Mafia #76 Game Thread: Revenge of the Nerds

[Fishfriend1]

So you took what we all said and effectively questioned everyone in the game.

I tried to focus on noods.

Was that just a total OMGUS vote?

No, it was not a OMGUS vote. I think that noods has been unhelpful, and thats w2hy i voted her. Better then you, who voted someone because they want you too against your better judgment. Yea, and im the one who makes no snese.

That happens in every person's life, usually around age 13...

Not funny.

Is that all you people got out of it... maybe i should just quote one thing at a time and post it as such... never had problems that way. Feel free to vote me, but it'll cost you $20!

 

[Fishfriend1]

That happens in every person's life, usually around age 13...

and im 16 going on 17.

 

[jpappy789]

Jm, what do you mean by Lab "going against [her] conscience?" She lists 5 people and narrows it down to 3, then down to 1 with explanations for each.

Her post seems pretty straight forward to me...even though I don't really agree with the specific reasoning behind her vote.

 

[jm1212]

Jm, so far you've tried to go after a couple people (DD, Lab) and flubbed. Who do you actually suspect and why?

Most recently labby with her switch to g.
FF isn't acting himself either. I'm not getting the whole 'didn't want to get caught up and then disappear thing'
Ice, since he is always a suspect of mine.
Possibly Bally, since she was going after JB. Though I do think it would be convenient for the scum to try to frame her after hitting JB.

 

[jpappy789]

FF:

Putting quotes together from different people is fine, but the problem is you do that and put one comment underneath a post or reply to a joke or fluff post when you're trying to make a case on a specific person. It's long, hard to read, and really doesn't help to make a point.

 

[jm1212]

Jm, what do you mean by Lab "going against [her] conscience?" She lists 5 people and narrows it down to 3, then down to 1 with explanations for each.

Her post seems pretty straight forward to me...even though I don't really agree with the specific reasoning behind her vote.

Before, she seemed pretty set on ice. Now, she's letting LG draw her vote, just as labby said lady g was trying to do. This isn't something that is in the ordinary for labby IME. Her only real reason for voting lady g was her supposed drawing of labby's vote to herself.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Wait... So you are going to go against your conscience because someone else is 'trying' to draw your vote? Didn't you spend two days grilling me about that in a previous game when I was 'doing' the same thing?

Did you even read my reasons for voting LG? Right now, she seems scummiest to me. I am not voting against my conscience whatsoever. There has been no explanation as to why she wanted to draw my vote (which was a total joke) off of Ice. JM, sometimes I think you are not playing in the same game that I am.

 

[jm1212]

Did you even read my reasons for voting LG? Right now, she seems scummiest to me. I am not voting against my conscience whatsoever. There has been no explanation as to why she wanted to draw my vote (which was a total joke) off of Ice. JM, sometimes I think you are not playing in the same game that I am.

And what if your joke vote happened to be on scum, and she was trying to keep him alive? Others have said that she is known for defending scum and going after innocents without knowing.

 

[Lady G]

Reading up from last night and I see we had a bad nightfall. Really sucks to have a UD along with the other events. Sorry to see you guys go.



Right now, Lady G has caught my attention as she's being kind of finger pointy. Usually, G seems so kind and nice to me that I've never got an evil vibe from her.

First I have to make note of her vote on JB. An obvious place to hide your vote is on the hit. On the other hand, it could be too obvious. Who knows, but I figured I'd point it out.

This is where LG starts to raise my eyebrow.



This was to Labby, concerning her vote on Ice.



She really seems stuck on Labby's vote on Ice.



What's the big deal with it, G? A vote isn't exactly permanent.



Claiming that Chill was protecting by saying that geeks take up dares too? Wow, that's reaching out there, IMO.



Now more taunting about that dang vote. Seriously, what's the big deal?



I think you might be right, but not in the way you've intended to point it.

It's ok, I tend to raise the eye brow on many.
Yep, a vote on JB would be a good place to hide your vote if you knew he was going to be the hit..not that i was actually doing that but I do believe someone was.
As far as giving her a hard time for her vote...well, what can I say it was something post worthy at the time IMO.
As far as daring her to vote me...well, why not.
As far as Chill protecting her...well, she brought it up as a defense, so I called it out I spose.

Put simply, I made a mistake and misread pappy's post. Most of my vote was geared towards her vote on Bally, which seemed odd at the time. I can't change your minds, but that's all I'm going to say about it.

I do have a question for

I can accept that answer, but why did you take so long to answer it, that's what bothers me.

If you want to look at distraction votes for the hit check out LG's reason. My reason is at least backed up with evidence, hers is just a " why not " vote.....if anyone was trying to make a vote to cover up the hit I'd check this out, plus she was the one to point fingers at me.... Shes trying to get the school to take out another geek

LMAO, nice try there Bally

I VOTE TO LYNCH BALLY

I agree 100%.....but would add Lady G to the list....her background demands it of me.

:silly:

You're seriously calling LG's "dare" a real one? I am not sure of her motives though. I said my vote will be on whoever I feel is the scummiest. At this point it will be moving since I don't find Ice particularly scummy at this time. I will likely change it later tonight since my day will consist of a 12 hour drive tomorrow, with maybe getting to my destination by nightfall.



