Mafia #67 - 50/50 -- The Play

[Lab_Rat]

Labby, you keep using this phrase "pro town", but you were the driving force behind lynching an innocent. Even after several people tried to point out to you the flaw in your interpretation, you kept at it. Was that terribly pro town?

FF asking scum to investigate him for the good of the town seemed too far fetched for even me to believe. So I figured it was scum trying to save a teammate. I don't trust you guys, why should I believe some fantastic story about why FF would post scummy sounding things?

So JB, if FF had been mafia, how would keeping him around have been pro-town? That was your reason for not wanting to lynch him...

 

[jbradt]

FF asking scum to investigate him for the good of the town seemed too far fetched for even me to believe. So I figured it was scum trying to save a teammate. I don't trust you guys, why should I believe some fantastic story about why FF would post scummy sounding things?

So JB, if FF had been mafia, how would keeping him around have been pro-town? That was your reason for not wanting to lynch him...

it wouldn't have been. thanks for pointing out the flaw in my logic (that i've already admitted to several times) yet again.

 

[Lab_Rat]

it wouldn't have been. thanks for pointing out the flaw in my logic (that i've already admitted to several times) yet again.

No problem! :thumbsup: Actually, it's that flaw in your logic that makes me think you're scummy above everyone else. It's why my vote is on you at this point.

 

[jbradt]

If that's what you've got, then have at it.

 

[Lab_Rat]

If that's what you've got, then have at it.

I will, at least until I find something scummier.

So JB, who are your top candidates for scum?

 

[the wizard]

Obviously you could not see that I was telling the truth. I'll admit, when an idea gets in my head sometimes I run with it too far. I thought I was doing what was best for the town. If I were scum I'd have come up with some elaborate fiasco instead of kicking around FF and his scummy seeming posts.

I call :bs:

We see this from you every game. First you launch your agenda, then you close your mind to any other possibilities.

After you get an innocent lynched you say you shouldn't have looked so scummy still keeping as your suspect list the players that didn't agree with you.

Then you go into the poor innocent me routine.

I don't buy it. :headshake2:

 

[the wizard]

I need to go run some boxes to the garage but will be back to see if anything else catches my attention.

Before I do I need to ask one question.

Noodles, are you ever going to reply to the numerous comments about your posting so far? I too would like to hear what you have to say in response.

 

[jbradt]

I will, at least until I find something scummier.

So JB, who are your top candidates for scum?

Still working that out.

 

[Lab_Rat]

I call :bs:

We see this from you every game. First you launch your agenda, then you close your mind to any other possibilities.

After you get an innocent lynched you say you shouldn't have looked so scummy still keeping as your suspect list the players that didn't agree with you.

Then you go into the poor innocent me routine.

I don't buy it. :headshake2:

Because I can't help myself I have to answer this one last post even though I'm already in bed...

Wiz, if that's not the pot calling the kettle black then idk what is. Do you forget how narrowminded and sure of yourself you were last game that I was scum? I did everything I could to try and tell the SC I was an IW without breaking the no RC rule. The scum team got my message as did the farmers. Somehow the SC totally missed it. So I don't think you have much ground to criticize me about being narrowminded. I freely admit that I can get swept up in my theories, it doesn't make me scummy.

And how many times, when I cry that I'm innocent am I actually innocent? I think you'll find it's a vast majority. Again, I'm trying not to default to that, but after a while of getting kicked around like a soccer ball in a world cup match it's where I tend to go when innocent. When I'm scum I simply slide back into the shadows, much easier and safer that way.

 

[the wizard]

Because I can't help myself I have to answer this one last post even though I'm already in bed...

Wiz, if that's not the pot calling the kettle black then idk what is. Do you forget how narrowminded and sure of yourself you were last game that I was scum? I did everything I could to try and tell the SC I was an IW without breaking the no RC rule. The scum team got my message as did the farmers. Somehow the SC totally missed it. So I don't think you have much ground to criticize me about being narrowminded. I freely admit that I can get swept up in my theories, it doesn't make me scummy.

And how many times, when I cry that I'm innocent am I actually innocent? I think you'll find it's a vast majority. Again, I'm trying not to default to that, but after a while of getting kicked around like a soccer ball in a world cup match it's where I tend to go when innocent. When I'm scum I simply slide back into the shadows, much easier and safer that way.

There you go again, reading into a post what you want others to see in an attempt to make yourself look good.

I remember full well that I was close minded to you being innocent last game. That was because your day 1 posting was not very pro town. I said it then and will repeat it here, speculating on townie prs in the game thread is not pro town.

I didn't see any pro town in your posts in this game either. you conveniently overlook the over abundant times that the posts were pulled showing you exactly where you twisted FFs posts to railroad him.

Read the entire post Labby I am not criticizing you for being narrow minded,
I am saying you are the little boy who cried wolf. We all know how that story ended.

As for you crying innocent, I would expect that from you. You do it every game.

I am not FF, you are not going to twist my words and get me flustered as you did him.

I will post rationally and coherently and answer your questions.