Mafia #67 - 50/50 -- The Play

[jpappy789]

Yes please :thumbsup:

I didn't know we were considering hypotheticals here...if you had been right then the situation would have been different. It would also depend on whether Lab was CM or NCM. Either way I wouldn't have ruled you out as scum. I'm sure someone would have questioned it, but probably not to the extent that we have now.

If we're also on the topic of stubbornness could you give us names of who you suspect? God forbid you're asked another question and actually have to post again...right now it just looks like you want to c

I need to stop hitting reply so soon.

Ignore the last part. I was going to comment on Rich wanting to crawl back to the scum den and hide but whatever...

 

[jpappy789]

What questions have I not answered?

It's not that...you just seem increasingly annoyed or agitated. I can't read feelings through a computed screen though

 

[jpappy789]

I am not sure if you are voting for him or not, but why not retract and be the last one on him then.

I do not think much has made sense in this game so far. The CI let one of their own get lynched and the CM hit one of their own. So why should rich start making sense now.

Heck my votes haven't made much sense either. I had JB as a suspect and then shifted. I was pretty sure that Dag was the mafia trying to buddy up to Lab, looks like that was annie. I need to review a few more things.

Just because I don't think it's probable doesn't mean I'm not going to risk it...:grinno:

 

[rich311k]

It's not that...you just seem increasingly annoyed or agitated. I can't read feelings through a computed screen though

Fair enough. I am just saying I voted who I thought was the scummiest of the two contenders. i was wrong, could be that I would have been wrong in either direction. Why is that an impossible scenario?

As for who I suspect, right now if had to vote it would be Dag.

 

[jpappy789]

Fair enough. I am just saying I voted who I thought was the scummiest of the two contenders. i was wrong, could be that I would have been wrong in either direction. Why is that an impossible scenario?

As for who I suspect, right now if had to vote it would be Dag.

I've never said it's impossible. But looking at my suspect list and I see JB as one of the top people and you up there as well...then I see you flip flop late and "save" him...it doesn't look like two innocents to me.

 

[the wizard]

A list.

Top things i would like to happen this year.
1. Mets win the world series. (Not likely)
2. Grandchild. (Probably not this year but soon)
3. get a few pictures published. (We shall see)

As for suspects. I will skip FF.

1. Lab rat
2. Noods when she is in complete shut down mode she is hiding.
3. Do not really have a firm third. I have some thoughts.

JL always worries me.
Pap seems to have an agenda. Have not really heard much from DD.
No real read on the rest yet, we shall see.

Here You said that when Noods is in shut down mode (as she has been this game) she is hiding.

Fair enough. I am just saying I voted who I thought was the scummiest of the two contenders. i was wrong, could be that I would have been wrong in either direction. Why is that an impossible scenario?

As for who I suspect, right now if had to vote it would be Dag.

So why would you vote Dag if you had to vote now?

Have you seen Noods helping the town?

 

[jpappy789]

To be fair I believe that is a D1 list. We've seen rich "change his mind" plenty of time between then and now.

 

[the wizard]

To be fair I believe that is a D1 list. We've seen rich "change his mind" plenty of time between then and now.

That is a good point, I just hadn't seen any reasons from Rich to suspect Dag but remembered seeing comment about Noods.

 

[Kashta]

I've dug up a few quotes I'd like to ask about.

Well info was gleaned to at least one person possibly a whole communicating side. I think it's probably safe to assume that an innocent was given the extra vote since it appears that Annie was hit by the mafia. I don't think it would be very likely that the communicating mafia would hit someone who was voting along side them. There is however the slight chance that another non com mafia for JB trying to save LR. I really don't know if it will matter though because tank may end up just UDing this time around. (if he does UD does his vote get doubled again before death?)

Lots of colors there, Dag. I'm glad I saw this again because I wasn't able to follow your thinking the first time around.

#1. (Blue) - FF's posting was real good at polarizing this crowd. Some voted against him, others didn't. The next day was similar. Some voted the lead person pushing FF so hard (Labby) while others voted the person who stuck his neck out farthest in opposition to his lynch (JB).

Questions: Today now, looking back at how this happened and how it turned out..... You don't think there was a mix of townie and mafia votes against JB for lynching? Do you really think the split was mafia-minded on one side in FF's lynch with townie-minded players on the other? And that lead to mostly the same people still at odds the next day, so also mafia voting one way and townies voting the other when it was JB vs. Lab Rat slated to die?

#2. (Green) - Really? When half the town votes one way and half the town votes the other in what amounts to a two-horse race, how would anyone be able to avoid voting alongside someone on their opposing team? We do that all the time in these games whether we want to or not.

#3. (Purple) - Sorry, Dag. Could you restate what you're trying to say there? I've read those lines a few times and still can't figure out what you meant by this.

 

[jbradt]

I'm going to comment on Pappy's post, but I wanted to keep the context... plus I just really love this exchange...

Pretty sure everyone in the game has an agenda Rich...mine's to get rid of mafia :thumbsup:

You on the other hand haven't exactly been voting for top suspects...

How is that going for you?

I see the lynched mafia corpses are pile all over the place.

Voted for one that turned out to be mafia.

Just have to point out here Paps, that the odds are nearly 100% that this would be the case by chance... but keep pinning it to your shield as defense for your voting record.

JB, want to pitch us on how keeping Rich around even if he is mafia is good for the town. It might work this time! New and Improved Pocket Mafia.

What are your thoughts on rich and noods?

JL... nope. I'm done trying to pitch you guys anything for this game. God forbid that I should put an idea out there before I've thought it all the way through. God forbid even further that I should try to defend someone I thought was innocent. Ice commented earlier that these games are damned if you do, damned if you don't. So I'm choosing don't this time. You can feel confident that I''m reading along when I can, and I'll post a little when I feel like it. That's just the approach I'm taking to this particular game. Read what you want into that... you will anyway.

Rich... funny as hell. I'm all for keeping him around just for that reason. Apparently ACville has no sense of humor either... Plus, once again I don't like the train at all. Go ahead, Dag... have at that one! :nutkick:

Noods... haven't seen enough to really get a read.


My vote will be staying where it is.

Here You said that when Noods is in shut down mode (as she has been this game) she is hiding.



So why would you vote Dag if you had to vote now?

Have you seen Noods helping the town?

Come on now, Wiz. Let's be honest with each other. The only ones who have done anything pro-town so far are the mafia team. :laugh: And the CMs at that. :thumbsup: Thanks, scum! And good job townies!!! :clap::clap::clap: