Mafia 62- The Play

[IceH2O]

I don't see why you would be trying so hard to stay in the game if you're innocent anyways.

Thanks Mich.
You also said earlier my strategy had changed. Since you've never played I'm assuming you're using an excuse that others have brought up.
Always alarms me when a new player votes me. Usually they are told to vote me as they wouldn't know to do it on their own.


Well this worked for me last game don't see why it wouldn't this game. Coupled with voting records it should help a lot.

Name your 4 top suspects.

Mine are (in no order) :

Mich - for reason above

Lab- pretty quick to jump onto Jpap after a day 1 night fall, also says Noods is her 1st choice but voted Jpap.

Noods- seems preoccupied, she tied Lab with Agi but it was still early. I still don't like that a large part of her reason for the vote was because she fooled us last game.

Zaffy- posts look like he was setting up Jpap because he knew Agi was going to come back innocent.

 

[Lab_Rat]

There is more evidence for me being mafia, but you feel more for Noods being mafia, but you vote me for being mafia, but Noods is your #1 suspect for mafia...

I didn't bait Agass. He was acting scummy and I voted for him. His logic didn't add up.

Sure looked like baiting but I agree he was acting scummy and squirmy. I have no idea why he wouldn't fight, even come out as detective. My vote is not set in stone but I still feel comfortable keeping on you for now.

I do.

Why is noods a stronger scum person feeling thing for you? Any reason other than gut?

Noods has been no where near as vocal as she was when I played with her in the Christmas game (where she had a good guy role). Mafia tends to lay low, at least often they do. When I was mafia I surely laid as low as I could. She admitted she's acting odd, even chastised me for bringing it up. Keeps blaming Stephen King for something... If you're asking if there is something I can point to to say "Noods is mafia, I'm absolutely sure of it" then no, there isn't. There is more pointing towards jpappy evidence wise, as I said prior.

The game Ice is playing is quite interesting. Would he have hit Kash? She's been the one questioning him. That could also be a mafia frame up...look at who is pointing at Ice, take them out, make it look like Ice put the hit on Kash. I don't know how to read that situation. Ice was rather quick to jump onto Agassizii for lynching.

 

[jpappy789]

Alright...

Lab- naming a #1 suspect but voting another.

Ice- I'm still suspicious of what motivated the call for protection

Michwol- the very late vote switch for no reason

DD- subtle point to me for going after Agass

 

[rich311k]

Pap - either he made a mistake or he was after Ag. I dont think Ag would have been a target for a trap, he was not a strong threat.

Rat - could not wait to get on pap.

Ice - same as everyone else, cant figure what he is doing.

Noods not sure about her. I will watch.

Not really a list just some thoughts. I need to read this with a little attention. I have been bouncing around on other matters. My nephew is a volunteer in Haiti and I was helping his mother get stuff together to send him.

 

[ZSandmann]

I'm game, no order:

Mich: yes, a newbie, but asking an Innocent to die seems contradictory to common sense. Based on the way the last game went down no one gets a pass from me.

Noodles: Yeah she doesn't seem to have her head in the game, generally skimmy. I don't really get how the book would influence her play either.

JL: Nothing solid at all but he flew into the game like he had something to prove, definitely making waves with Lab and others.

Ice: Kash was on Ice pretty hard towards the end of Day 1. To Hit her draws attention but then we get into WIFOM of if he'd risk it and I could see Ice doing it.

 

[johnlarson66]

My top four suspects -

Lab-Rat: I have not liked any of the reasons given for their votes and I don't like the look this way but vote that way. Atempting to blame jpap for lynching Ag.

Dangerdoll: The late, just before nightfall vote on Ag. Pretty safe vote on a player that was leading the votes and then atempting to blame jpap for Ag getting lynched.

Noods: Not as much activity as I would expect from her. I don't understand the whole Steven King thing or the not drinking beer angle. I know that if she is mafia, she will crack. I get a weird feeling that she is agreeing with me to keep me off of her.

Ice: Not sure if I understand the new Ice. I go back and forth on how I feel about Ice. I did not like the pocket mafia or the plea to have the Doc protect them.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Lab-Rat: I have not liked any of the reasons given for their votes and I don't like the look this way but vote that way. Atempting to blame jpap for lynching Ag.

I'm not looking one way and voting another. I'm looking both ways, if I had two votes I'd give one to both jpap and Noods. And I'm not attempting to blame jpap for lynching the detective, I am blaming jpap for the results of this nights lynch. (Also blame Ag some as he should have defended himself or even revealed he was detective).

 

[jpappy789]

Glad to know I have such a profound effect on the game to convince six other players to vote for the same person.

 

[AnniesNotOK]

To all eliminated townies:

Each game night you may PM me with the name of a player who's role you'd like to know.

Remember, you may not make any in game posts, or talk about the game in other threads once you are dead, as per the rules.

If you wish to be a "Ghost Detective", it is expected that you WILL NOT make any post, in this thread or any other, which could affect live gameplay.

This is only to keep things fun for the dead.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Glad to know I have such a profound effect on the game to convince six other players to vote for the same person.

Actually I just looked back...while I think you baited him, you weren't the first to vote for him (in fact you were fourth) and he did react weird to all your probing. Ice was the first to actually vote for Ag.