mafia 63- Who is Who

Madcrawdad said:
...

I'm proposing that the town selects and lynches a player who has historically been generally unhelpful (ie, lack of effort/lurking, little original thought, etc.) to the town, even when they've been town-aligned.

....
Click to expand...

So Mad, who are your top (or I guess bottom) historically generally unhelpful players?

There is a term I was taught years ago, to each their reach. Also, most sucessfull things in life need team work. A football team can't have 11 quaterbacks.
 
jpappy789 said:
At the very least you're getting rid of people who aren't known for contributing, which makes it harder to figure out their role.

I see issues with the idea, and it's not perfect...but it's good enough for day 1 that I wouldn't find it scummy if anyone resorts to it...
Click to expand...

I agree, Pappy. Don't think there's anything sinister behind Mad's motives... don't think he's scummy at all for suggesting it.
 
Hmmm i retract my vote from mad
 
Rbishop said:
hmmm...I don't like any body.....

I vote to lynch....

Jpap
Rich
BettaFishMommy (BFM)
Zaffy
Agi
Mad
JB
Lab
JL
Kash
Fishfriend ( FF)
TRS
Annie
Razz
The Wiz
Click to expand...

Okay, here's a shot in the dark.

I vote to lynch Rbishop.

First.. it's consistent with Mad's plan (for what that's worth) because Rb isn't all that helpful most of the time. So he's a lurker, normally. Also, while I don't think Mad's approach gets us very far, there's no harm cooperating with it either. Jpappy brought up a good point that it's the lurkers we have the most trouble pinning down later in these games.... so I don't mind losing a few random lurkers here and there while we're biding our time.

Second.. Rb wants to killl everyone else but himself -- all at the same time. Wow, Bob... that's one way to speed things up! Not necessarily a scum move, but it's good enough to draw a random vote from me.

Subject to change...
 
u no what I vote to lynch Riboship just in case i cant show by tomorrow.
 
johnlarson66 said:
So Mad, who are your top (or I guess bottom) historically generally unhelpful players?

There is a term I was taught years ago, to each their reach. Also, most sucessfull things in life need team work. A football team can't have 11 quaterbacks.
Click to expand...

I'd really like to know as well. I see where he's coming from, but I don't think it's an effective strategy for this game. No more effective than regular day 1 crazyness at least. imo, This game is about finding associations between players. Those low contributors will align themselves as the game goes on.

I'll give him credit at least that it's a method to place a vote on day 1 at least. It's trying, which is better than enumerating the letters in someones name and calling them scum because it adds up to a prime number.
 
8) Game ends when one of the team bosses is killed.
Click to expand...

This begs the question, what if the mayor is a lurker?

I don't know if it's a good idea to start fishing for mafia near the bottom of the list anymore. For all we know the mayor could be trying to avoid attention. We may catch some mafia in the process but I'd rather not lose the game because of it.

I vote to lynch fishfriend

The vote on Mad, then the retraction, then the quick vote on Rb right after Kash...seems rather fishy to me. I normally don't like voting newbs this early but with a 50/50 chance I don't think there is any problem in doing so...
 
jpappy789 said:
This begs the question, what if the mayor is a lurker?

I vote to lynch fishfriend

The vote on Mad, then the retraction, then the quick vote on Rb right after Kash...seems rather fishy to me. I normally don't like voting newbs this early but with a 50/50 chance I don't think there is any problem in doing so...
Click to expand...

Thats called being confused lol
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom