I see what you're saying here, Pappy; but the way that I look at it is that if there was that much energy behind posting for this game, then the posting would have been there anyway. However we could have directed it toward other things. Things that IMO could have been more productive than the NOTHING that we got from the way it actually turned out. Again, if you gained some grand nugget of wisdom from FF's lynch, then by all means; please share it.
All of this, however is speculation at best..
Agreed, it's speculation which is why I do not like why you have been implying it since yesterday...saying that we would know something more today by lynching anyone other than FF isn't something you can prove which is why the argument is moot.
That's a fair question so I'll answer it... for the same reason Ice is looking at Labby. You bolded the phrase "if the mafia investigate me" and left out the following phrase: they will vote for me. That totally changes the meaning of the whole post.
Then when you say it was for dramatic effect... I've learned from my clients that people who are being dramatic purposely are trying to sell you something. I'm seeing a lot of that going on this game, and not just from you...
I bolded the entire statement and anyone can read it.
I'm well aware that people check quotes in context when they're posted. People like you, Ice, Kash, Mad, etc. are great at double checking for word twisting and such.
Doing so in this case in no way changed the interpretation of the post. Please read it and tell me that at the point FF posted it he did not insist that his post was not directed at Lab but at all the mafia. You can't because his intention was clear.
I admit I went overboard in attempt to poke fun at Wiz's extreme use of red and bold. Haha.
Btw, would you like some girl scout cookies?
Pappy, at the time I made the comments they made sense to me. I still stand by my statement that we could have learned more from nearly any other lynch candidate, and possibly saved an innocent. If you've never come up with an idea that you wish you hadn't put out there, go ahead and put your vote down.
My point was you obviously don't stand by the statement that scum-FF would be a help to the town if kept around. The whole lynching anyone else argument is beside the point.
There was no guilt trip either Lab, there was sarcasm intended but I suppose it didn't translate well to type. You stating I haven't done anything "pro town" didn't actually hurt my feelings. Maybe that "guilt trip" you claim to have been on is an exaggeration as well, like the rest of that post.
Lab, in life I have found people exaggerate about things for one of two reasons:
#1: To make that thing look better.
#2: To make that thing look worse.
Why exactly are you employing such tactics?
I'm going to need a double dose of that prozac Doc.
Really. Did most of what work for me Pap? I have been quite clear I did not vote for FF as a result of anything you, Lab, or anyone else posted about him. FF was the author of his own demise.
I take full ownership of my vote for FF. I voted for FF as a result of the posts FF made before and after Lab started beating on him. They were scummy posts. I did not vote FF to end the discussions of FF. I voted for FF to kill a scumbag.
Are you asking me why I didnt jump in and start beating on FF too? Lab was already doing a fine job of that. And you, to a lesser extent. Are you implying that by choosing to watch the chaos instead of add more I'm scummy and opportunistic? If so, why aren't you voting for me now? Are you waiting till someone else latches on first. If you have a case to build I suggest you go pull the quotes and post it. Otherwise, get off my lawn.
I didnt question the players defending FF because I did not know FF's alignment. Does this make any sense to you?
I started the game with the least amount of information available Paps, just like the other vanilla townies (or NCI's in this case...that's right I said it...Darn, innocent again...) so I felt I had said enough at that point until I gained more information.
You want me to build a case on you?
Already did. I admit, there's not much to go on and I didn't pull quotes but I can put numbers with my summaries if you would like. You've done a good job of hiding in the shadows.
You say you kept out of the discussion to not add to the confusion. I say if it were so clear to you how the line was drawn then it shouldn't have mattered, if you were town. You didn't have to go after FF since you had plenty of other "suspects" to go after apparently. Pretty much ignored them too. NCM also start out with no information...what do you say to that?
Lab and I go after FF and others. You sit back and let us take the heat while you just keep claiming that you thought FF was scum in your crosshairs over and over.
Thank you for pretty much daring me to vote for you...can't pass
that up...
I vote to lynch Annie
I don't care if anyone latches on. I already suspect you and I've made it clear that I do.
Oh yeah, that's right, I'm thinking you are scummy. Now I don't like the fact that your suspect list is similar to mine, don't like that one bit. Did you just copy my suspects to try and align yourself with me? And the whole picking on the fact that I use the term "when I show innocent", that's been done before in this thread too. That's nothing original there Annie. But your reaction to what I posted was way off base, that's some original content. Seriously, the whole guilt trip thing, then couple it with a compliment (yeah, hefty may have been an exaggeration), that's not something a townie feels the need to do.
