Mafia #64 ? Cabin Fever - The Play

[johnlarson66]

I'm gonna skim again and see if my results are similar.

I think everyone should post a list of remaining players and rank them 1-10.

When I have been evil and had to do this at the request of the innocents, it was hard.

Why don't you start with your own list? I am guessing it will be hard for you.

 

[johnlarson66]

I vote to lynch AnniesNoOk.

Several reasons, the list of three names with no reasons at all - no words even - just 3 names. Then there is the suspect Kash, vote Ice post, then there is the asking for everyone to do a ranked list, when they can't even give explanations on their own suspects.

I think it might be little early for ranked lists. The only other real strong suspect I have is the wiz, he seems to be blending in and just mirroring Kash, I would like to see some original input. Maybe post something Kash has not.

 

[Fishfriend1]

Read earlier posts plz.



Gee thanks... I think that Tex is an accomplice and the madman is useing him to confuse us, or as a target, as for me, well i kinda killed myself i think, what with the mwa mwa mwaaa that everyone seems to think was an evil laugh. One last time, for clarification, an evil laugh is mwahahaha not mwa mwa mwaaa. I hope you can see the diff.

DD - Is quite a savvy player who often gets killed easily the first day. As she disagreed with my/our suspicion against Lab Rat, I'm prepared to drop her as one of my top suspects.. for the present time. The position DD took opposing Lab Rat's banishment seems/feels sincere in retrospect and outweighs the case I believed I had against her over her reaction to my posts.

You have to understand that all the bad guys can communicate and know who is who, so they can safely vote for us without fear, also that they can easily vote for one of themselves to remove suspicion from the rest. I think that DD may have voted for someone other then lab because she knew lab was an innocent, witch would take her off the radar. the same can be said for anyone who didn't vote for lab.

Dag - As a noob to our game, he's hard for us to read. Combine that with his relation to Lab Rat makes this even more difficult. Don't know what his actual game experience is but he seems to be pretty smart, based on the posts he's made. I'm not going to assume though that he's communicating offline with Lab Rat (as JL has suggested a number of times about me and Wizard).

Dag seems safe to me, but that itself makes him worrying.

Annie - Was a suspect of mine because he's virtually inactive in this game.. and his similar position to Dag and Zaffy where Lab Rat was concerned. Someone who might rather volunteer for an accomplice role so he'd have someone to communicate with.

Im not a good judge of his character, being here for a short time and all, ill just have to trust u.

Wizard - JL keeps suggesting that Wizard was following my lead this time and he's hinted that we're working together outside the game. Whatever role Wizard has this time, I have no idea. I know the man well in everyday life but Wizard is also very smart and he understands this game very well. I expect he'll be quite good at this on his own... but I've not played with him or against him in this game setting enough that I can read him yet.

Hmmm worrying that Kashta dismisses him so fast. I think that he was definitely following you Kashta, you voted for Lab, and he voted for Lab almost immediately after.

Rich - Better than just about anyone at lying low and staying under the radar in this game. That makes him a very good choice either as the madman or someone the madman might have recruited.

Definitely good at hiding, did you notice that he voted ice and ice voted him? maybe a madman/accomplice thing here.

FF - Seems to be all over the place and his nonsensical posting resurfaced as soon as nightfall was over. This doesn't reassure any of us about him being pro-town in any way. FF seems (again) to crave our attention more than anything else and I don't believe he actually cares which team wins. The scum side is communicating this time (FF was non-communicating evil in his last game). If he's evil, I don't see that his teammates would sit by watching him post the comments he made tonight, so it's really anyone's guess which team FF is on.

I will skip over the nonsensical part now. Im just no good at hiding so i say "why try, it'll just make me look bad". I do care which team wins, preferably mine, even if i need to ud to kill someone i think is a bad guy. This will totally get u to think im evil, but maybe the evils want me to be a target so they dont die, that would be my strategy if i was evil. Get rid of an idiot who everyone thinks is evil, and then there is one less good guy out there.

Tex - Has made something of a spoiler of himself, posting disparaging remarks. Definitely not a pro-town person and he probably isn't taking this game seriously. This seems to be a joke to him or something he's joined to pass the time. As an evil, he's playing a laughable game so I don't see him volunteering for the role or being chosen by the madman.

Also add that he still hasnt answered my question of whether he has played or not, seems anti town to do that. Also note that he has said some scummy things that may just be the newb coming out. My head says he is a newb and and my gut says an newbi bad guy.

Razz - Totally non-productive in the game, whether he's innocent or evil. Not much use speculating about him, at this point.

