize was not possesed. My pm said I could do as many excorsisms as I wanted until I failed, then I would lose faith and be revealed as a failed excorsist.

OK that makes more sense then.

In my book, Luvbugz has a LOT more credibility right now than you do. A lot of things she has been posting seem dead on..

I don't disagree with this except the part about her being dead on.

Here's another example of this where she's talking about JM's odd behavior all of a sudden.



Agree with this completely... JM's done that before too. He got rattled in the vampire game and made a similar slip. That lead to both vamps getting killed that night, one by town lynch.. the other by the hunter's shot.

OK but JM is not on the list. So you are trying to tell me that there are 4 evils left in this game even after 2 have already been taken out? That's a total of 6 out of 15 players. That just doesn't seem right to me. Too lopsided. Especially since it seems that the possessed can turn others to their side.

 

[IceH2O]

I haven't had a chance to pull the posts with the headline word,just wanted to comment on some posts.

It says in the nightly events that Luv has lost faith. This is different from when DD used her exorcism power. Not sure exactly what it means though. Maybe she WAS turned?

As its been pointed out DDs said the same thing,I'm wondering why you didn't bring mine up as me being turned also?

Sure is quiet today. We know Ogre was telling the truth about his role now.. I find it a little disappointing that no one is posting about him to follow up with all that after his death. Reading through Ogre's posts again.. that must have been frustrating. He tried real hard to tell us everything he could before nightfall. I didn't even go right back to it though... got caught up looking up those references from the newspaper headline instead.

Having done that, I have a suspect list finally. That's a big difference too. Yesterday we couldn't find any suspects (other than Ogre) - today we've got too many to pick from.

Here are my suspects (not in any ranked order yet): Dawg, Rocker, Annie, JM, and Coler. This is a bit daunting too.. holy crap, it's half the remaining players who are still alive.

1. Dawg/Rocker/Annie because of the newspaper quotes taken directly from their posts.

2. JM because he weirded out on us with those key words too.

3. Coler because Ogre wanted him dead so badly.

Not sure on Coler,all I know is he isn't possessed right now. Could be KGB but to say so because Ogre wanted him dead is flawed. Luv was also a suspect.

 

[dirtydawg10]

The reason I am following the list is because two known evils are on that list: Rich (who was turned) and Phoniex who was the KGB assassin. That right there leads me to believe there is AT LEAST one more name on that list that is evil. Also, two people that were already on my list are on that list. Concidence?? I think not.

Rich was also clearly an asset to the town as Wycco pointed out. I can also see why it would be easy for you to follow the list when 2 of your suspects were on the list.

My theory: Our CIA assassin might be trying to give us some clues through the newspaper on who has been investigated and turned up evil. That's just my take on it.

I don't think it was the assassin who does the investigating. And I doubt they investigated 3 evils since it was night 2.

 

[Luvbugz]

Rich was also clearly an asset to the town as Wycco pointed out. I can also see why it would be easy for you to follow the list when 2 of your suspects were on the list.




I don't think it was the assassin who does the investigating. And I doubt they investigated 3 evils since it was night 2.

I meant our CIA investagator.

 

[dirtydawg10]

As its been pointed out DDs said the same thing,I'm wondering why you didn't bring mine up as me being turned also?

Because I thought that Luv's said something different than DD's and I didn't really pay much attention to your's, Ice. I already admitted that I effed that one up and that DD's was similar to Luv's.