Mafia 73: Werewolf Game!

[jm1212]

Ok JM, now I agree User has posted lost of things that send up red flags, and he is one that just wont go away in my mind...but you are kinda doing the calling the kettle black thing here. You say he would be in the lead for voting innocents, aren't you the only one who was on innocents both nights?
As far as JB saying he trusted Kash, how does that factor in for you? Zaff was innocent also and thought she was evil. They are both good players, so how can you believe one and not think about what the other said? The fact JB stated it right before nightfall and was the hit actually makes me wonder a bit more.

As j said before, I trust JB's judgement, because perhaps he knew something that we dont

 

[jm1212]

What were you talking about JM????? I never voted for an innocent???
mg:

oh, and I agree with you LG that you can't just point out one theory a player had and ignore the other....

And you're just funneling someone else's ideas again.

 

[Lab_Rat]

As j said before, I trust JB's judgement, because perhaps he knew something that we dont

He seemed pretty happy with the race between Zaffy and me. I wouldn't say JB's judgment was better than Zaffy's in this case at all.

 

[user_name]

:iagree: you havn't really provided real input since the beggining, and back then you were one of the top posters....

talking about rocker, meant to quote him

 

[jm1212]

As j said before, I trust JB's judgement, because perhaps he knew something that we dont

should be 'as I said'

 

[user_name]

And you're just funneling someone else's ideas again.

and your just trying to divert the blame away from yourself again. How about trying to make a legitamate case against other players and try to help the town???

 

[Chill]

as for why JB that's a hard one
If LR is innocent then why would the wolves take someone doing their job for them?
If LR is guilty it sure looks bad that he was hit so it could be a setup, or it could be worth the risk to get rid of him especially since the town would probably buy the set up theory.
On the other hand if Kash is guilty then it doesn't appear to make sense to take out an innocent who's doing her dirty work, but she would know she was going to look bad today, and taking out JB sets up LR and muddies the water.

I think this was a tough calls for the wolves as FF was still looking for PM's 5 minutes before nightfall.

 

[Lady G]

G I think the world of you as well, but I'm more then fine with you having a hard look at me we can't afford to be losing two innocents a night, everybody should be scrutinized - as for the shave bring your razor sounds - like fun to me

LOL, sure it could be

And you're just funneling someone else's ideas again.

That may be true, but the fact remains...you were misleading saying he would lead in voting innocents, when in fact you have been on an innocent both nightfalls.

 

[Chill]

As j said before, I trust JB's judgement, because perhaps he knew something that we dont

so you're talking PR's now too?

 

[Lady G]

as for why JB that's a hard one
If LR is innocent then why would the wolves take someone doing their job for them?
If LR is guilty it sure looks bad that he was hit so it could be a setup, or it could be worth the risk to get rid of him especially since the town would probably buy the set up theory.
On the other hand if Kash is guilty then it doesn't appear to make sense to take out an innocent who's doing her dirty work, but she would know she was going to look bad today, and taking out JB sets up LR and muddies the water.

I think this was a tough calls for the wolves as FF was still looking for PM's 5 minutes before nightfall.

I can sooo see them taking someone doing their dirty work in a case like this. 1) it "sets up" another innocent, 2)if they are not looking at you at the time and are a good player...doesn't look like you would be the one taking them. Giving you an advantage of taking out someone who most likely will get to you eventually. Much better to take them before they start on ya.