Mafia 58-

[jpappy789]

QuestionPap? Since Dawg did turn up Communicating Mafia, why would the accusations Kash and DD have been "spewing" about you be BS?? Please "splain"....not sure I get this, but then again I don't do that "new math" either!

Noods I don't know, to be honest. They implicated me, so of course I'm not going to agree with it, because I know that at least that part is wrong...Kash pretty much put me and Dawg in the driver's seat (thats how I viewed it), so the whole theory is still BS in my mind. I will say that I certainly didn't see it from Dawg but I also can't rule out the fact that he tried to appear close to me for a reason. Sounds like I'm saving my neck, and it kind of is, but it's all I have to explain it.

Dawg being mafia threw me for a loop. I'm moving DD down the list to be a consideration for a non-communicating mafia, especially with the way TRS and MC are acting lately. They are moving up...

But with the headlines, I have to have Kash and Rich somewhere since it's 50/50. Kash was right about Dawg, so she too would have to be non-communicating. I don't see Rich being so obvious as hitting Jb though but he is still a good possibility.

 

[mostlycichlids]

Why would MC be first on your list and you would not vote for him?

annie did vote for me.

 

[noodles62]

jpap, I voted for rich before jbrat did.... I think he is mafia, and said that for a while now. Why I think rich is mafia is because he is laying back, not arguing with anyone and not trying to point out mafia. Now Sandman, for a while there you were grilling jbrat pretty good.

ok TRS, This is now day three. it is a known fact that Rich ALWAYS lays back, which by the way I dont like, but does not guarantee he is mafia.....
Now I agree that the current headline certainly makes him a person of much more interest, but do you have anything ELSE to offer in this game? You have really not put anything else out there - no theories, no evidence, no damning posts....nothing! You seem to be skating through this game without much input and quite frankly guilty of the same thing you are accusing Rich of.....makes me think you are scummy too. To coin a phrase from another player..."Just sayin".
Show me why I should follow you and vote for Rich.

............sorry, I have a had a couple beers and am gettin sassy! (I have the day off tomorrow and I deserve it!)

 

[ZSandmann]

jpap, I voted for rich before jbrat did.... I think he is mafia, and said that for a while now. Why I think rich is mafia is because he is laying back, not arguing with anyone and not trying to point out mafia. Now Sandman, for a while there you were grilling jbrat pretty good.

"For a while there" = one post but yes I did not like JB's style of play.

When I made that post he replied with a few posts that made me reevaluate my thoughts of him and as such I removed him as a suspect. Was there a follow-up to that?

 

[jpappy789]

this is false by the way.

Sev votes for rich
JB makes case for rich

I never said it was perfectly in order, I didn't check because it doesn't matter who voted first. You both voted for rich, and the innocent one is dead. Perfect opportunity for you to implicate rich along with the headline.

Of course, this would mean that Kash is mafia (based on the "true" headline) and I'm not very confident about that.

Now you are just putting words in my mouth, I think I have already explained myself and my reasons. It means I have you as a suspect but not 100% sure if you are mafia yet? I am on the fence with you but would not hesitate to vote you either....not contradictory just not 100% convinced.

Not 100% convinced but apparently enough for you to vote for me. Your counterargument to whatever I said was that you never said that I was scum...a vote, unless Day 1, pretty much means that you think that person is more likely mafia than the others. It's not like you said it was random or a throw away. You stated someone else's logic to even back it up.

 

[The Red Severum]

Noods, I have played with rich in a some games in the past, rich has two game types. One is going out and agreeing with people, adding more on to other peoples thoughts, and when he plays like that is usually a innocent of sometype. Then rich plays games like this one, where he doesn't bother to jump in and agree and add thoughts, he just sits back, only talking when someone is pointing the finger at him, which means he is usually mafia.

 

[rich311k]

I do not know what the headline is about. I do know I voted for a mobster and I would like to think I am smarter than hitting my number one accuser. Maybe the mob has a good reason to kill me off.

 

[OgreMkV]

I disagree MC.... Dawg (& Jpap) was all over Kashta so I think htat headline was to implicate her in case he lost the tie tonight...... not sure about the Rich reference yet, but certainly worht looking into.

Thank you, Bala, for an excellent coin toss!!!

Hahahaha.. nice try, scumbag reporter. There's no way in hell I was working with Dawg. But it's a cute attempt to discredit me and the suspicions I've been posting about so much the last two days.

This also shows I'm on the right track with at least some part of what I've been saying. Now, we just need to narrow things down even more to figure out what made the mafia reporter nervous enough to try this.

I don't get this one, friend. Dawg and Jpappy were both after Rich. We know now that Dawg was scum and we'll find out about Pappy too when we get to him. Please be clear with your headlines for us.. we need your help too, hon.

Hi guys,

1) no I have not caught up on yesterday.
2) I did not know dawg had two votes when I voted for him. Though I'm glad I did, it was a lucky accident. I was voting to not UD.
3) From the rules

"
One non communicating innocent and 1 non communicating mafia will get investigations.
They will also be able to publish a newspaper headline. You will not know which side the headlines are from."

so both noods and kash that the journalists are somehow involved is mistaken. The journalists are either A) reporting the results of investigation or B) making stuff up.

One J is innocent the other is mafia. Obviously the innocent J is trying to tell us who to vote. The mafia J is making stuff up. Which is which?

Even if we 'test' one of them, that doesn't mean anything. Headline style can be copied, names dropped for any or no reason. Each case really needs more than a headline to vote.

To choose one of the two, is to gamble. Which way do you want to go? Or do you want to think about everything else?

JB was non-communicating so that doesn't help us with the Jpap/TRS thing.

Of everything I've heard so far, the only thing that has me interested is Annie quoting MC saying that he[MC] sees Dawg's logic. It really doesn't make sense for a communicating mafia to say that to another communicating mafia, normally mafia want to be as far away from each other as possible (unless there is a plan).

Based on this shakey tree of logic, I vote to lynch Annie.

 

[rich311k]

Noods, I have played with rich in a some games in the past, rich has two game types. One is going out and agreeing with people, adding more on to other peoples thoughts, and when he plays like that is usually a innocent of sometype. Then rich plays games like this one, where he doesn't bother to jump in and agree and add thoughts, he just sits back, only talking when someone is pointing the finger at him, which means he is usually mafia.

I believe I made several posts putting my thoughts out there. I was also correct by the way.

 

[noodles62]

Noods I don't know, to be honest. They implicated me, so of course I'm not going to agree with it, because I know that at least that part is wrong...Kash pretty much put me and Dawg in the driver's seat (thats how I viewed it), so the whole theory is still BS in my mind. I will say that I certainly didn't see it from Dawg but I also can't rule out the fact that he tried to appear close to me for a reason. Sounds like I'm saving my neck, and it kind of is, but it's all I have to explain it.

Dawg being mafia threw me for a loop. I'm moving DD down the list to be a consideration for a non-communicating mafia, especially with the way TRS and MC are acting lately. They are moving up...

But with the headlines, I have to have Kash and Rich somewhere since it's 50/50. Kash was right about Dawg, so she too would have to be non-communicating. I don't see Rich being so obvious as hitting Jb though but he is still a good possibility.

Why would hitting JB be obvious for anyone? He was not really agressive.....