Mafia #75... Assassins in the Palace - The Play

[Lady G]

Thr guards job is to protect the King. The only way we can protect the King is by making the assassin unsure who the King is. We have to make the assassin believe there is a possibility we ourselves could be the King. If User can no longer do that he is useless as a guard and he could also possibly be the assassin. Would you rather eliminate someone who has not already been outed?

After 4 votes User was a done deal. He was guaranteed not to be the King at that point. If I was the assassin I would have wanted to keep User around and take out someone else so I would know who 2 people were. Now the assassin knows only one of us.

I have to agree with Tay about even if they are known to not be the king, they can still help.

You say if you were the assassin you would want to keep them around...I guess I don't get it, but why exactly would they want to keep a pretty much "known" guard around? The assassin knows ALL of us are guards, how can you say they only know one of us now?

 

[Taysius]

I'm not big on this logic, yes the person has value in that can contribute, (nevermind were talking about User who didn't even appear to be reading let alone contributing), but you have to weigh that value against the cost of jumping off to somebody else and outing another person. I don't think there's much choice but finishing off somebody who's one vote from death.

You guys are so hung up on the fact that it was User under the vote. By Dawg's logic it could be anyone with 4 votes.

I still think Dawg's up to something, but in order to learn more and hear more thoughts...

I retract my vote on Dawg

 

[rich311k]

I see the logic, If you have 4 votes you are a guard or the assassin. if you are the assassin let us find out, if you are a guard everyone knows that by then so you are eliminated by the assassin as a possible king. Making that person the best choice to lynch.

 

[Chill]

This is getting stupid. In my opinion you have misinterpreted LG or purposely tried to discredit her and now, between the 2 of you, you have blown it out of proportion. i will refrain from becoming any more mixed up in this for now.

I think that, of the two of them, Dawg has more to asnwer for.

i retract my vote.

I vote to lynch Dawg.

Wow that was a very short refrain - 4 whole minutes.

 

[Lady G]

You yourself said you didn't know what User was at the time of my post. Here's your quote...



At that point JB had already informed us as to what User was. Maybe this is just a misunderstanding of the timeline of when things occurred. I think you are the one with the timeline of posts being mixed up...not me. If it's me please show me so I can understand what you are trying to say.

WOW, now you are FLAT OUT twisting my words re-read Dawg....I said I DIDN"T IMPLY I DIDN"T KNOW WHAT HE WAS....how do you get I DIDN"T KNOW WHAT HE WAS???

 

[jbradt]

Current vote count:

Razz (2): Labby, Rich
Dawg (2): LG, FF

5 votes needed to lynch.

 

[Taysius]

Wow that was a very short refrain - 4 whole minutes.

That's like 4 years in FF time.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I have to agree with Tay about even if they are known to not be the king, they can still help.

You say if you were the assassin you would want to keep them around...I guess I don't get it, but why exactly would they want to keep a pretty much "known" guard around? The assassin knows ALL of us are guards, how can you say they only know one of us now?

The assassin does not know who the guards are or who the King is. Just that all of us are against them. If the assassin has a living player who they know is not the King they don't necessarily want to kill them. The assassin would rather have 7 players alive who they know are not the King. Then they know who the King is. The assassins role is to kill the King...not to kill the guards.

 

[Fishfriend1]

Wow that was a very short refrain - 4 whole minutes.

You know who i am right? I say something, and do the opposite without a care in the world. i am reliably unreliable ;D

 

[Lady G]

Nope, didn't IMPLY I didn't know what User was at that point. Just saying what it looks like to me :grinyes:

Here, let me repost my reply...where did I actually say I didn't know what he was.....unless of course you take of the first part of the post that goes with it? You are twisting pretty hard here.

Thought the guards were noble and will take one for the king not to out them, you sure are fighting pretty hard here