Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[the wizard]

Wiz, I may have missed something, but can you explain where you came up with 50/50 chance of lynching an innocent?

Also, which question are you waiting for a response to? You don't need to repeat the question, but if you could just point me to your original post, I'd greatly appreciate it.

The question itself wasn't important, more of a dig at him anyway. the important thing is that as he has been doing this whole game is that he sidesteps questions.

He sidestepped many of Kashta's questions yesterday by responding with questions.

However, for your own curiosity, I pulled my original post and posted it below.

You really expect us to believe that you wouldn't have Kashta hit when she posted enough coherent thoughts and questions that you deemed it necessary to side step and avoid them?

 

[Lady G]

Yes, I know, and like I said, Wiz is going to make a huge deal out of me saying that, but I wasn't going to not give my reason. It's a darned if you do, darned if you don't situation. And since I'm more convinced he's scummy than innocent I felt ok putting it out there. What would you have done in my situation?

Well, I wouldn't of put a name out there period as to who I would of hit. Your weren't asked (from what I remember) so why mention it, you had to know you would be asked why. By bringing it up yourself, you put it out there to be questioned.

 

[Lady G]

Sorry, I haven't had much of a chance to check this until now. I admit my vote earlier looked like a safe vote when I voted JL. However, I still think he looks like he's trying to work people up to get them into trouble, and I am more convinced of it after FF proved to be innocent.

at this point, I'm still going to keep my vote on JL

I VOTE TO LYNCH JOHN L

I think that he's stepped back a bit to not have the attention back on him.


ILM I'm not sure what to think of as HE hasn't posted much in here (I have to agree with ice, if people aren't going to play there needs to be a game mechanic to remove the person)

I'm not sure what to make of ice, when he finds someone, he really goes after them, I'm not sure to look at that as a scummy trait or as someone is is very enthusiastic.

I agree, lab rat is looking pretty bad right now, I have my suspicions, but more of her posts last night strike me more as frustration and fatigue, I'm still watching though....

JRR- well he posts like a hit man, not really saying much, and placing a vote....

My view of Bio, I get the impression she's not really comfortable with game play, so she's making wording mistakes. She could still be scum, but for now in my opinion she's trying to figure out how she fits in

I agree those who sign up should play...but would you be kicked out of the game if that was a rule, you really haven't posted much either. Yes, Annie and Mollies have posted less, but for you to say something about others not posting is kinda funny to me.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

LG, mollies hasnt posted a single thing relevant to the game other than a hit n run vote on ff...quite a bit different than what cap and annie have done imo.

 

[the wizard]

Yes, I know, and like I said, Wiz is going to make a huge deal out of me saying that, but I wasn't going to not give my reason. It's a darned if you do, darned if you don't situation. And since I'm more convinced he's scummy than innocent I felt ok putting it out there. What would you have done in my situation?

Labby, I am pretty busy going through my notes and evaluating my suspect list.

In light of your RL happenings the past 2 days, I opened the monopoly game and withdrew a get out of jail free card for you on this one.

 

[Lady G]

LG, mollies hasnt posted a single thing relevant to the game other than a hit n run vote on ff...quite a bit different than what cap and annie have done imo.

Yes, I know and I agree.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Your life sounds even crazier then mine...sorry to hear about your grandpa, hope he continues to do better.

(Labby - first, sorry for your RL issues. Hope everything will be ok.)

In light of your RL happenings the past 2 days, I opened the monopoly game and withdrew a get out of jail free card for you on this one.

g/o Thanks guys, fortunately I think things are going to be ok with him, at least in the immediate future. g/o

Wiz, if you truly think I'm scummiest, then vote for me. That's fair, that's how the game is, you gotta vote for who you think is scummiest.

 

[captaincaveman9]

I agree those who sign up should play...but would you be kicked out of the game if that was a rule, you really haven't posted much either. Yes, Annie and Mollies have posted less, but for you to say something about others not posting is kinda funny to me.

I posted more yesterday than today for sure, but I'm still trying to contribute to the game.....

 

[the wizard]

Still working on my suspect list but at this point it is difficult without knowing exactly how many scum there are.

That said, it seems that usually we have 4 or 5.

Going conservative for my numbers I am going to go with 4 as a base figure for my list.

I am considering the comments about ILM and I have to say, The last game we played with ILM, his posting habit was identical to this game.

I seem to remember him being scum.

So I will, for the time being drop Bio from my most suspect list to make room for ILM.

 

[the wizard]

g/o Thanks guys, fortunately I think things are going to be ok with him, at least in the immediate future. g/o

Wiz, if you truly think I'm scummiest, then vote for me. That's fair, that's how the game is, you gotta vote for who you think is scummiest.

you are still on my list but at present I see JL as scummier.