OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
The boy has lost his mind. Well, that was a nearly wasted day. Although I do think I found some people that are helping the town more than not.
Mafia 58-
- Thread starter IceH2O
- Start date
That stinks. No way to play if I have a say in the matter.
I retract my vote on Noods and vote to lynch Annie.
I am not a big fan of hit and run votes.
I retract my vote on Noods and vote to lynch Annie.
I am not a big fan of hit and run votes.
I haven't kept track "officially" but I want to say it's 3-3 between Annie and Gun.
I vote to lynch Gun
I think between Gun and Annie its a tossup. Both came in with a vote and no reasoning but knowing Annie I find it more unlike him given the fact that we don't know who Gun is. Annie has been a little more talkative though...I pretty much just picked one to be honest.
DD, yes I skimmed twice...whoop dee doodle doo. If skimming = mafia, then by all means consider me a top suspect.
I vote to lynch Gun
I think between Gun and Annie its a tossup. Both came in with a vote and no reasoning but knowing Annie I find it more unlike him given the fact that we don't know who Gun is. Annie has been a little more talkative though...I pretty much just picked one to be honest.
DD, yes I skimmed twice...whoop dee doodle doo. If skimming = mafia, then by all means consider me a top suspect.
Just back today now with a quick read to catch up. Going through what's been posting, the way I have this figured is I think Woody must be non-communicating mafia. In his first game, he was innocent... and now he's trying to figure out how to be evil instead, but also more involved... without benefit of anyone to help him out.
Then I got to this post of his.
Okay.. that's just lovely. So the guy says he's going to quit and nothing he's been doing mattered. That might be true... OR it might be his idea that bluffing this way but THEN posting a last-minute vote just before nightfall might be his only way of saving his own arse. It pulls votes off him so he won't get lynched, while leaving him in control to make a vote and avoid the UD.
If Woody did send a PM to the game mod and Ice bothers to confirm this for us... then I'll drop him. But until that happens, I'm not going to buy into anything Woody tells us he's going to do.
Also... whatever was in Woody's head about his interpretation of the rules when someone quits may or may not be correct.
I vote to lynch Woody
Subject to change.
Then I got to this post of his.
i believe its time.
im heading off to work here in the next ten minutes or so....and guess what. i wont be back.
it seems i have almost all votes on methe bad thing is....im going to UD.
friday night i found out i am going to be busy almost all this week. with work, the end of the trimester, and a marriage in the family thats about to go down.....theres no time to be lynching people on the internet. so i figured i would have some fun on saturday
i must admit that Rich and Noods are not on my team at all.....i just thought it would be fun to see how some people would take the thing i said.
in fact, i cannot communicate with anybody this game...but im not going to tell you what side i am on...you will find that out "tomorrow"
im sorry for any of you die-hard mafioso out there who think i may have ruined a night of this game by messing around...but hey, i doubt any of you are that extreme.
so yeah. i dont think i missed anything...i will check up on this thread tonight to see if i got hit with a double whammy (UD and the noose) and i will try and look at this thread throughout the rest of the week to see if my suspisions were correct or false.
so rich....you were right about 40 or so posts ago when you said that the train could be random fun.
good day all :frog:
Okay.. that's just lovely. So the guy says he's going to quit and nothing he's been doing mattered. That might be true... OR it might be his idea that bluffing this way but THEN posting a last-minute vote just before nightfall might be his only way of saving his own arse. It pulls votes off him so he won't get lynched, while leaving him in control to make a vote and avoid the UD.
If Woody did send a PM to the game mod and Ice bothers to confirm this for us... then I'll drop him. But until that happens, I'm not going to buy into anything Woody tells us he's going to do.
Also... whatever was in Woody's head about his interpretation of the rules when someone quits may or may not be correct.
I vote to lynch Woody
Subject to change.
I would also like to know why he pulled my name (as well as Rich's) out his.....the air? This is only his second game and I did not play with him last game...in fact I have not played in the last 2-3 games, so why me? Who told him to make me suspect? I had done nothing prior to his statement to make me stand out (IMO). Just makes me even more uncomfortable.
I have no idea, Noods. He's obviously not taking the game seriously and his play style is idiotic. But until he is killed off or quits or UDs on purpose... I'll leave my vote on him to help push him out the door. I think he's trying to play boldly and has no idea how to approach the game from a mafia role. Either way it's a 50-50 call which side he's on. As a townie, he would have a better idea how to be helpful having been on that side last time. But as mafia, maybe his best guess was jump in a confuse people.
I understand what you are getting at Kash. If Wood does show up last minute he is a shoe-in for tomorrow's vote...no questions asked. Hopefully Ice takes his post as him quitting, whether he was PM'ed or not, so we don't have to waste another day on Wood. It's just ridiculous.
Noods, you do make a good point and I had forgotten that you did not play last game. Weird play by Wood. The main reason I do not suspect any behind the scenes plans is because I really don't see either you or Rich doing something to this extent. Rich especially. He can easily glide through a game without having to resort to cheesy tactics like this. If Wood is a communicating mafia, I don't see you two as his teammates.
If he is non-communicating, well then at least we are down one and know that he was just trying to stir things up. Same thing goes for if he is innocent except we're down an innocent who had no idea what they were doing, and in the end could have hurt the town more than helped. I hate it when people use that to justify lynching an innocent but I don't think anyone who has been following the game could look at what Wood has said and not believe that he was anti-town, no matter the role.
Noods, you do make a good point and I had forgotten that you did not play last game. Weird play by Wood. The main reason I do not suspect any behind the scenes plans is because I really don't see either you or Rich doing something to this extent. Rich especially. He can easily glide through a game without having to resort to cheesy tactics like this. If Wood is a communicating mafia, I don't see you two as his teammates.
If he is non-communicating, well then at least we are down one and know that he was just trying to stir things up. Same thing goes for if he is innocent except we're down an innocent who had no idea what they were doing, and in the end could have hurt the town more than helped. I hate it when people use that to justify lynching an innocent but I don't think anyone who has been following the game could look at what Wood has said and not believe that he was anti-town, no matter the role.
