Mafia #67 - 50/50 -- The Play

[Lab_Rat]

Its not always only innocents that build cases on Day 1. Thats the most BS thing ever said in mafia.

Really I haven't dug? I've asked plenty of questions of players. I haven't had to dig far to find my number 1 suspect ...you're right out in the open. Are you saying you want me to build a fake case against someone?

You want a suspect list?

Lab
Jpap
Dag
Mad

maybe DD for voting alongside you even after posting against you.Possibly JL for his BS vote.

Awesome, your list is opposite of my list. :thumbsup: Further solidifies in my mind that you are indeed scummy.

 

[IceH2O]

Lab, so you do see where FF could be innocent?

Ice, do you see where FF gets twisted in his own thoughts?

FF, you really need to present some sort of list. Leaning mafia, leaning innocent. You are no longer a noob.

FF is twisted period.

 

[IceH2O]

Yes, I see that FF could be innocent. If he is, I am sorry that I made a case against him, though I think it's served the purpose of bringing the scum out of the woodwork to protect him. I truly believed his posts to be scummy when I saw them, and his responses in my mind got scummier and scummier. Story kept changing. Not something I'd expect of someone telling the truth. Hopefully he is scum and gets lynched tonight. If he shows innocent I know it's my head next since scum will hold everything I've said against him against me.

Now why would mafia come out to protect an innocent?


Why would only mafia be after you for lynching an innocent?

 

[Lab_Rat]

FF is twisted period.

And since he's twisted he can't be scummy so we should ignore every twisted thing he posts...that's your reasoning, right? Worked out really well for the town last game.

 

[Dagamoth]

A worthless vote. How can you think Dag is mafia and not think Lab is? Are Lab and FF both innocent and you don't want any part of it?
I can't believe no one has even pulled this post...so caught up in the FF/Lab situation we are over looking posts now?

actually i think the vote on me was actually a vote on FF but cautious vote in the instance that FF is the SB. But I could be wrong.

 

[johnlarson66]

A worthless vote. How can you think Dag is mafia and not think Lab is? Are Lab and FF both innocent and you don't want any part of it?
I can't believe no one has even pulled this post...so caught up in the FF/Lab situation we are over looking posts now?

Yes, it is a worthless vote, but Dag is my top suspect.

I see Lab as very vocal and at this point I think she thinks she is helping. I think she is very narrow minded and feels she has caught FF. She is unable to let go of it. I don't think she would be this vocal on day one and be mafia. Dag has not been vocal and has had very little input. His vote on FF for revenge from last game is of little use.

I think this could be very well two innocents going at it. The problem is that FF is hard to defend, he is his own worst enemy. I gave two examples where he has contradicted himself. The silly role claim was the last straw.

Given the options, I would rather have Lab around than FF. Even if innocent, FF causes enough khaos to help the mafia.

 

[Dagamoth]

I am just curious as to the people who are defending FF saying that he is just being FF, what happens if FF shows non com mafia? Are you going to say that someone picking on what he posted seemed scummier then actually posting scummy things and that is why you voted for LR?

 

[Lab_Rat]

Now why would mafia come out to protect an innocent?


Why would only mafia be after you for lynching an innocent?

Mafia would protect him because you think he's one of your own. For the same reasons I've made a case against him, his posts were just plain scummy. Not to mention the fact that IF he shows innocent, you can totally turn it on me and get another innocent lynched. Win/win for you scumballs.

It's been made pretty clear that the popular thought is this whole case against FF has been due to my actions (even though that is BS). Wiz went so far as to call it mine. So I'd expect to be on the chopping block if he shows innocent for some ungodly reason. Not only mafia will be after me, I'd expect some townies would be too, thinking my arguments were scummy. I'm not blind you know...is this an "Ice-trap"?

 

[Dagamoth]

Yes, it is a worthless vote, but Dag is my top suspect.

I see Lab as very vocal and at this point I think she thinks she is helping. I think she is very narrow minded and feels she has caught FF. She is unable to let go of it. I don't think she would be this vocal on day one and be mafia. Dag has not been vocal and has had very little input. His vote on FF for revenge from last game is of little use.

I think this could be very well two innocents going at it. The problem is that FF is hard to defend, he is his own worst enemy. I gave two examples where he has contradicted himself. The silly role claim was the last straw.

Given the options, I would rather have Lab around than FF. Even if innocent, FF causes enough khaos to help the mafia.

I could have sworn I was pretty clear when I said that yes when I first voted for FF it was a revenge vote but it has since after reading what FF has posted it has become a vote for scum. I believe I have said that twice now (it might even be 3 times I have just lost track) after you keep saying that it is just a revenge vote.

Please read what you said already JL :

So Dag's vote on FF is no longer a random revenge vote...

 

[johnlarson66]

Lab, you are unwilling to take credit for grilling FF and getting him to slip? Who else should get credit? Dag? DD?