Ps... no matter what you say, someone will make you look suspicious. That's half the fun of the game. :nilly:
Mafia 62- The Play
- Thread starter AnniesNotOK
- Start date
Any thought JB on who you think it would connect her back to?
Totally understood...remember I'm not the one who keeps bringing it up...I'm not the one saying I would have come out if I was det but I don't think Ag should have. That's Ice...and i think he's scum so I'm pointing it out. Isn't that what I'm supposed to be doing?
I haven't said Ag should have come out. I never brought that up at all. I'm saying and have said from the start I don't think anyone would have believed him. I never said I'd come out either, I said I might but I have more pull the Ag and might be more believable. I also said with the timing of the votes it wouldn't have made a difference either way. Even if Ag could have convinced 3 or 4 players to pop off him if the Dr didn't believe him or wasn't around then the mafia could just switch hits to him. I think you're trying to make this a lot more then what it is.
I'll give you a pass on this statement because you're new. But go back and search the past 5 or 6 games. Just go to the last pages of each game and look at the breakdowns of nightly actions. I never make it past day 2, this time I figured I'd try to make the mafia wonder about hitting me instead of just taking a hit.
DAY TWO
Jpap-0- Lab(#231)
Lab-6- JL(#243), Jpap(#252), Noods(#257), Ice(#310), ZS(#322), Noods(#327), Razz(#330)
Ice-2- Dawg(#320), Mich(#392)
ZS-1- Zaffy(#350)
Noods-2- Lab(#365), JB(#369)
No vote from DD, and Rich
NIGHTFALL IN NINE HOURS TWENTY MINUTES
PM'S AS REQUIRED
Jpap-0- Lab(#231)
Lab-6- JL(#243), Jpap(#252), Noods(#257), Ice(#310), ZS(#322), Noods(#327), Razz(#330)
Ice-2- Dawg(#320), Mich(#392)
ZS-1- Zaffy(#350)
Noods-2- Lab(#365), JB(#369)
No vote from DD, and Rich
NIGHTFALL IN NINE HOURS TWENTY MINUTES
PM'S AS REQUIRED
The more of Labs posts I read the more she looks less scummy. That may just be a good player tricking me but I almost want to switch my vote........ Now who looks more scummy?
Labrat
I think are innocent, I think are mafia, I can't tell yet
Dawg - I don't see anything scummy about Dawg. They seem to be helping the town.
DD - Hasn't been around much so I cannot lean her either way as of now.
Ice - Seems very different. It may just him being tired of being killed early or it may be a way for him to keep the town from lynching a mafia player.
JB - I can't tell for sure but there is just something about him that makes me think he is a mafia player. Mostly a gut feeling
JL - Seems pro-town but with what everyone else is saying I can't decide if I should take him completly off my list of suspects.
Jpap - Very pro-town, and very helpful so far.
Labrat - The more I read what she has said the less I think she is mafia. Again, she may be pulling the wool over my eyes so I am leaning mafia but not quite. (She would be my 4th pick for mafia.)
Mich - Hasn't voted, hasn't put anything out there for us to go on and I son't know why. It worries me that he may be trying to stay off the radar with his lack of posting.
Noodles - I don't understand why people think she is mafia. Unless I missed something I don't see the case against her.
Razz - I know my role.
Rich - Again is a low poster and is only putting things out there that can't be built on.
Zaffy - Good player but I don't know their playing habits so I can't go either way.
Zsand - A good player but he just isn't sitting right with me. I can't put my finger on it but they just seem like they are playing a game from the mafia side.
HTH
Labrat
I think are innocent, I think are mafia, I can't tell yet
Dawg - I don't see anything scummy about Dawg. They seem to be helping the town.
DD - Hasn't been around much so I cannot lean her either way as of now.
Ice - Seems very different. It may just him being tired of being killed early or it may be a way for him to keep the town from lynching a mafia player.
JB - I can't tell for sure but there is just something about him that makes me think he is a mafia player. Mostly a gut feeling
JL - Seems pro-town but with what everyone else is saying I can't decide if I should take him completly off my list of suspects.
Jpap - Very pro-town, and very helpful so far.
Labrat - The more I read what she has said the less I think she is mafia. Again, she may be pulling the wool over my eyes so I am leaning mafia but not quite. (She would be my 4th pick for mafia.)
Mich - Hasn't voted, hasn't put anything out there for us to go on and I son't know why. It worries me that he may be trying to stay off the radar with his lack of posting.
Noodles - I don't understand why people think she is mafia. Unless I missed something I don't see the case against her.
Razz - I know my role.
Rich - Again is a low poster and is only putting things out there that can't be built on.
Zaffy - Good player but I don't know their playing habits so I can't go either way.
Zsand - A good player but he just isn't sitting right with me. I can't put my finger on it but they just seem like they are playing a game from the mafia side.
HTH
I just have a couple minutes between chores, but I have been thinking about Labby. .....I just cant shake the feeling that all she has really done is make a lot of posts that are nothing more then self preservation pleas instead of trying to build cases against others............part of me feels like deja vu ~ the way Luvbugz painted her self into a corner and just kept digging the hole deeper, and more times then not she was innocent.... The scum feeling is still stronger so my vote stands for now. Rich would be where my vote would move, if I should move at all.........
Glad to see Mich pop in. I hope he votes before nightfall. Will be interesting to see where DD and Rich place their votes.
Glad to see Mich pop in. I hope he votes before nightfall. Will be interesting to see where DD and Rich place their votes.
I hate second guessing myself! My suspisions have had Labby at the top of the list all along and I need to stick to with my instincts.
I have spent the time since the past nightfall defending myself. That is a very true observation as I have been repeatedly raked over the coals. The heat is all on me and I have tried to explain why I posted what i posted previously.
Go back and read before the first nightfall. I was doing my best to kick bushes and find scum. The unfortunate result of me sharing my thoughts and suspicions with the town was twofold; not only did I come across as scummy to many of you, but it also seems I inadvertantly muddied the waters. Not wanting to increase confusion for my fellow townies I am now not throwing my every suspicion out there.
That being said, I'm not going to do what the mafia hopes...I'm not going to roll, I will continue to defend myself. Hence all of the recent defensive posts. Unfortunately, due to irl obligations, I will miss the couple hours prior to nightfall tonight. Do not mistake that for me giving up. If anyone wants to know anything from me, please ask now. I should have time to post again around 3pm est but that is likely about it.
Helps me immensely.
I also garner from this that Z, Rich and I are your top suspects?
JB isn't colored,whats that mean?
He voted like an hour before you posted.
I want to thank you both.I was on the fence this morning about keeping my vote on Lab. I think she is being sincere but I didn't want to be rash and just jump. I've had her and Noods as suspects thinking one of the 2 is mafia. Then Noods post about the train coming her way really swayed me to think she was saying this as a preventive measure to make other innocents not want to move to her. Then the posts above sealed the deal for me.
I retract my vote on Lab and vote to lynch Noodles
My suspect list is now:
Noods
Razz
Dawg/Jpap ( but more because Razz has them listed as innocent)
Of Dawg/Jpap I'd only suspect 1 of the 2 is actually mafia. IMO it would be Jpap over Dawg. I feel that they are hoping that Dawgs posts against me will sway me to look his way when Razz shows mafia.