You're right, it would be odd if you hadn't asked.

By that statement it means I found LG's "dare" to vote her very odd. It was obvious my vote for you was a joke, and I just did it because you claimed you're too good to be voted off. I thought it was pretty clear it wasn't a serious vote. But then she comes along and tries to pull my vote off of you and onto herself. Why would she do this? Is it a way of trying to get votes off of you? Pinged my scum meter.

Why would I do it, guess it was a "in the moment" kinda thing.

FF just wondering....
you analyzed the crap out of what everyone else said. But only mentioned the most trivial thing out of what I said. Did I not say anything worth while or are you protecting who I was talking about?

And have you actually said anything this game, aside from your bad day??

In an effort to consolidate my suspect list, here goes...no particular order...

Jm- been posting nonsense all game. Misreading? Maybe, but IMO it's too blatant to ignore the misquoting going on. A protown player is going to double check the facts before trying to put a case out there on someone. A scum player could care less if it is true just so the person goes down...unless they get caught. I think that is why he flubbed again.

DD- I still stand by my D1 vote for the same reason. That post was a bunch of fluff and it's weird she has never said anything about skimming my posts. Instead she gets defensive and turns around on me saying there was other things I should have picked up on...yet she didn't either...she has also taken off on the Jm thing. I'm not saying that is scummy in of itself but possibly some distancing going on here.

FF- just read the last page and you'll see why. I do not buy the excuses he is throwing out about why he isn't posting.

Pat- he too has been all over the place but I still am not sure if its due to a jittery, scummy newb or an overly-excited, innocent newb. He's thrown a lot of names out there but it could just be getting a handle on the game for all I know. Warrants further watching.

LG- the whole thing with JB and Bally seemed illogical to me when you really think about it. Would an evil Bally really try to go after JB based on nothing but something from a past game? Jb didn't think so and I see his point. That doesn't mean I find her innocent, but the way LG jumped on him and then right away put it out there that the hit was from Bally really caught my eye. And then the whole sarcastic bickering with Lab over her joke vote on Ice. She seems a little more agitated than the normal LG.

Yes, Pap I could see her doing that.

Maybe I am more agitated this game.

I'm about to go to bed but I wanted to stop by here real quick first.

This FF thing, as most have noted, is whack. I feel like we've scared him into junk post overload now that we brought up how quiet he was. And the fact that he was on the site when he said he wouldn't be and avoided this thread sends a huge red flag. I'm not falling for any crap anymore. (thinking back to Bally's "i didn't realize I was invisible" a couple games back.)

This thing with JM is tiresome to me. It's like this in every game I have played. JM slips up in some way, gets himself and the town confused, gets flustered and ends up innocent anyways. I'm not saying he's innocent, because I don't know, but I have to think to myself that maybe he's just bad at proofreading? lol

Bally still makes me nervous but I'm getting pretty sleepy in my typing so that's all I'm going to say about her right now.

Lastly, LG, where are ya? I usually expect to see her by evening. I agree with what Pappy has mentioned about her as well as my own observations made earlier. As of right now, she is my strongest suspect in my gut.

I vote to lynch Lady G

:thumbsup:

How have you not seen anything scummy??? JM is making incorrect statements in several places. PP has said more than a few things to peak my interest, and seems to have retreated. Bally has said a couple of things that make her suspicious. LG tried to draw my vote off of Ice for some reason, not sure why.

Right now, I could vote for either FF, JM, or LG. I want to see more from PP and Bally before voting for either of them. Maybe FF was really at grandma's that whole time, and I know JM made many flubs as an innocent, but I still can't figure why in the world LG tried to draw my vote off of Ice and on to her.

I think I'll give LG what she wants...I retract my vote on Ice and vote to lynch LG. If LG shows jock then I will be voting and keeping my vote on Ice next.

Just can't resist that dare can ya

 

[Lab_Rat]

No, it was not a OMGUS vote. I think that noods has been unhelpful, and thats w2hy i voted her. Better then you, who voted someone because they want you too against your better judgment. Yea, and im the one who makes no snese.

You may make no snese, but I explained my vote for LG. Was not against my better judgment since she seems scummiest to me right now, though I would be fine putting my vote on you or JM as well.

Before, she seemed pretty set on ice. Now, she's letting LG draw her vote, just as labby said lady g was trying to do. This isn't something that is in the ordinary for labby IME. Her only real reason for voting lady g was her supposed drawing of labby's vote to herself.

Did you miss the whole part about that being a joke? Let me give you the cliff notes version: Ice said he was too good to be voted for, I said I wanted to vote for him just because he said that, he double dog dared me to, so I did after nightfall. I had said I was going to and I think most of the players realized it was a joke. What is very odd is that LG then attempted to get me to move my vote off of Ice. She has yet to explain her reasons for that. If LG was trying to get me to move off of her teammate (Ice), then if they're both scummy jocks I really don't care which one is taken out, as long as a jock goes. That would also be why I said if LG flips scum when lynched then Ice will get my vote (for real) next.