Mafia 58-

[Dangerdoll]

DD, I did not say YOU saved wood...if you have been following the conversations at all Kashta has named players who she thinks tried to. That little aside was supposed to describe me, Dawg, and Zaffy.

What does that bolded part even mean? I already said that Dawg and I share two top suspects.


My reasoning has never indicated that I am positive of you being mafia DD. I said that you are my top suspect, as evidenced by my vote.

If you read my post, I asked if you were saying that I was trying to save Wood. I said I never tried saving wood and wondered where you got that from, if you were meaning I tried saving him.


the bolded part means just what it says.... I asked you both why neither of you had each other listed on your lists of suspects. This means, you did not show Dawg on your list and Dawg didn't show you on his current list. When I askedyou both about it, you both claim you each haven't cleared each other, that simply have each other lower on your lists.

Where is the evidence, pap?

 

[Dangerdoll]

I think Paps is a very good player.

I'm assuming you mean where would I rank him on a scum scale? Some where in the middle of the road. I don't have a good read on him as usual.

really.... how convenient

Should read "I did not try to say YOU saved wood"

"try to".... ok...

 

[jpappy789]

Well after all I have read through I think kash's posts have convinced me of my vote for you....with a little OMGUS mixed in. And I am aware my so called "day one case on wood was before he UD'd....still why would I change my vot to him after finding he was UDing. As I have said I was thinking about changing my vote, was behind on following the game, and when I caught up it was pointless to change my vote.

No, your post was before he even indicated that he would UD. You had the chance to vote for him while he was still playing the game.

I find two things odd here:

1) Now you are using the UD excuse, but in your post about Wood you said you didn't like the train. Did you forget? Having a hard time keeping your facts straight?

2) You use Kash's argument to support your vote. A main part of that argument is that a group of players retracted their votes off of Wood who was potentially going to UD, but that was actually a move to "save" him in case he came back. You said yourself that you wouldn't vote for a player who was going to UD. Hmmm...

 

[ZSandmann]

10 minutes and Pappy leads it.

 

[noodles62]

10 minutes and Pappy leads it.

what are you talking about? did i miss something here?

 

[Dangerdoll]

Pappy leads what?

 

[mostlycichlids]

No, your post was before he even indicated that he would UD. You had the chance to vote for him while he was still playing the game.

I find two things odd here:

1) Now you are using the UD excuse, but in your post about Wood you said you didn't like the train. Did you forget? Having a hard time keeping your facts straight?

2) You use Kash's argument to support your vote. A main part of that argument is that a group of players retracted their votes off of Wood who was potentially going to UD, but that was actually a move to "save" him in case he came back. You said yourself that you wouldn't vote for a player who was going to UD. Hmmm...

Dude you are not getting it.....I have only logged into AC today.....was not on yesterday at all....Thought about logging in to change my vote, never did.....Get it now? I never quoted anything from kash's case, I really don't see any reason to be more specific...also said it was partial OMGUS...unless you have already forgotten.

 

[jpappy789]

If you read my post, I asked if you were saying that I was trying to save Wood. I said I never tried saving wood and wondered where you got that from, if you were meaning I tried saving him.


the bolded part means just what it says.... I asked you both why neither of you had each other listed on your lists of suspects. This means, you did not show Dawg on your list and Dawg didn't show you on his current list. When I askedyou both about it, you both claim you each haven't cleared each other, that simply have each other lower on your lists.

Where is the evidence, pap?

It was supposed to say something to the effect of me, Zaffy, Dawg, etc. theoretically saving Wood.

The bolded part, to me, asked why is Dawg not at the top of my list...ummm, maybe because I don't find him as scummy?

And basically that is what you were trying to ask. Why would I just put someone on my list if I don't think they are more likely mafia? I only have 4 people there...the rest of the players (including Dawg) haven't done anything to make me think otherwise.

DD I am voting for you because: you barely acknowledged what Wood said, made a mess over Dawg's comment and I still don't understand what you meant, and that little I meant to vote so and so thing (kind of like the cherry on top).

really.... how convenient



"try to".... ok...

Make sense? Sorry for the confusion.

 

[jpappy789]

10 minutes and Pappy leads it.

Dude you are not getting it.....I have only logged into AC today.....was not on yesterday at all....Thought about logging in to change my vote, never did.....Get it now? I never quoted anything from kash's case, I really don't see any reason to be more specific...also said it was partial OMGUS...unless you have already forgotten.

LOL, Mc you are not getting it. The post I am referring to was prior to any talk about Wood UD'ing so that excuse makes no sense. I am talking about the post where you said some things in response to Wood but "didn't like the train" and voted Annie out of left field instead.


And you said yourself that based on what Kash said you think I am scum...if so, then what specifically? Alluding to what others have said but not explaining exactly what brought you to your vote is both lazy and scummy.

 

[ZSandmann]

I need to learn how to count, disregard anything I say about votes