True, but htta itself may make him evil, if he is hiding under the radar then he is not helping the town and may even be evil. We should watch him.


All in all i think ill keep my vote on tex, he seems a safe vote for now.

I hope that helps a little.

 

[Fishfriend1]

mine in bold

 

[rich311k]

I hope that helps a little.

I did not vote for Ice and he did not vote for me.

 

[Kashta]

Fish, you have some serious logic problems. (Breaking up FF's screwy post into sections.)

Read earlier posts plz.

Gee thanks... I think that Tex is an accomplice and the madman is useing him to confuse us, or as a target, as for me, well i kinda killed myself i think, what with the mwa mwa mwaaa that everyone seems to think was an evil laugh. One last time, for clarification, an evil laugh is mwahahaha not mwa mwa mwaaa. I hope you can see the diff.

No kidding. Ya think? :headshake2:

DD - <snipped>

You have to understand that all the bad guys can communicate and know who is who, so they can safely vote for us without fear, also that they can easily vote for one of themselves to remove suspicion from the rest. I think that DD may have voted for someone other then lab because she knew lab was an innocent, witch would take her off the radar. the same can be said for anyone who didn't vote for lab.

That makes no sense, Fish. If DD knew Lab was innocent, DD has to be evil. None of the innocents on Day 1 know anybody else's role. Only the evil team knows who all the innocents are.

Dag - <snipped>

Dag seems safe to me, but that itself makes him worrying.

Okay.

Annie - <snipped>

Im not a good judge of his character, being here for a short time and all, ill just have to trust u.

This is also a pointless remark, Fish. You should not trust anyone. Do your own thinking, make your own judgements, and vote who YOU think is your best suspect.

Wizard - <snipped>

Hmmm worrying that Kashta dismisses him so fast. I think that he was definitely following you Kashta, you voted for Lab, and he voted for Lab almost immediately after.

Fish, Wizard and I were reading the thread, pulling quotes, and writing our posts at the same time (on different computers). That means we read the same posts at the same point in time while we were both here.

While I was browsing the thread, I saw Wizard's post where he said he thought Lab Rat was suspicious.. or he was thinking of voting her.. whatever.... just before I finished my post. I had just pulled the quotes I intended to include in my post and I voted her at the same time. In my mind, there was no reason for me to wait and think it over first. Lab Rat was a solid Day 1 vote based on her being so jittery and defensive. That was a heck of a lot better than picking someone randomly because Lab was already acting scummy.

Right after my post hit the thread, I saw Wizard had also posted a similar vote against Lab Rat right behind me (time-wise). His vote on Lab Rat didn't surprise me in any way... he'd already said he was considering the vote and he obviously made the same judgement about her that I'd made after reading the same information.

Go back and look at the posts we both made. Wizard's posts and mine were overlapping during that period of time. You really need to think things through and look beyond the tip of your own nose.

Rich - <snipped>

Definitely good at hiding, did you notice that he voted ice and ice voted him? maybe a madman/accomplice thing here.

This is completely wrong, Fish. Go back and re-check who voted whom.

FF - <snipped>

I will skip over the nonsensical part now. Im just no good at hiding so i say "why try, it'll just make me look bad". I do care which team wins, preferably mine, even if i need to ud to kill someone i think is a bad guy. This will totally get u to think im evil, but maybe the evils want me to be a target so they dont die, that would be my strategy if i was evil. Get rid of an idiot who everyone thinks is evil, and then there is one less good guy out there.

Uggh.. okay.

Tex - <snipped>

Also add that he still hasnt answered my question of whether he has played or not, seems anti town to do that. Also note that he has said some scummy things that may just be the newb coming out. My head says he is a newb and and my gut says an newbi bad guy.

Okay.

Razz - <snipped>

True, but htta itself may make him evil, if he is hiding under the radar then he is not helping the town and may even be evil. We should watch him.

This same argument is true for a lot of people.

All in all i think ill keep my vote on tex, he seems a safe vote for now.

A safe vote, Fish? Why, because you think it may keep you alive longer in the game? That's pure scummy reasoning trying to save yourself instead of helping the town.... even if that leads to your death.

 

[Fishfriend1]

Fish, you have some serious logic problems. (Breaking up FF's screwy post into sections.)



No kidding. Ya think? :headshake2:



That makes no sense, Fish. If DD knew Lab was innocent, DD has to be evil. None of the innocents on Day 1 know anybody else's role. Only the evil team knows who all the innocents are.



Okay.



This is also a pointless remark, Fish. You should not trust anyone. Do your own thinking, make your own judgements, and vote who YOU think is your best suspect.



