Mafia 73: Werewolf Game!

[Piranha86]

Hey guys. I might not have a lot of posting for a bit. There's some family stuff going on... I'll try to get on, but my vote stays with zaffy until further notice.

 

[rich311k]

All my ex-girlfriends say I'm emotionally constipated, so it's not likely.

I think you're Scummy McScumpants (JB stole that from me first) for believing Rich. His story is awful.

That is because it is not a story. I am sorry it was not up to your standards.

 

[jbradt]

Another note, where is Rocker? Haven't really seen him since he lynched himself.

That's an interesting question. Someone throw a milk-bone down the street and see if he comes out!

 

[Zaffy]

Zaffy and Pappy pull the same quote and both respond to it in a similar tone.





Okay, so they were on the thread at the same time and saw/responded to the same post. By itself, that isn't anything, I know.

Then here, Zaffy goes on to jump on Pappy in response to JB... but for what? Because Pappy agrees with what Zaffy's been saying too?



You know, guys. You're both sounding like dual cross-examiners here. Don't get me wrong, you're both making good points about different people that I agree we should examine. But the two of you sound almost interchangeable and this tag team thing with alternating posts directed at whoever posted last is making my head spin.

After that, this post was directed to Chill from Zaffy.



And that was followed by this post to Rocker from Pappy.



However...... at this same time, both of you totally overlooked a direct question I posted earlier to all the experienced players. I posted that because I really want to know what others think.... including you.

@Pappy - How many werewolves do you think we should estimate there are in this game?

@Zaffy - How many werewolves do you think we should estimate there are in this game?

And, again... I'm not directing that question only to Pappy and Zaffy. I'd also like some input about this from Chill, Dag, Lab Rat, Lady G, Rich, and Wizard. (And yes, I'll repeat that again to each of you, if you don't respond to this.)

I think in this game it's important for us to discuss numbers. We usually do that anyway very early in the game whenever it's a non-standard game format.

In this round we have 15 players. The town side has 3 non-communicating PRs and 3 townies who communicate but have no power. That's almost half the field. Then on the scum side, they get an opportunity to possibly turn people.

How does everyone figure we should factor that in to make a best guess at the number of werewolves we're dealing with?

I love this post more and more everyday.


Let's go through the time line.

post # 149 9:28am Kashta asks a question about # of wolves.
post # 151 11:26am Zaffy confronts JM about joke votes.
post # 152 11:31am Jpappy confronts JM about joke votes.
post # 153 11:41am Zaffy comments on Jpappys post.
post # 155 11:51am Zaffy asks Chill about LG's alignment.
post # 158 11:55am Jpappy responds to Rocker about an LG comment.

You guys may notice as I have that Jpappy actually follows me. Although the time stamps are close enough that it's possible we were forming ours posts at exactly the same time.

My question to everyone, is how did I know what jpap was going to post before he posted? how did I know to vote him early and keep my vote on him? are these things that are possible in this realm of existence?

I think Kashta is just sad that we apparently ignored her question to the vets. (which I later answered anyway)

 

[Chill]

Have anything to add yet Chill? I know you said you asked a question and was waiting for an answer. This is the only question I see, so is this what you are waiting for?
You also said you were going to reread, so any thoughts?

no not a lot of thoughts at this point. I reread Wiz's posts and there wasn't much to go on. At one point he mentions coming back to Rocker which he may or may not have done when he commented on him not helping. Rocker's self lynch worries me some.

There are likely more than 2 wolves so the current narrow focus bothers me some.

My problem is I think like me, I think what would I do, and that runs to some pretty wild scenarios. I'd sure like to know why Wiz? did he hit something we're not seeing? No disrespect to Wiz but if I was a wolf he wouldn't be my first target. Maybe cause the only game I played with him was the last one and by his own admission he really wasn't into it.

 

[Zaffy]

I've been doing a lot of reading here. Zaffy is being very wishy washy about everything. Makes me feel pretty good about my vote on him.

The idea is to quote posts which support your claim. You can use the [ QUOTE ] button at the bottom of a post to do it. Show me the wishy washy!

I'm sure others want to see it too.

 

[Lady G]

Another note, where is Rocker? Haven't really seen him since he lynched himself.

LMAO!!! Yeah, that was a great post huh!!!

 

[Zaffy]

Aww, poor Zaffy. I wasn't interested in debating this back and forth with you. Then Rich wouldn't play along either, would he? So maybe you can entice JM to go for it.... not a bad try, Zaff. Ya gotta come up with something to try turning the game back around, don't you? Good effort there, dude.





Of course, if all else fails you might as well turn on your own teammate at this point. Sacrificing Lab Rat as a lost cause to try saving yourself now is about all there's left for you to do. (Pity you didn't think of that earlier.... but then neither of you saw this coming.)

Leaving that up to JM to do all your digging for you, however? Gee, I don't see what prevents you from doing that yourself.... you have the paws for it.

You're a good player, Zaffy, and an intelligent one. No reason I can think of why you can't read this thread yourself, pull whatever posts you want, and make your own case.

You have done that before... plenty of times... when you were innocent.

I know as well as anyone that if I'm scum and it shows at night fall that my vote and reasons for it are to be taken with a huge grain of salt. I know I wouldn't be fooling anyone.

I'm not trying to have anyone do my digging for me, I can read perfectly well. I'm just trying to throw some accountability out there. People are making claims, and their not backing them up. I just want the back up.

Thanks for thinking I'm good at this game : )

 

[Taysius]

The idea is to quote posts which support your claim. You can use the [ QUOTE ] button at the bottom of a post to do it. Show me the wishy washy!

I'm sure others want to see it too.

Holy crap, I'm not a child, I know how to use a forum.

 

[Lady G]

no not a lot of thoughts at this point. I reread Wiz's posts and there wasn't much to go on. At one point he mentions coming back to Rocker which he may or may not have done when he commented on him not helping. Rocker's self lynch worries me some.

There are likely more than 2 wolves so the current narrow focus bothers me some.

My problem is I think like me, I think what would I do, and that runs to some pretty wild scenarios. I'd sure like to know why Wiz? did he hit something we're not seeing? No disrespect to Wiz but if I was a wolf he wouldn't be my first target. Maybe cause the only game I played with him was the last one and by his own admission he really wasn't into it.

Well, I imagine there are more then two...I doubt very much FF would only add two wolves. So anyone spark your interest?
I agree Rocker is very suspicious and pretty much just a distraction.