Mafia #74...ACville Penitentiary!

user_name said:
two hobbies has played before, he was in the vampire one. (numer 73 i think?)

Your right, there isn't really anyone else scummy in my mind yet. I just got home, and have family stuff tonight, but I'll try to skim through right now....
Click to expand...
Yes, he played before, and he played well. But that kind of slip is a noobish slip, especially if they've never played as scum before. Plus, I consider players noobs until they get a couple of games under their belt...except for Tay, she is no noob anymore.

jm1212 said:
I am really not liking your 'suspect lists' on day one. right now, we have no idea who is a snitch and who isnt, and you're already giving us lists of people that you seem to be sure are innocent. not liking that one bit, nor your vote on Zaffy.
Click to expand...

Um, he voted Ballyhoo, not Zaffy...
 
Lab_Rat said:
I would guess 4 for the snitches. That's just under 25% with 17 players, and standard mafia games it's 25% scum. There is no turn option this game either. 3 seems like too few, 5 would be a lot of scum.
Click to expand...

:iagree: although there could always be less or more if LG wanted to mix things up.
 
user_name said:
I agree, it seems like you are automatically clearing people on day 1.
I also don't like that you have such a clear cut list, was that sent to you from the wardens office?
I vote to lynch/shank piranhaha
Click to expand...


I am confused, who is he clearing? Just want to make sure I'm not missing something here...
 
Lab_Rat said:
Yes, he played before, and he played well. But that kind of slip is a noobish slip, especially if they've never played as scum before. Plus, I consider players noobs until they get a couple of games under their belt...except for Tay, she is no noob anymore.



Um, he voted Ballyhoo, not Zaffy...
Click to expand...

yeah i meant Ballyhoo and meant to correct it but you got to it first.
 
user_name said:
:iagree: although there could always be less or more if LG wanted to mix things up.
Click to expand...

Of course there could always be more, but standard mafia format is 25%. Last game was on the low side, with only 20% scum. That may have been due to FF's mathematics skills.
 
jm1212 said:
but there were only 3 last game. granted there was some type of "turn," but only if the alpha would have survived and everyone else died.
Click to expand...

I know, but you also have to take who the mod is into account. FF even admitted he didn't try to figure out 25% of 15. I think LG would have taken more care to make sure the game is balanced. She even mentioned wanting to give the CIs some extra powers over the original game to make sure it was balanced.

Not that the exact numbers matter, I think if we focus on finding 3-4 scum that is a good way to start. 5 seems too heavy in scum favor.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom