Mafia #75... Assassins in the Palace - The Play

[Lady G]

I believe he has but I am old and forgetful.

Ok, I was just kinda feeling bad for them if it was their first game...could you imagine THIS set up as your first OMG!

Feel free to disagree that's your perogative. I guess you would rather out another guard than vote this one out?

I would like to eliminate the assassin and User was just as good a candidate as anyone else with the exception of the King. Apparently 4 other people before me wanted to see User gone also. If no one has the balls to be the kill vote on someone this will be a long game. Feel free to vote for me for that if you like.

Hmmm, ok Dawg...you say this as if you KNOW who is a guard? IMO, there is only ONE person who would know that and that would be the assassin, because know one else knows anything except who the King is.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I still say Razz is not helping the palace, but Dawg's reasoning for the kill vote on UN doesn't quite sound right.

It's way too quiet in here...

Can you explain that to me Lab? What doesn't make sense?

 

[dirtydawg10]

Ok, I was just kinda feeling bad for them if it was their first game...could you imagine THIS set up as your first OMG!


Hmmm, ok Dawg...you say this as if you KNOW who is a guard? IMO, there is only ONE person who would know that and that would be the assassin, because know one else knows anything except who the King is.

G...you're not sure if User was a guard? I wrote this after JB told us what User was.

 

[Lady G]

G...you're not sure if User was a guard? I wrote this after JB told us what User was.

Yes, and it is slightly convenient you waited until then to answer/respond to the post, you sure seemed in a hurry to get in with things

 

[Fishfriend1]

Im confused, when did lady G say she wasn't sure if user was a guard or not after nightfall?

 

[Lady G]

Good points but it also points to a common Mafia occurance that those who talk the most are usually suspected the most. It is good that you are keeping your eyes open.




Very true. We also need to be careful not to put too many (if any) lists out there and be selective with our voting. Remember that the assassin knows what we all are just not who the king is. If we put all our votes out there and spread them around we are essentially making a list for the assassin of who is not the King.

I am going back to read the old game to see how we won that one. It would help if others did the same.

You pulled a post from the old game saying it was more what you were trying to say:
"The way I see it, we have the advantage here. We (the guards), all know who the king is. The fact that there is a vast majority of us means that the king is in no danger of being lynched. The only people the assassin can trick the rest of us into killing are guards. Since we all agreed to die for the king when we took the job, means that it doesn't matter if we get tricked, as long as we don't do something to give the king away: like never voting for him.


What I'm trying to say is appropriately placed votes and retractions for the king may actually be a clever way to help shield that person. I will not suspect anyone for voting for the king. "

These two posts actually look to say the opposite of each other IMO. You posted in YOUR post that we should not make lists, or mutli-votes (pretty much) because it would out the king. The post you pulled actually say's there SHOULD be votes on the king to "hide" them. So which is it YOU actually think Dawg?

 

[Lady G]

Im confused, when did lady G say she wasn't sure if user was a guard or not after nightfall?

I didn't, it was more a way for him to "dance" around answering IMO.

I vote to lynch Dawg

 

[Lady G]

Yes, and it is slightly convenient you waited until then to answer/respond to the post, you sure seemed in a hurry to get in with things

"IN" should be "ON"

 

[dirtydawg10]

Im confused, when did lady G say she wasn't sure if user was a guard or not after nightfall?

Here...let's see if you can follow this FF.

I made the following statement after knowing what User was because JB had already told us.

Feel free to disagree that's your perogative. I guess you would rather out another guard than vote this one out?

I would like to eliminate the assassin and User was just as good a candidate as anyone else with the exception of the King. Apparently 4 other people before me wanted to see User gone also. If no one has the balls to be the kill vote on someone this will be a long game. Feel free to vote for me for that if you like.

LG then says this...

Ok, I was just kinda feeling bad for them if it was their first game...could you imagine THIS set up as your first OMG!


Hmmm, ok Dawg...you say this as if you KNOW who is a guard? IMO, there is only ONE person who would know that and that would be the assassin, because know one else knows anything except who the King is.

Implying that I knew something the rest of you didn't. We all knew what User was at that point. Get it? LG was implying that she didn't know what User was but I did.

Yes, and it is slightly convenient you waited until then to answer/respond to the post, you sure seemed in a hurry to get in with things

Take a look G...JB was the next post after the post I responded to. In that next post we all found out what User was. Sorry I didn't answer during those 13min. or whatever it was between the 2 posts.

 

[Fishfriend1]

I didn't, it was more a way for him to "dance" around answering IMO.

I vote to lynch Dawg

Did you really warp her wording Dawg?

Thats sad. If you are a gaurd you shouldn't need to warp otherws wording to incriminate them, thats just scummy.