Mafia 72-Vampires game thread

Come on Noodles.....two vampires and one Dracula is THREE.

ok, I can see that I guess; altho Dracula is a vamp and on the vamp team. Just the way I read it.
 
Mr. Palmer walks though a town divided against itself. All this distrust, in only 1 1/2 days! Those vamps are doing a real good job of confusing us. He has placed his lot with Kashta, and voted against Ice, but still he worries. The town is talking in spurts and bursts, but not everyone is talking. Mr. Palmer decides to look into those who aren't talking much, because if the vamps aren't talking then the town is not looking in the right direction...

Basically, i think we should look at who hasn't been talking much today. I will be doing so presently.
 
What happened was people voted who they thought was evil off very limited information. So the whole we might of hit a vamp doesn't apply. However the death of username does apply.

I'm going to answer this just because I was a voter on DD. I think the vote that actually happened last night benefits the vampires much more just for the fact there is one less townie around and that puts them 1 step closer to taking over the town. If you had to choose between two people who was going to die, would you 1) shoot the man with terminal cancer or 2) shoot the person next to the guy with terminal cancer (but he MIGHT be a bad guy)?

For me, I would shoot the guy with cancer, he was going to die anyway and the guy next to him could of just said the wrong thing at the wrong time. Hence why I voted for DD because user_name the guy standing next to terminal cancer didn't seem to be all that evil to me.

I find your idea and your analogy somewhat flawed. Even on limited information we could have hit a vamp so to say with certainty that "the whole we might have hit a vamp doesn't apply" either shows a somewhat dangerous reliance on assumption or a disrespect for the intelligence of the town.

As for your terminal cancer patient, I had a friend with terminal cancer. The doctors called in his family as he was not going to make it through the night. He not only made it through the night but when into full remission. He lived 10 years cancer free, saw his kids graduate high school, get married, and give him grandchildren. He died last fall but he lived a lot in those 10 years, so no I wouldn't be shooting the guy with cancer.
 
People who posted and why:

-Kashta(offence)
-Ice(defense)
-Fishfriend1(everything possible)
-Wiz (
-Dag(in defence mostly)
-JB (semi-offensive, against Ice)
-Noods(defensive)
-Chill(RP, checking possible vamp numbers and wasting out time!)
-Lady G(Defensive, offensive)
-Judgemax(recently, just a little bit)
-JM1212(offensive, some defnece)
-2H(only recently, and only to argue)
-Rich(only after i accused him of not being helpful, and he was all defensive)


This is just in my opinion, feel free to clarify and corrct points i have gotten wrong. If you want to correct/clarify something you need reasoning to back up the correction/clarification.
 
I think I'm semi-offended.
 
People who posted and why:

-Kashta(offence)
-Ice(defense)
-Fishfriend1(everything possible)
-Wiz (
-Dag(in defence mostly)
-JB (semi-offensive, against Ice)
-Noods(defensive)
-Chill(RP, checking possible vamp numbers and wasting out time!)
-Lady G(Defensive, offensive)
-Judgemax(recently, just a little bit)
-JM1212(offensive, some defnece)
-2H(only recently, and only to argue)
-Rich(only after i accused him of not being helpful, and he was all defensive)


This is just in my opinion, feel free to clarify and corrct points i have gotten wrong. If you want to correct/clarify something you need reasoning to back up the correction/clarification.

You go first with the good reasoning.
 
I'm still not sure how I feel about going with the two horse race tonight. I see the merit in it, but something still doesn't settle quite right. I'm glad we have time to look at it further. My vote will most likely fall with either Kash or Ice, but what I'm looking at ATM, and what I'm wondering about from others is if both Kash and Ice were taken out of the equation, who would you be looking at?

For me it would have to be Rich and 2H. Anyone else care to weigh in?
 
AquariaCentral.com