Wizard, you watched the same nightfall as everyone else. While I agree with your concerns about Noodles.... what are your thoughts about Rich and his last-second vote switch?
Mafia #67 - 50/50 -- The Play
- Thread starter dirtydawg10
- Start date
Wizard, you watched the same nightfall as everyone else. While I agree with your concerns about Noodles.... what are your thoughts about Rich and his last-second vote switch?
This post didn't make sense to me the first time through. I took this to mean earlier that Pappy was trying to direct votes onto Rich by minimizing the risk of getting blown up -- if you're the last 2 on. (Sorry about that BTW, I'm just real skeptical about everyone right now.) But.... I think now I get it now and realized it's a good point.
Without reading some ulterior motive into the statement, it makes more sense to me: If Rich was the SB and he has no preference which team/players die because it's all the same to him in that role... then why would he care which one died between Lab Rat and JB? He wouldn't, as it would have no positive or negative effect on his game.
Just one more for now.
JL - You retracted your vote on Rich and didn't put it back. Where do you intend to place your vote?
JL - You retracted your vote on Rich and didn't put it back. Where do you intend to place your vote?
Okay. One more post then, as I've just seen this.
In that red part, JB, I think you're being totally unfair. Many of us are really trying to sort it all out.
If you've got something to say, just say it. You're up against the exact same odds in this game as everyone else.
In that red part, JB, I think you're being totally unfair. Many of us are really trying to sort it all out.
If you've got something to say, just say it. You're up against the exact same odds in this game as everyone else.
I appreciate the feedback, Kash. Honestly. If I'm being unfair, I appologize. But I've said what I have to say for the moment.
Okay. As already pointed out, scum is simply a label for one of the two equal teams playing the game, right? So with scum in the lead, can you explain how they 'know they are on the ropes'?
You're acting like this game is simply a matter of identifying scum and taking them down 1 at a time.... A little bit harder with scum having the advantage, isn't it?
I have already posted my thoughts about the last minute vote switch, but for you skimmers, I will post them again.
I have stated that I haven't been able to get much of a read on most people this game. Therefore, I need to kick my own bushes.
I asked Noods a couple of questions that she has not answered to my satisfaction.
I like to vote for my top suspect when placing my vote. How many times have we seen someone grilled for not doing so?
I see you have followed the pack with your vote Kashta, but thats ok.
Keep digging, it appears like you are kicking bushes and trying to be helpful to the town.
I'm sorry JB, but that just isn't good enough in this game.
The whole idea, unless I have been mistaken about these games altogether, is to post your thoughts and questions.
Then we all have something to go on and can form our opinions and post them.
To choose not to, isn't any better than Noodles coming in for her "fabric softener" posts then leaving again.
I was starting to think you had the towns best interests at heart, but, to shut down when everyone is just bickering back and forth about semantics isn't helping.
Only brought that up because Rich wanted to comment on how my votes went. Voting records in these 50/50 games mean nearly nothing with certain people communicating and others not.
And I disagree it was by chance. I picked up on someone I thought was scummy and voted...ooops, using it to my defense again...darn, innocent...
We possibly have 2 mafia to be lynched over the next 2 days plus CI hits. How are they not on the ropes?
Using your argument why then would Rich switch to Lab and out himself and JB? If JB was mafia then Rich may as well let JB die and stay out of the limelight.
You can't have it both ways Mad. Either you think Rich saved JB because they are both mafia or JB is innocent and Rich is setting him up for the next lynch. Third option, Rich is SB or innocent and took out who he thought was mafia of the 2 at the time.