Fish, Wizard and I were reading the thread, pulling quotes, and writing our posts at the same time (on different computers). That means we read the same posts at the same point in time while we were both here.

While I was browsing the thread, I saw Wizard's post where he said he thought Lab Rat was suspicious.. or he was thinking of voting her.. whatever.... just before I finished my post. I had just pulled the quotes I intended to include in my post and I voted her at the same time. In my mind, there was no reason for me to wait and think it over first. Lab Rat was a solid Day 1 vote based on her being so jittery and defensive. That was a heck of a lot better than picking someone randomly because Lab was already acting scummy.

Right after my post hit the thread, I saw Wizard had also posted a similar vote against Lab Rat right behind me (time-wise). His vote on Lab Rat didn't surprise me in any way... he'd already said he was considering the vote and he obviously made the same judgement about her that I'd made after reading the same information.

Go back and look at the posts we both made. Wizard's posts and mine were overlapping during that period of time. You really need to think things through and look beyond the tip of your own nose.



This is completely wrong, Fish. Go back and re-check who voted whom.



Uggh.. okay.



Okay.



This same argument is true for a lot of people.



A safe vote, Fish? Why, because you think it may keep you alive longer in the game? That's pure scummy reasoning trying to save yourself instead of helping the town.... even if that leads to your death.

I think she may. Fine All i can remember is that Ice voted for the person that voted her. I cant remember who, but i think i may have been... um... Zaffy?
A save vote because i think he is scum. I am not trying to save myself, just the town. I cant wait till im voted out, you will all be so shocked he he he...:nutkick:

 

[Fishfriend1]

im going to listen to some music and re-think my logic...

 

[AnniesNotOK]

I believed you were wrong, Annie. And like any other player in the game, I posted the best contribution I could find based on how people acted in the game. Lab Rat acted like scum, so I voted her. Zaffy appeared to be defending Lab Rat, so I suspected him for that reason. As far as who else votes for whom, that's their call to make as much as my vote was mine.

If you believe I'm scum, Annie, then vote to banish me. I find it rather scummy on your part, however, for you to make such a case against me with these posts now only to turn away and vote Ice instead.

Yes, I'm sure you do find that rather scummy indeed. I'd have no trouble voting for you at this point. I believe you, Ice and the Wiz are all scumbags, with Razz tossed in there for good measure.

Is Ice the Madman? Methinks he is. Just a feeling.

I don't have time to go thru and make a list but I will tonight.

Just because someone didn't vote Lab isn't going to take them off the suspect list. One of the reasons I suspected Zaffy so much was because of the fact that when I'm scum and there are a lot of votes on an innocent I try to get players off of them so it looks like I'm in the best interest of the town.

Annie- why bring a case against Kash for leading the charge then vote me? Isn't that backassward and a scum tell? Just sayin'

Yes, it does seem a little scummy. I wonder how many will use that as their excuse to vote for me.

Shenanniegans (TM)

hmmm... Annie, did you mean to vote for Kash? It is not making much sense where you had so much to say about her, yet you spit off a couple sentences on Ice and vote him.... I am not getting the logic. What is making Ice more suspicious to you than Kash?

No, I meant to vote for Ice. I was trying to be a drama queen. I suspect Kash and Ice fairly equally at this point, but something in my gut says Ice may be in charge of the scumbags. I would change my vote to Kash or Wiz.

Why don't you start with your own list? I am guessing it will be hard for you.

I'll show you mine if you show me yours.

1= innocent 10= scumbag

Annie- 1
Dag- 5
Rich- 5
Dawg- 5
DD- 5
JL- 6
Texas-7
Razz- 7
FF- 7
Kash-8
Ice- 8
Wiz- 8

Not hard at all really.

I vote to lynch AnniesNoOk.

Several reasons, the list of three names with no reasons at all - no words even - just 3 names. Then there is the suspect Kash, vote Ice post, then there is the asking for everyone to do a ranked list, when they can't even give explanations on their own suspects.

I think it might be little early for ranked lists. The only other real strong suspect I have is the wiz, he seems to be blending in and just mirroring Kash, I would like to see some original input. Maybe post something Kash has not.

I think you mean you vote to banish me John, but I hope you'll reconsider.

What are your thoughts on the players on my suspect list?

im going to listen to some music and re-think my logic...

Sounds like a good idea FF. Know what would be good right now? If you posted your notes like you did last game. Some of those posts really cracked me up man.

 

[johnlarson66]

I vote to banish AnniesNotOk

Thanks for the heads up, I can't see reconsidering at this point. Your list is a joke. You should have said you were going to rank players 5 thru 8.